5 ms·
And apparently Mr Cringely doesn't know anything about Webmaster Tools, which would probably be the first stop of anyone wanting to know about a sudden change i
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
And apparently Mr Cringely doesn't know anything about Webmaster Tools, which would probably be the first stop of anyone wanting to know about a sudden change in rank.
Sudden changes are usually the function of 'action' rather than 'inaction' so I'm guessing that somewhere there was an action. Did she succumb to some black hat SEO marketing pitch? Did Cringely piss off some black hat SEO person? Did her site get compromised and have malware installed? Did she not actually update the content for the last 5 years (including Copyright notice) so it doesn't appear to be a dead site.
The 'OMG I don't show up in results' is a good starting point but hardly the ending point of these stories.
- ry0ohki 13y ago>Sudden changes are usually the function of 'action' rather than 'inaction' This is not necessarily true and I have plenty of first hand experience. Also Webmaster tools is useless if they were not directly affected by a spam penalty.
- sergiotapia 13y agoYou're talking out of your ass and it's really infuriating to hear people disregard real, tangible problems you are facing. Google makes software, and no software is perfect. I've been bitten by shitty google services before. My most recent sting was Google Webmaster Tools not showing any Googlebot crawls to me website. My website is very niche and literally 1 of 4 competitors in the same arena. 5 month. 5 MONTHS. and google has yet to crawl my website, even though google analytics shows me stats day in day out. Why? Google breaks sometimes, and it's incredibly crappy that you can't even reach out to someone to ask what's up.
- mkhaytman 13y agoI'd contend you're the one talking out of their ass. Relying on another company for all your business isn't a sound business strategy. The person in the article put all their eggs in one basket and this is the result.
- grey-area 13y agoIn principle, I'd agree that relying on another company is not a sound business strategy, but Google has a virtual stranglehold on organic traffic to websites, something that is outside the control of most web companies. How do you suggest a web-based company should counter that and not rely on google for much of their business?
- wmf 13y agoMarketing? You know, advertising, social media, word of mouth, etc.
- sliverstorm 13y agoBut that costs money! ;)
- grey-area 13y agoMany of those channels rely on guiding people to search engines, or at the very least being findable on search engines by name. To take this example, your website is called portrait quilts, the url is http://portraitquilts.com/ http://portraitquilts.com/ - so you do loads of advertising on twitter, print media, word of mouth etc, and people try to find your site. You can try to guide them to a unique url, but often people won't remember urls, but names, and are encouraged to use this method by the blurring of urls and keyword searches in browsers. So they open up their browser, type portrait quilts in the address bar, which redirects to a search, and your website is on page 8 despite being an exact match on the search. Game Over. Seems your other channels are not quite as effective as you thought if google decides to penalise or blacklist your site. If you're off page 1 or 2 you may as well not exist. Of course from Google's point of view, you'll just have to advertise with google, so this doesn't penalise them at all, in fact they are rewarded monetarily for arbitrarily shifting rankings periodically (not that I'm suggesting that they go out of their way to do this, just that the perverse incentive is there).
- wmf 13y ago
- 300bps 13y agoHello friend. You seem angry so I'm going to attempt to tread lightly as I throw some friendly suggestions out. 1. Do you have a verified valid robots.txt that Google can read? 2. Does your verified valid robots.txt point to a verified valid sitemap or sitemap index? 3. Did your submit your verified valid sitemap or sitemap index to Google Webmaster Tools? Based on the responses to this, I or someone else might be able to help you further. Good luck to you.
- sergiotapia 13y agoI'm not angry, just trying to drive a point home using colorful language. 1. Yes, I have that. 2. Yes, I also have that. 3. Here's an actual screenshot of my google webmaster tools for my website: http://i.imgur.com/9Nwgts1.png http://i.imgur.com/9Nwgts1.png Remember: We're now closing in on 6 months with Google just not crawling my site whereas other search engines crawl near daily.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoTwo other pieces of information would be great here. 1) What is the URL in question. 2) When you click the 'why not' link what does it say? The other (possibly not relevant) question is whether or not you have any Google advertising or not on your site. I'm not suggesting that there is a 'pay for play' here, what I'm looking at is that when you use 'AdsenseForContent' or (AfC) the only way Google can know what sort of ads would make sense on your page is to crawl them first. If you had AfC ads on your page and Google wasn't crawling them, then that would suggest that your URLs are black listed for some reason. At Blekko our crawler tries to avoid sites that are either patently malicious (they've got known exploits in their pages) or on a list of malware/childporn sites, or have complex page structures that don't involve recursive crawling loops. What is the URL of your site?
