6 ms·
My sister's a quilter and Google mugged her
- mikeash 13y agoReally, "mugged"? Google walked up to her on the street and threatened her with a weapon?
- bmelton 13y agoThe sad part is that I was expecting that maybe there was a snafu with Google's NFC payments, or the Wallet, or maybe Google Shopping algorithm or something. Google used to give her a bunch of web traffic, arguably for free, and now they apparently have stopped, possibly with good reason, possibly without. And that is somehow stealing? I'm sympathetic to the plight of having lost revenue, but that revenue was never guaranteed, nor was it owed, nor should she have allowed Google to be her sole source of traffic.
- grey-area 13y agoThe percentage of traffic provided by google is largely outwith the control of websites - the users of the search engine decide how much traffic they send through google.
- DanHulton 13y ago"Allowed Google to have been her sole source of traffic?" It's one of the realities of the world we live in that Google - if you're popular on it at all - will likely dwarf any other traffic you're pulling in, despite any other efforts you may make. Further, it's important to note that effort spent on optimizing your Google ranking is usually an order of magnitude more effective than time spent optimizing for any other search engine. For people with very limited time outside of their primary activity, you've got to prioritize. (That said, the rest of your comment was spot-on. I just felt the last part of the last sentence didn't really reflect a few key realities, is all.)
- bmelton 13y agoCompared to free traffic, I'd agree. What I was trying to say was that, if traffic is so important to one's business, one should try securing it... but even that isn't really valid since, why would you spend money on something that you're getting so much of already, but for free, especially in a business that doesn't scale. Either way, Google's organic traffic results are probably replaceable through purchased clicks, and I'm guessing the proprietor appreciates the value of it more than what they otherwise might have, so who knows? Maybe all the free traffic is just Google's upsell. "You remember all that traffic you used to get? You can have it all again, for just $149 a month."
- oftenwrong 13y agoFor the curious: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=portrait+quilts https://duckduckgo.com/?q=portrait+quilts https://duckduckgo.com/?q=photo+quilts https://duckduckgo.com/?q=photo+quilts http://www.bing.com/search?q=portrait+quilts http://www.bing.com/search?q=portrait+quilts http://www.bing.com/search?q=photo+quilts http://www.bing.com/search?q=photo+quilts http://www.yandex.com/yandsearch?text=portrait+quilts http://www.yandex.com/yandsearch?text=portrait+quilts http://www.yandex.com/yandsearch?text=photo+quilts http://www.yandex.com/yandsearch?text=photo+quilts http://www.baidu.com/s?wd=portrait+quilts http://www.baidu.com/s?wd=portrait+quilts http://www.baidu.com/s?wd=photo+quilts http://www.baidu.com/s?wd=photo+quilts http://search.yahoo.com/search?p=portrait+quilts http://search.yahoo.com/search?p=portrait+quilts http://search.yahoo.com/search?p=photo+quilts http://search.yahoo.com/search?p=photo+quilts
- greglindahl 13y agoOr even https://blekko.com/#?q=portrait%20quilts https://blekko.com/#?q=portrait%20quilts and https://blekko.com/#?q=photo%20quilts https://blekko.com/#?q=photo%20quilts EDIT: By the way, the reason we have this site lower than other engines is that we tend to put howto and non-selling sites over selling sites.
- 3JPLW 13y agoToo many, didn't click: (the result order for me; yours may vary) DDG: 1 2 Bing: 1 2 (but ads before) Yandex: 1 3 Baidu: 1 2 Yahoo: 1 2 (but so much ads/images/cruft before) Blekko: 3 x
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ErikAugust 13y agoComes up first for me - https://www.google.com/#q=portrait+quilts https://www.google.com/#q=portrait+quilts Edit: HA! Sorry, it's an ad! I thought it was the first organic result but it was actually the second ad! I can barely perceive that shade of yellow indicating that it's an ad. Took two or three takes.
- pflats 13y agoDoesn't come up on page 1 at all for me for photo or portrait quilts. edit: An ad for portraitquilts.com shows up first in the ads sidebar, though.
- toll 13y agoIt isn't in the search results for me, but there is an ad for portraitquilts.com. So i guess they bit the bullet and paid for advertising.
- 3JPLW 13y agoIt's an ad for me. Of course, Google's been doing all it can to make ads look like organic results. Looks like she bought into the protection racket.
- mynameishere 13y agoMaybe you're being funny, but it's scary to think that google has a quiet policy of letting businesses develop revenues through organic search and then intentionally changing the algos.
