4 ms·
>"I was surprised it was all meaningless to me. These pages meant the world to her, but to me they meant no more than any non-secret conversation we’d ever had.
by samstave 13y ago
>"I was surprised it was all meaningless to me. These pages meant the world to her, but to me they meant no more than any non-secret conversation we’d ever had. It was the same stuff that we all think."
Uh - yeah this is completely naive. Here is why; the informatin is meaningless to you only if you are not looking to manipulate, exploit, blackmail or have the upper hand of the person holding the secrets.
This is why the dragnet is insidious. Because it may be insignificant to the rural farmer; but valuable aagainst the urban lawyer seeking office, the corp exec or other heeled/monied power wielders...
- Munksgaard 13y agoI don't think he's making a point the NSA dragnet (which I'm assuming you're referring to) - that's obviously a completely different thing. He's talking about individuals willfully releasing information, not some secret government program to collect all your personal data that has ever been on the Internet.
- samstave 13y agoWhile that may be true - this article is addressing the sentiment of privacy in general; "If you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to worry about" -- and it uses a very personal anecdotal perspective on this matter: ones Diary. He, as I quoted, notes that this information in the super-super private diary was not only provided to him for perusal over cider, but that it was nothing that was of interest to him. This is a ridiculous statement, to me, on several levels. To illustrate, please provide me the email address of the friend with the super-super private diary; I would like to ask anonymously over the internet to be afforded the same luxury of reading this material. Do you think my request would be agreed to? No, this guy had a personal relationship with this diary author, however intimate/or not, but it was a personal relationship none-the-less. The idea here is that there is private information that one should have private from anyone - but will choose to share it with those in their intimate circles. This is not the same as saying "Why is anything that is factual secret" and thus who cares if it gets read by some anonymous entity that may or may not have any vested interest in knowing my secrets.
- Lagged2Death 13y agoIf you give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest of men, I will find something in them which will hang him. -- Often attributed to Cardinal Richelieu
- jaynos 13y ago"Often attributed"...I like that hedge.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tedunangst 13y agoThat quote doesn't really work for me, because it seems to be assuming that no other lines are available to provide context. Or rather, instead of meaning "everybody is guilty of something", I interpret the message as warning about the dangers of relying on a quote taken out of context.
- Lagged2Death 13y ago...instead of meaning "everybody is guilty of something", I interpret the message as warning about the dangers of relying on a quote taken out of context. It's not a concerned person's warning, it's a gloating celebration of ruthlessness, of power, and of the inconsequentiality of facts. It's bragging. If your every statement is recorded, it will be possible to find something in that record to make trouble for you, should powerful parties feel the need. "Guilt" and "innocence" are, in this context, meaningless abstractions.