4 ms·
There's a slight positive aspect to this, which is that if consumers start to understand just how valuable this information is, they might start demanding their
by jerf 13y ago
There's a slight positive aspect to this, which is that if consumers start to understand just how valuable this information is, they might start demanding their cut. In this case, in the form of cheaper service. That would cause a significant shift in the market as a whole; I wouldn't even try to do a full analysis but it seems to me likely to result in an improvement.
In addition to the moral and social implications of widespread privacy infringement that is the more typical line of HN argumentation, it's also offensive and corrosive that this value is being plucked from you without you having an opportunity to bargain like someone providing a valuable commodity, rather than as a degrading "eyeball". Some people may find $360 a year a worthy trade for their browser history.
- dictum 13y agoI'm afraid it would go the opposite way—everyone chooses the cheaper, less private plans, then the company raises the prices and the ad-ridden plans eventually start costing the same as the old neutral plans, while the neutral plans (sold as "private" premium options) get premium prices - 5x what the ad-ridden plans (and the old neutral plans) once cost, etc.
- dwild 13y agoIf they can do that then competition will appear and will offer it for less... Nothing stop them from offering the current plan for 5x the price, except potential competition.
- sixothree 13y agoWhat's really offensive and scary is that it's obviously worth more than $360 per year.
- shalmanese 13y agoHow so? Valuing the average user's data at $360 a year would mean it would be about $100Bn across the entire US. This is the amount of total digital ad spend over the last year. Comcast would have to own the entire digital ad world and have 0 cost for this to be a break-even proposition for them. In reality, your user data is probably worth around $30.
- sixothree 13y agoGood point. Why would they offer such a steep discount if it were not worth that much? But $100Bn would be if every American were a paying customer. So maybe they are expecting the people most likely to accept this offer are households with many users. And maybe those younger users are the ones most valuable?
- shalmanese 13y agoThat you called it a "steep discount" is why. Imagine that the market optimal price for the plain service is $70 and the amount they could monetize from personal data is $2 a month. By offering the $100 tier, most people are going to think "Wow, $30 discount per month! That's a great savings" and a small percentage of die hard privacy advocates are going to buy the $100 plan on pure principle, leading to basically all profit from Comcast. Note, in this scheme, the $2 a month extra Comcast gets from selling your user data is basically irrelevant. They could actually just do nothing with your data and still come out ahead. It's the pricing psychology game that's important.
- smcnally 13y ago> "this value is being plucked from you without you having an opportunity to bargain like someone providing a valuable commodity, rather than as a degrading "eyeball". " Do you consider reading sites (other than this one) without making direct payments -- subscription, per-article -- to be without value? You're paying with your time and attention. That's the bargain. It'd be great to have ways to turn your engagement into currency more directly.