- EliRivers 13y agoIt's often interesting to perform the same search on google.com using different proxies. Sometimes I get things in my proxied results that don't turn up in my unproxied (and vice-versa).
- brent_noorda 13y agoIt came up for me in the adwords section, either at the top or on the right, for the first two pages. But I scrolled through five pages of results and in never came up as an "organic" result.
- pflats 13y agoSince work's got me locked into IE/Bing, I might as well point out that Ms. Cringely's site is #2 on Bing (#6 if you count the 4 ads on what looks like a 15% blue-gray background that come before #1).
- zallarak 13y agoI see a lot of these articles; someone feeling cheated because Google takes them off some or all search results. Google did not "mug" anyone - it is the reason for your traffic to begin with. The fact that you even ever had discoverability among a billion or so websites is a beautiful thing. Additionally, have some perspective, the search is a free tool that is very tough to get right. This might sound harsh, but I believe the effort in complaining could be better allocated into promoting the authors' sister's business. To emphasize, Google search is a FREE tool - use it to get business but don't make it your bread and butter because it is optimized for users, advertisers - not the content creators. To accept this is not optional, it is simply reality.
- eurleif 13y ago>it is the reason for your traffic to begin with No, people searching for "photo quilts" are the reason for the traffic. Most of those people happen to be using Google, but if Google disappeared, they would switch to another search engine. The site owner has a legitimate interest in Google doing its job better, and so do we as Google users. The point of this post is that Google isn't serving anyone's interests properly here (except, perhaps, its own). As a Google user, I want to know that.
- wtetzner 13y ago> The point of this post is that Google isn't serving anyone's interests properly here I'm not sure about that. When I search for "photo quilts", I find plenty of relevant sites. They seem to be at least as good as www.portraitquilts.com. I would say Google is doing a fine job serving it's user's interests. It might just be that www.portraitquilts.com isn't as relevant as the other results.
- latj 13y agoIn one sense you are correct that Google is "free" because one does not pay cash directly to Google to be listed in its results or to preform a search. But in another sense, Google is not free at all. The fact is, Google lives and thrives off of the data generated by the public. Yes, Google employees smart people. But its real value is derived from the underlying public data that Google gets- for free. Google search works because the world allows Google's bots to traverse their websites freely and index their content. Google translate works because the EU and other governments translated their documents into many languages and then gave them away to the world. Google Maps works because of GIS information gathered on the public's dime. Gmail is able to operate because users allow it to mine their personal messages to better tailor advertisements. Google is built on top of and depends on the public- both to be its customers and to be the source of its products. It has taken the market in search, email, browser, and mobile. And, for the most part, it has created some great tools for people to use. But there is a minority of people whose lives are affected by Google for the worse. Its important not to marginalize these people. This is a non-democratically elected institution whose policies and actions have more effect on people's lives than the governments of many nations. Those policies and actions ought to be looked upon critically by the people.
- eli 13y agoReminds me a bit of the recent article on the rise and fall of the content farm Demand Media: http://variety.com/2013/biz/news/epic-fail-the-rise-and-fall-of-demand-media-1200914646/ http://variety.com/2013/biz/news/epic-fail-the-rise-and-fall... (worth a read). Someone was recently telling me that "diversity of traffic sources" is a key metric they use to evaluate digital media properties. There's a real risk in basing your whole business on organic Google traffic.
- nwalter08 13y agoMost misleading title of the day!
- tedunangst 13y agoEric Schmidt said he was sorry but he couldn’t help. Now I’m angry. Wow. I think I respect Google more now. I don't like the "take it to the people" approach needed to get action out of Google, but I like "I know people who know people" approach even less. The chairman of the company should not be dicking about with search results because a friend asked.
- oh_sigh 13y agoYeah, it seems pretty pathetic to get upset that you can't get preferential treatment through personal connections.
- mempko 13y agoExcept he could have given some helpful hint...
- 300bps 13y agoIn reality, he couldn't. There are likely several million sites that are wondering about their Google page ranking as well. Figure several thousand of them know someone who knows someone who knows Eric Schmidt. From a practical standpoint, how many hours are in the day and how many do you think he should devote to such activities? From a fairness perspective, is it fair that you give inside Google information to someone because they're an acquaintance of an acquaintance? Eric Schmidt said he was sorry but he couldn’t help. Now I’m angry. This line strikes me as very similar to the person who makes a scene in a restaurant when they can't get a table right away. "Don't you know who I am?! My sister has the former #1 Photo Quilting business online!"
