8 ms·
FWIW, Google tried to avoid this scenario with 'snippets' which everyone was supposed to do every day. Basically you posted a snippet of what you were thinking
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
FWIW, Google tried to avoid this scenario with 'snippets' which everyone was supposed to do every day. Basically you posted a snippet of what you were thinking about / working on that day which gave folks evaluating you some idea of what was going on in your head at any given time. (note that snippets were world readable)
Unfortunately, when I was there, there wasn't a lot of protection from the conflict created by your snippets, so if you wrote "tried again to convince team X to let me fix their code, they brought up objection a, b, c. Still no clarity from them on what they really want." In your snippet it would make Team X look bad, and at some point it could come back to them that you were bitching about them in your snippets (even if you were doing what you were told to do) and then they would counter-attack in their snippets, and a little sub-surface adhominem would go on for a while. Moderating your snippets made you look non-productive. It was an epic failure in leadership.
- tensafefrogs 13y agoNo, Google uses the OKR (Objectives and Key Results) system to track performance. You set goals with measurable results, and you grade them every quarter. That way you aren't evaluated so much on when/how you work, but on what you accomplish. (I should also include a note here about how you are evaluated by your peers at Google, which has its own set of benefits and downsides, but OKRs are meant to be a somewhat objective measure of output)
- myko 13y agoI remember dealing with both OKRs and snippets at Google. Personally the snippets were very helpful just helping me keep track of myself. I never ran into the issues the GP did which do sound unfortunate :(
- munificent 13y agoEverything about your post is correct except the "No,". Googlers have both OKRs and snippets.
- jonahx 13y ago> Everything about your post is correct except the "No," My first thought when reading this was that I would have nodded in agreement 90% of the time no matter what the remaining content of the parent had been.
- tensafefrogs 13y agoThe "no" was directed at this statement, which I believe to be not very accurate: > Google tried to avoid this scenario with 'snippets' My point is that OKRs are meant to be used for tracking performance (such as what the article was talking about) and snippets are more for personal use or casually for information among teammates or other curious people who want to know what you work on.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoNot sure why you're getting voted down (your comment has gone grey as I type this). I don't recall the OKR system being there when I was (at least not in any sort of formal capacity). The author of the submitted piece was talking about the perception of productivity however, and that was something snippets were designed to provide (at least that was how they were presented to me)
- tensafefrogs 13y agoAh, I've always used snippets more for personal use, so when the time comes to evaluate yourself you have a record. Yes, they are public, but they've always felt more informational than a mandatory log of what you've done.
- donpdonp 13y agoIt would seem that OKR results have more to do with how the objectives were set rather than a measure of performance.
- mason55 13y agoYes - your manager should be helping you set good goals.
- infinite8s 13y agoWhat happens when he goals change one what midway? Do you lose the progress on current goals when it finally comes time to evaluate your progress?
- mason55 13y agoIdeally you'd be evaluated on the progress you made on both sets of goals with consideration given to the fact that you weren't working on either set of goals for the entire quarter. I can't imagine a manager who helped you set quarterly goals with objective completion measurements and then penalized you if the goals changed partway through. There would probably be some discussion as to why the goals needed to change. If they were not set appropriately to begin with that might be an issues between you and your manager or might be an issue between him and his manager (maybe priorities weren't communicated effectively from higher up the chain) or it might truly be a case of changed priorities in the company (changing markets, change financial outlook, whatever).
- kamaal 13y ago>>You set goals with measurable results, and you grade them every quarter. This unfortunately has never worked. I don't if it worked at Google. But as far as I remember 'Setting goals' by and large works like premature optimization or at most in the theme of water fall model. When we used that approach we found half way down the goal timeline, our priorities as dictated by the business totally changed. We discovered better ways of doing things which altered goals. Some times we found we were simply measuring the wrong things. Some higher priority stuff just preempts the existing business goals and tend to get abandoned etc etc. I can see how it may work for business folks. Having targets like 'Increase revenue by $100 million', or 'Hire 10 new team members'. But in the grass root level day to day life can hardly be lived in the scopes of rigid goals.
