5 ms·
Its great that the power of the law is currently being directed at great big jerks, but do we really think it will stay this way? These revenge porn sites are
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
Its great that the power of the law is currently being directed at great big jerks, but do we really think it will stay this way?
These revenge porn sites are journalism. And apparently we are all now cheering the government as it shuts down publications whose motives and views we disagree with.
http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/defending_hunter_moore.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/defending_hunter_moor...
- blueblob 13y agoIt is not journalism to hack people's computers, steal their stuff and pit it online.
- ianhawes 13y agoBut in most cases, nobody was "hacked" at all. The photos were distributed, without limitation, to 1 or more people by the actual subject of the photos.
- rblatz 13y agoI read an article a week or two ago about a mother that was a former private investigator researching the owner of one of these sites. She claimed that a lot of the women featured on the site had their info gathered by someone hacking their gmail account. I'll search for a link when I'm not at work. Don't really want revenge porn showing up in my search history here.
- byerley 13y agoWhen has the media ever had a good handle on what "hacking" means and how prevalent it is? Why would someone with the ability to "hack" a large number of gmail accounts choose nude photos to make their money with? I can't imagine the payoff is comparatively good and large-scale blackmail is a pretty good way to get targeted for prosecution. Further, aren't these pictures in their email because they were sent to someone? How would the average person distinguish between their account being "hacked" for the purpose of retrieving the picture opposed to the receiver sharing it? It sounds more like the instinctual "my account was hacked!" response to something embarrassing.
- tedunangst 13y agoWhat, you don't email yourself a copy of all your nude selfies for safe keeping? I thought everybody did that. edit to add: wow. From the xojane link it appears that's actually exactly what everybody does. I'm at a loss for words.
- sliverstorm 13y agoTo many people, email is how they move files about.
- tedunangst 13y agoYeah, I know. Done it myself. I was mentally filtering nude selfies out of the set of files I would want to move about. I draw a distinction between "here's a sweet recipe for chicken alfredo, better save this for later" and "here's a picture of me naked, better make a copy in case I need this later", but I guess others don't.
- rcthompson 13y agoThat's not true. There was an article that recently crossed the front page of HN by a victim of one of these sites, and her research revealed that a large fraction (possibly over half, I don't remember) of victims gas their photos obtained by hacking, not by a vengeful ex who already had legal access to the photos.
- ZoFreX 13y ago40% hacked, 36% revenge porn, 12% photoshopped, 12% self-submits.[1] [1] http://www.xojane.com/it-happened-to-me/charlotte-laws-hunter-moore-erin-brockovich-revenge-porn http://www.xojane.com/it-happened-to-me/charlotte-laws-hunte...
- byerley 13y agoI cringed when I saw "informal survey," but this seems to be in the important bit - "In most cases, the scam began through Facebook and ended when “Gary Jones” gained access to the victim’s email account." Unfortunately it doesn't make a lot of sense without context that I can't fine in the article. Was it phishing?
- ZoFreX 13y agoSadly it's not very clear, and it wasn't a random representative sampling, but it's the closest thing we have to any actual figures right now (AFAIK)
- yummyfajitas 13y agoYou mean like the Guardian did after Snowden stole peoples stuff and released it? Or like wikileaks/etc? Or assorted other newspapers releasing illegally acquired information?
- tptacek 13y agoThese are bad examples, because the legality of publishing Snowden and Manning's documents was in fact legally tenuous, and so far the publishers of the documents are protected largely by the enormous public welfare implications of the documents themselves. Especially in Snowden's case, that could change. Wait 6 months and see if the Snowden trove results in operationally relevant serious foreign intelligence disclosures that don't implicate the rights of US citizens, and then we'll see how much "journalism" really is a free pass to publishing "anything".
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- freyrs3 13y agoNation states are not people.
- detcader 13y agoWhen did The Guardian, WikiLeaks, NYT etc hack or steal anything? This is new to me
- jasonlotito 13y ago> hack people's computers, steal their stuff and pit it online. All 3 of those things were already illegal, and had legal remedies.