- pcmonk 13y agoThe real problem is not that they couldn't get preferential treatment. The problem is that there is no way to get treatment at all. If they hadn't have asked Eric Schmidt, then we could have wondered whether they had really tried everything. Since they did, it's obvious that Google simply has a problem that they're not interested in fixing.
- DanBC 13y ago> Eric Schmidt said he was sorry but he couldn’t help. This is a good thing. It's incredibly frustrating that Google has no way for people to get help with the search engine. Allowing the few people who happen to know someone who knows someone to get help doesn't make Google any less frustrating in this situation - although it does help that one person. It would be interesting to learn why the site got delisted (if it did). Often someone complains vociferously, then a Googler points out all the weird SEO links that exist for that domain, and a bunch of odd things happening on the site.
- southpawgirl 13y agoSorry for the author's sister, but it's kinda reassuring to know that even Google's CEO won't tamper with the results algorithm. Which might or might not be fair, but still...
- ChuckMcM 13y agoAnd apparently Mr Cringely doesn't know anything about Webmaster Tools, which would probably be the first stop of anyone wanting to know about a sudden change in rank. Sudden changes are usually the function of 'action' rather than 'inaction' so I'm guessing that somewhere there was an action. Did she succumb to some black hat SEO marketing pitch? Did Cringely piss off some black hat SEO person? Did her site get compromised and have malware installed? Did she not actually update the content for the last 5 years (including Copyright notice) so it doesn't appear to be a dead site. The 'OMG I don't show up in results' is a good starting point but hardly the ending point of these stories.
- ry0ohki 13y ago>Sudden changes are usually the function of 'action' rather than 'inaction' This is not necessarily true and I have plenty of first hand experience. Also Webmaster tools is useless if they were not directly affected by a spam penalty.
- sergiotapia 13y agoYou're talking out of your ass and it's really infuriating to hear people disregard real, tangible problems you are facing. Google makes software, and no software is perfect. I've been bitten by shitty google services before. My most recent sting was Google Webmaster Tools not showing any Googlebot crawls to me website. My website is very niche and literally 1 of 4 competitors in the same arena. 5 month. 5 MONTHS. and google has yet to crawl my website, even though google analytics shows me stats day in day out. Why? Google breaks sometimes, and it's incredibly crappy that you can't even reach out to someone to ask what's up.
- jiggy2011 13y agoI've had this sort of thing happen myself, client's who's websites lose out on <company name> to some spammy site for no obvious reason. People seem to assume that google operates as some sort of public service which provides free services to website owners. Now I just tell people to factor adwords spend into the development costs for a site.
- wonderyak 13y agoThis is what I see on Google: https://i.cloudup.com/7ymLpPBmma-3000x3000.png https://i.cloudup.com/7ymLpPBmma-3000x3000.png The first organic results don't even show up with the size of my window. The whole situation these days on the SERP for any purchasable item is pretty sad. Luckily, I don't use Google that much when pricing or shopping. Results for data are much more helpful and useful for me.
- maaaats 13y agoAnd the shading is so much more hidden now. I had to tilt my screen properly to even see that it was ads.
- derekp7 13y agoI found out that this varies quite a bit based on your monitor. For example, on my newer Thinkpad, the yellow background really stands out. But on my desktop monitor (a 5 - 6 year old Samsung), it isn't noticeable at all, even with tilting the monitor.
- fyrabanks 13y agoYou might want to color calibrate.
- ry0ohki 13y agoIt's the unfortunate reality, I honestly feel like Google's algorithm has gotten really arbitrary lately (just had a huge drop off of almost all traffic for a month which was completely unexplained, only to come right back a few weeks later). The fact that they hide keywords now will make it seem all the more arbitrary. The real world comparison is not a mugging, it's as if your small business was on Main St one day, and the next there are literally no roads to get to you.
- neilk 13y agoThis is more of a story about the danger of relying on search ranking than it is about Google abusing anyone. Presumably Cringely knows this, but he also knows that carping loudly about it will increase portraitquilts.com's Google rankings. Unfortunately, this is a zero-sum game. If portraitquilts.com deserves to win, then that's also saying that the other businesses, how-to sites, Pinterest boards, and so on deserve to lose. Is that obviously true?