- vidarh 13y agoGaming "Objectives and Key Results" type evaluations is far older than Google. It's not remotely an objective measure unless you have an organization that has extensive knowledge of how to accurately assess effort based on set objectives. From what I've seen, many organizations that try to formalize evaluations this way are easier to game, because the very idea that there are somewhat reliable metrics makes it easier to justify not following up as closely. (I'm not saying it will happen, but I've seen it far more often than I care to; including once having a manager that didn't even inquire about what my team had done lately for three years - I didn't mind, I delivered what I should to other parts of the business, but he should have: he had no effective oversight over a team officially reporting to him that handled tens of millions in revenue; if I had messed up, his head would've been on the chopping block next to mine)
- jordanb 13y ago> if I had messed up, his head would've been on the chopping block next to mine Maybe he trusted you?
- acdha 13y agoThis is likely the case but there's absolutely no excuse for a manager to draw a paycheck without at least asking what you're doing. If things seem to be going well and you trust the team, perhaps that's an infrequent high-level "what we did, what we're thinking about next” email but you should know at least that much.
- moron4hire 13y agoA few years ago, I worked about a small consulting firm that did the same thing. It was exactly as you described it. I would get in trouble for not writing enough, then I'd get in trouble for writing too much. Could never win. Eventually found out people were not only bitching about me, so I setup a daily search for my own name to keep on top of it. Started discovering key work information within their status reports that they weren't sharing with me, too. A year and a half there was 18 months too long.
- moron4hire 13y agoWhoa, what the hell happened to my ability to write today? I drank waaaay to much coffee today.
- JimboOmega 13y agoI don't see how this solves the problem at all. I suppose it gives a "paper trail" that shows what you're working on each day. But my experience is that this sort of thing (as you observe) really rewards those who are good at writing and navigating the social waters... rather than really reflecting work. If a manager is reviewing snippets, you just need to say what he wants to hear. Even if it should be "Was kind of blah today, didn't get any work done, talked to Y about it for a while but still didn't do much", you'd of course write "Faced several challenges with X, but made progress; had meeting with Y and got useful feedback". It's sort of an art, especially when it comes to full performance reviews. I used to be something of a savant on the subject. I have yet to see ANY system which comes close to measuring programmer productivity, even in a relative way, that isn't prone to huge errors or gaming. Same problem with interviewing, really; often social adeptness is what's being measured.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoTo be clear, I didn't say it solved the problem :-) I said Google tried to solve it. My experience of it was that it did have a bit of a 'motivating' effect (which is to say you felt bad if your snippet was 'read docs all day and am still confused', and it did have a bit of keeping track of things feel. But being self created, it varied a lot from engineer to engineer how the snippets read. And yes, it did test both social adeptness to some extent.
- mattmanser 13y agoIt's an automated form of micro-management trying to get you to justify yourself every single day. Sounds horrid.
- zeidrich 13y agoIt's horrid if you use it to judge or justify, it's actually not so bad if it's something you use to record and analyze without judgment. That's to say if you do it personally for the purpose of self-improvement, it's fine, when there's a social aspect of trying to determine who is pulling their weight it's going to more dishonest.
- jamesbritt 13y agoA few years ago I was working on a long-ish project and was tracking my time for billing. I noticed that, every so often, I would total up time spent on this or that feature or behavior and wonder how in the world did that take so long? So I wrote a small CLI tool that would let me write a short note and append it to a file. The note would be time-stamped, and the file name (or something) would reflect my current working directory. I forget exactly the details (I should go find this code if I can) but the idea was to be able to record quick observations about what I was doing so that later I could go back and get a more nuanced picture than basic time-tracking might offer. For example, I could do this: james:~/dev/BigProject$@ gem docs for stupid-easy-attachment gem do not match reality The '@' was the name of my note script. I'd then have a record of my trouble getting some gem to work. If nothing else it was therapeutic. Sometimes just writing something out spurred a useful idea, too. My time-tracking tool (JotBot) did allow for adding notes to recorded time but being able to record quick thoughts with little interruption to my work flow was a big win.
- borkabrak 13y agoThanks for the idea. I just wrote a similar thing, based on this. Credited you in the header. :)
- jamesbritt 13y agoSweet! Good to see the idea spread.
- silverlake 13y agoI had this same idea back when Yammer was started. But I wanted the social network to match the org chart. Your tweets go to your team. Your boss retweets a subset to his boss and other managers. And so on up to the CEO. This would solve your unfortunate problem and it wouldn't overwhelm people with zillions of irrelevant tweets.
- jrockway 13y agoI don't think snippets are really related to this particular problem. Ultimately, at Google, the results are what matter: Did you implement a system to do something? Are people using it? In that case, both teams demonstrated look fine: people are able to provision analog and digital channels. If the digital team is doing the same work with a smaller team, then that just makes the team look like they might be working at a higher level, which is good at promotion time.