- nextstep 13y agoHow is revenge porn journalism?
- ianhawes 13y agoI believe he means they are protected free speech.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoAre you seriously disputing that releasing Anthony Weiner's selfies is journalism?
- wmf 13y agoAre you seriously making no distinction (three times and counting in this thread) between public figures and normal people?
- baddox 13y agoWhen it comes to publishing nude photos sent in a clearly private context, what is the distinction?
- tptacek 13y agoWhy is OK to humiliate a public figure by publishing sexualized nude photos of them? I'll hazard that it isn't OK, but that we kid ourselves because the cases where that happens, the mere existence of the photos is newsworthy. We conflate two different pieces of information: (a) that the photos exist, are real, were sent as alleged, &c and (b) the visual content of the photos themselves. (a) is a valid product of journalism; (b) probably isn't. We think (b) is, though, because one way that media outlets secure power for themselves in the market and elsewhere is by exploiting (b) to inflict punishment on the targets of their stories. They don't like Anthony Weiner (no surprise), so they're happy to torture him to get extra pageviews.
- Crito 13y agoI think that cases involving public figures is more complicated than many people think. Most of us would probably agree that paparazzi publishing pictures of celebrities naked in their back yard with telephoto lenses is not okay. Publishing pictures of Rob Ford smoking crack? That seems more than reasonable. Publishing pictures of Rob Ford smoking crack, naked in his backyard? I don't think that Rob Ford's attire changes the situation (does it really matter if he's wearing a t-shirt, a business suit, or his birthday suit? Either way, he's smoking crack), but how do you encode that in the law? I am not convinced there is a good way, even if we just say "lets hash it out on a case to case basis in courtrooms, then you have to consider SLAPP concerns.
- CatMtKing 13y agoI'm cheering anyway. It's not possible to have a set of laws or system that will prevent all misdeeds and protect all basic rights.
- 48snickers 13y agoThe charges in this specific case are blackmail. I don't think this has anything to do with viewpoints or consent. http://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-kamala-d-harris-announces-arrest-revenge-porn-website-operator http://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-kamal...
- tptacek 13y agoWhat isn't journalism by this definition? The simple response to your question is that if "journalism" has the nearly-useless definition you're providing, then "journalism" simply doesn't get to receive deference from public policy. Candidly: the publication of the Weiner "selfies" wasn't a high water mark for "journalism" anyways. Media outlets could have authenticated the photos and then published the simple facts of what had happened. Instead, those outlets applied their own morals and judgement to the situation, made their own decision that Weiner was an asshole, and punished him by repeatedly and gratuitously humiliating him. Maybe that shouldn't have been O.K. The public interest in the actual photos was, let's be honest, pornographic.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoIs releasing anthony Weiner's selfies not journalism? That's revenge porn by any reasonable definition. I would say that releasing true facts about people with documentary evidence is journalism. What else would it be?
- tptacek 13y ago(1) Maybe not. (2) If it is, so what? If any kind of publication is "journalism", than "journalism" isn't a free pass. The reality is that to the extent that lascivious photos are "journalism", then we recognize different degrees of "journalism"; it's not a binary state.
- bmelton 13y agoSo, if it isn't journalism (and I agree that the claim is tenuous), isn't it still free speech? Journalism isn't the only form of speech that falls under first amendment protections. Moreover, between laws against theft, and laws against copyright violation, I'm unsure how this isn't a solved problem, or why "revenge porn" sites are deserving of special legislation.
- tptacek 13y agoCasting an action as "speech" doesn't give you a free pass; fraud is also speech, as is libel. The rights enumerated in the Constitution conflict with each other; they were self-evidently incoherent when they were ratified, and the expectation has always been that those conflicts would need to be adjudicated by the Judiciary. What is true is that speech and expression must receive enormous deference, and what is also generally believed to be true is that the content and ideas animating speech can't be the basis for allowing or denying it.