- sergiotapia 13y agoMy url is: http://www.smitecamp.com http://www.smitecamp.com
- ry0ohki 13y agoTry posting it to Google Plus, you should get crawled instantly (not necessarily indexed though).
- russelluresti 13y agoSome things that may explain things: According to ahrefs, the number of referring pages (a big factor search results) dropped from about 22k pages to well under 1k over the course of 2 months starting at the end of march (source: https://ahrefs.com/site-explorer/overview/subdomains/www.portraitquilts.com https://ahrefs.com/site-explorer/overview/subdomains/www.por...). Additionally, it seems the site does show up in Google search results on the 10th page (https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=photo%20quilts#hl=en&q=photo+quilts&start=90 https://encrypted.google.com/search?hl=en&q=photo%20quilts#h...). I'll be honest, I don't understand what exactly that means, but it seems to have happened at around the same timeframe that you're referring to (5 or 6 months ago), so I'm going to bet it's a factor. Hope you figure it out - the whole search engine algorithm thing is really complex. But, honestly, I don't believe that Google just stopped working for a single domain. The more likely scenario is that something you/your sister is unaware of changed and had a large negative result.
- VMG 13y ago> Did she not actually update the content for the last 5 years (including Copyright notice) so it doesn't appear to be a dead site. That's a function of inaction however. Moral: don't base your income on something as volatile as your Google ranking
- drhayes9 13y agoThat's a pretty unrealistic moral in the face of the reality of how the consumer web works. I mean, I get the whole "don't depend on another company for your revenue" (e.g. apps in the Apple app store), but you're saying "don't count on Google sending traffic to your site". Plus, her ranking didn't change -- her site vanished out of the index. EDIT: Unless you mean "don't depend entirely on organic traffic"? I can sorta see that... but, again, if I've only now thought about putting a photo on a quilt (which is a new idea to me), around 70% of the US thinks putting [photo quilts] into Google is the way to get the site you want. What else would you suggest? EDIT #2: Maybe "vanished" is too strong a word, since it does show up on string matches. But it was deindexed for search terms it used to rank for.
- mkhaytman 13y agoHow did you infer the site was deindexed? They said specifically by typing the URL of the site, it would show up.
- drhayes9 13y agoFrom the site: "...but if you look for photo quilts or any similar search term, Portrait Quilts — which for years was always the top result — no longer appears." I'm being a little imprecise, but her site was deindexed for a bunch of search terms that she used to rank highly for.
- mkhaytman 13y agobased on how misinformed the author was in general on the subject, I think its more likely the site dropped off the first few pages of results. Since it still came up when you search for the domain, it can't be deindexed.
- cyrusshepard 13y agoA quick 2-minute check shows that yes, indeed the site violates Google guidelines. If you check the backlinks using any number of checkers (Open Site Explorer, Ahrefs, Majestic SEO) you can find a number of over-optimized 'unnatural' backlinks residing on spammy link-exchange pages in clear violation of Google's guidelines. The only reason to place links on these pages would be to try to rise higher in Google's search results. Yes, it feels unfair when Google drops you in search results, and Google has changed the rules over the years and it's hard to keep up with shifting guidelines. In truth, the website can recover from this. The same people who placed spammy links on 3rd party sites in order to manipulate rankings are probably savvy enough to mount a clean up effort to get those links removed and/or file a disavow request with Google (which basically tells them to ignore those links) Ironically, Eric Schmidt once tried to scrub Google of unfavorable search results about himself, and he was told they do not do that for individual results. ;)
- ars_technician 13y agoThe crappy part about this is that people can do this to sink competitors. Why bother lowering your prices? Just spend a few hundred dollars to have spammers plaster links to competitors on hacked sites... :(
- jayjay1010 13y agoThis is a report going into detail about the site and the violations to Googles terms with regards manipulative links: http://linkaudit.co.uk/blog/did-cringely-call-out-google-as-robbers-unfairly/ http://linkaudit.co.uk/blog/did-cringely-call-out-google-as-...