3 ms·
How does this help user privacy? Currently your open action is not not tracked via images, since they're disabled by default. With this, anyone can find out whe
by MichaelGG 13y ago
How does this help user privacy? Currently your open action is not not tracked via images, since they're disabled by default. With this, anyone can find out when you displayed their email. That seems rather crappy.
Nothing stops Gmail from doing the loading on their side (to hide UA, IP, etc.) but only when you ask for it.
What's Google's motivation for this? Do they do emails that need to be tracked? Are they doing this for themselves to avoid having to special-case their own emails?
Wouldn't it be better to work on a standardized way to embed images in email, so that recipients can get nicely-rendered emails without exposing themselves to action tracking?
- chmars 13y agoAt least for me, Gmail's image settings have never worked reliably. Maybe they just capitulated?
- RexRollman 13y agoReally? Image loading should be pretty easy to get right.
- tokenizerrr 13y agoThey work fine for me. There's two types of images, embedded images and external images. Embedded ones always got shown, and it's the external ones that are the issue.
- dangrossman 13y ago> What's Google's motivation for this? Possibly, to get you to use more of their advertising services, which is in-line with lots of their recent changes (like removing all organic shopping results in favor of paid listings, and adding e-mail ads to Gmail's promotion tab). Prior to this change, a dozen or so of Google's competitors offered e-mail remarketing. That's where you insert an image into your marketing mails to set a cookie in the recipient's browser when they open the mail, then you can later advertise to that person across the web. For example, you could show banners on the NY Times site advertising your Black Friday sales only to people that opened your Black Friday sale preview e-mail. With Google proxying images, regardless of cache/deduplication policy, only Google can sell e-mail remarketing to Gmail users now. They already sell web remarketing through AdWords/DoubleClick. That means companies advertising with Google's competitors will have to move money to Google.
- tokenizerrr 13y ago> Wouldn't it be better to work on a standardized way to embed images in email We have that already, it's part of MIME. The external images are used only for tracking, potential bandwidth savings, and incompetence.