- jenno 13y agoHas this sister ever engaged in any dubious SEO practices, such as hiring "backlink providers" on fiverr, spamming her link on unrelated websites, or too much prolific use of using the anchor text of "portrait quilt"? Any of those will signal to Google that they are unnatural links and as a result, the site can be penalized and show up less in results, sometimes being removed altogether. I apologize if this comment is too obvious -- I have worked as an SEO consultant for a while. The first thing she should do is check her Google Webmaster Tools, as this is where she will receive any unnatural link warnings. If it is there, she can start taking steps to remedy the situation by undoing any of the questionable SEO tactics she may have used, and request reconsideration from Google.
- shobhitverma 13y agoThis is pretty interesting. So I can theoretically bring down a competitor's rank by creating spammy websites and providing unnatural backlinks ? Even if the competitors figure it out from the webmaster tools, they will have no way to remove the backlinks. Right ?
- momokatte 13y agoBacklinks can be disavowed via Webmaster Tools. https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/2648487 https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/2648487 Related: http://searchenginewatch.com/article/2309486/Matt-Cutts-Use-the-Link-Disavow-Tool-Even-if-Your-Site-Hasnt-Been-Penalized http://searchenginewatch.com/article/2309486/Matt-Cutts-Use-...
- frakkingcylons 13y agoIf you're going to write an article criticizing how Google lowered your spot in the SERP, then at least try to make a substantive argument for why it deserves to be higher. Otherwise it's just whining.
- Systemic33 13y agoI think it is quite terrifying, that one company can singlehandedly shut down business, even if you have never used a Google service in your entire life; because all your customers only discover you through Google. And what is to be done about it? you aren't a Google customer in the direct sense, so they feel no obligation to assist, and it seems as if even actual customers get negligible support. The only way out of this seems to be either Google collapsing, or a MS-esque antitrust/monopoly court.
- gagege 13y agoLet's say I own a single store and it happens to be in a space in a mall. Also, the mall is letting me do business there for free. I get exposure, electricity, easy access, all kinds of good stuff, for free. (The mall is Google) Suddenly the mall wants to extort me by charging me money to use their space, electricity, water, etc. Those jerks!
- tjr 13y agoDoes Google let you buy search result placement? Not ads, but better placement in search results?
- Systemic33 13y agoCompletely missing the problem. The problem i'm talking about is more in the case of some company distributing a large phonebook for the city, which includes all stores and people, information they gathered by downloading public city records. So people start using this phonebook all the time, and for most citizens, it's the only way they can find your business. But on day the phonebook company, decides for an uknown reason to delist a business. When the store then contacts the phone company, they are reached with a voicemail, every time they try to contact. The store knows some friends who know the owner of the phonebook company, but the guy they know refuse to comment on it. What the hell is the store supposed to do? The entire city is so hooked on the phonebook company, because they give them free phone lines, and all sorts of seemingly free stuff, which is really just feeding drugs to the addict. How does this not stink far away of antitrust? The phonebook is actively working to keep its users with free stuff, so that they keep using them, and enables them to extort the phone store to have to pay the phonebook company for getting them listed again.
- EliRivers 13y agoIf I were running a business providing free advertising for such companies, I'd wait until a company relied on me and then make them pay for it. Given that google is a business, doesn't seem that odd that this happens. In fact, seems surprising if it doesn't.
- csomar 13y agoLet's make people rank, so they could build businesses from traffic we drive, and then cut the traffic. That would be a good business plan for Adwords, no? Now, seriously, I don't think this is Google plan. I think Google just got many billions websites and pages to rank. Google aim is not to be fair for every website, but instead to give the best results. Given a huge number of websites (and people running them), these occurrences would obviously happen.
- grey-area 13y agoYes, there is a serious conflict of interest at the heart of Google's business - they are in the business of selling links to advertisers, and of curating links for readers.
- dude3 13y agoGoogle just plain hates exact match now in my experience. You have to build up solid reputation to get out of the exact match sort of penalty. I think they think exact match is generally spammy and elevates the spam filter. Some other factors in an algo update probably got more weight that the site was affected by and pushed the site over the edge. I tend not to change anything right away when this happens. Wait a bit and see if it corrects. Then make small iterative SEO changes and throw some youtube videos on your site that you produced. Another good strategy, and I've seen a bunch, is to change the domain name. Only do that in last resort. Watch how often googlebot accesses your site and try to increase frequency too.
- kybernetyk 13y ago> Eric Schmidt said he was sorry but he couldn’t help. > Now I’m angry. I would be more angry if Eric Schmid had helped. Because not everyone whose website gets de-indexed knows someone who knows a buddy of Eric Schmidt. So at least it stays equally shit for everyone and there's no two-tier society of website owners divided by Silicon Valley real life contacts.