- byerley 13y agoThe problem is that people have gotten comfortable with the idea that it's acceptable to hate someone for their hateful beliefs - forgetting that virtually every belief can be considered hateful with the right spin. While I think this case had mitigating factors and the guy could have been charged anyway, I certainly don't trust the jerks in the DA's office to decide who the other jerks are.
- rsynnott 13y agoPutting illegally obtained images on a website and operating an extortion racket to get them taken down is _not_ journalism.
- gamblor956 13y agoBy this logic, all killing should be allowed because we merely disagree that some types of killing. All type of sexual activity should be allowed because we merely disagree that some types of acts are non-consensual. Indeed...all types of crimes should be allowed because we merely disagree that some things are crimes. Absolutism may work wonderfully in a fantasy universe, but it has no place in reality. There is a huge difference between the non-consensual posting of someone else's pictures (i.e., revenge porn) and Anthony Weiner, a politician running for office, posting his own pictures of his own privates to women he had just met or not even met. (Hint: in one situation, the subject of the photo did not consent to the distribution of the photo, and may not even have consented to the photo itself. In the other situation, the utter stupidity of the actions calls into question Weiner's judgment and demonstrates a propensity for making rash decisions, both of which are important to know when electing a representative.)
- anigbrowl 13y agoThese revenge porn sites are journalism Nonsense. I read your blog post; you begin by asking readers to imagine an alternative reality where someone engaged in briebery is expose d by a journalist (despite the briber wishing that such activity would remain private), and then draw a false equivalence between bribery and exposure of one's body in a photograph. The differentce is that while bribery is a crime in most jurisdictions, taking a revealing photograph (or being the subject of one taken by someone else) is not a crime in any of the jurisdictions that apply here. So your public interest argument goes up in smoke. You go on to draw a comparison with Anthony Wiener. But given that a) he is occupying public office while b) sending unsolicited pictures of a sexual nature to random women he encountered on the internet, that isn't equivalent either. There is a public-interest argument to be made about the unwisdom of him sending out sexy pictures of himself (albeit a limited one; I think most people were more offended by his persistent cheating on his wife than being a horny guy, and this might not have been such an issue if he was single), but you seem to have forgotten that the story first made headlines because he mistakenly posted pictures to his public Twitter account and then organized a wild-goose-chase investigation by falsely claiming his Twitter account had been hacked. This is very different some third party making public a picture of him that he had anticipated would be kept private. Now I like a good contrarian argument as much as the next guy but this isn't a well-formed argument; it's irrational on its face and degrades the subject of the story in the process of trying and failing to make a point.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThere are all sorts of legal acts which reporters write about and which others might like to keep hidden. For example, consider "secretive rich guy is a racist" or "person I disagree with took money from Koch". As a tech related example, consider assorted hit jobs on peter thiel, pax Dickinson, etc. An act doesn't need to be criminal to be of journalistic interest. And a public figure is just a person that reporters take an interest in.
- anigbrowl 13y agoPerhaps, then, you should develop a new argument from that standpoint. And a public figure is just a person that reporters take an interest in. There is a difference between a merely famous person (eg Kim Kardashian) and a public figure like an elected official, in whose good behavior the public has an interest (as distinct from being interested in it in the colloquial sense). I mean this in the sense of the word republic which is a contraction of the Latin res publica or 'public matter.' This is why private individuals enjoy a right of publicity to their own likeness and copyright protection for their public performances, but the identity and doings of legislators and government officials (within the scope of their official activities) are in the public domain.
- garthdog 13y agoPure HN gold.
- thatthatis 13y agoThe "yelling fire in a crowded theater" standard is pretty clearly applicable here: Here are photos of someone naked vs here are photos of someone naked along with workplace, home address, home phone, etc. Yelling fire isn't protected as it insights panic. Doxing/revenge porn should be protected as it insights harassment.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]