- BlakePetersen 13y agoDude, that site is riddled with out-dated and now black-hat seo tricks. It was just asking to be blacklisted. Get that cheater off my SERPs, I wanna go with the honest portrait quilt providers.
- maaaats 13y agoany examples?
- fyrabanks 13y agoIf I recall correctly, the latest change Google made to PageRank penalizes her for using meta tags the way she does. edit: Also just realized she doesn't have a robots.txt. edit2: Gauthier's comment (December 11, 2013 at 7:24 am) on that article sums up the problems pretty well.
- genericuser 13y agoFirst off I know nothing about SEO as will likely be apparent from my comment, that said. As someone who knows nothing about SEO it looks to me like it could of triggered duplicate content detection portion of a google algorithm. https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/66359?hl=en https://support.google.com/webmasters/answer/66359?hl=en Looking briefly at the source she has the entirety of the following in the title of every page other than the main page I looked at Portrait Quilts - Memory Photo Quilts with up to 96 Photos! Personalized Memory Quilts, Picture Quilts and Photo Blankets info - Portrait Quilts - Memory Photo Quilts with up to 96 Photos! Personalized Memory Quilts, Picture Quilts and Photo Blankets and half of it in the title of the main page It seems like some maintenance could be order for the site.
- panzi 13y ago"This is how she makes her living, selling on the web and through photo stores." "She founded PC Data, the largest PC market research firm, now part of the NPD Group." She founded the largest PC market research firm and now she has to make a living making quilts? How did that happen? Wouldn't the bigger story be how she lost all her money (which I'm assuming) running a PC market research firm?
- Xylakant 13y agoShe has to make her living != She makes her living. Maybe she just likes making photo quilts and found a niche market that allowed for a sustainable business that was now ruined. Isn't that what we'd all like to do: Earn enough money so that we can work in a job we like, even if that doesn't pay as much as we'd need to live?
- panzi 13y agoYes, but again, this would have made a interesting story. It's just confusing and strange to note such a thing and then not elaborate at least a bit on it. Also, someone who can found such a firm usually understands how not to "get mugged" by a changing search engine.
- gscott 13y agoThe problem is your sister is in direct competition with Google. Searching Portrait Quilts brings up your sisters site then a large box that says "Shop for portrait quilts on Google" Google is a competitive enterprise. They have to report to stock holders every quarter that income is more then the previous quarter.
- noveltysystems 13y agoMaintaining rank and attracting organic traffic from Google requires constant, continuous work, and there are plenty of ways to shoot yourself in the foot. We all compete for this traffic; getting angry at Google and writing a pissed-off blog post won't change her ranking - stepping up to the plate and competing for the traffic using white-hat SEO, semantic markup, webmaster tools, syndication through social media, etc. is the only way forward. SEO has changed - adapt or die.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- trevin 13y agoSpent a few minutes looking at the site. Looks to me like it was hit by Google's Penguin 2.0 update [1] that targeted sites that had low quality links pointing in to their domain (in particular inner pages). Probably not the sisters fault, but the site has done a lot of reciprocal linking in the past which Google really frowns upon nowadays. There's prominent page on her site featuring some of those links: http://www.portraitquilts.com/info/links http://www.portraitquilts.com/info/links She also has some links from pages that are selling or exchange links to spam/escort sites: http://www.iwr.com/gifts/crafts.html http://www.iwr.com/gifts/crafts.html http://www.livebusinessradio.com/trade/recip.cgi http://www.livebusinessradio.com/trade/recip.cgi Again, probably not her fault. Google is doing their job but with so much misinformation about SEO and link building out there it is easy for people to accidentally get themselves in trouble. If anybody is curious, I used ahrefs to pull in the backlinks to the site: https://ahrefs.com/site-explorer/refdomains/subdomains/www.portraitquilts.com https://ahrefs.com/site-explorer/refdomains/subdomains/www.p... There are some other examples of link spam in there. Penguin would be my guess after a quick check. [1]http://searchenginewatch.com/article/2279845/Googles-Penguin-2.0-Algorithm-The-Definitive-Guide http://searchenginewatch.com/article/2279845/Googles-Penguin...
- shobhitverma 13y agoThat is insightful
- adam12 13y agoAnother site that was intended to raise her page rank, but in the end got her site blacklisted: http://www.linkstrategy.com/links/home-furniture-specialty-unique.htm http://www.linkstrategy.com/links/home-furniture-specialty-u...
- mkhaytman 13y agoMr. Cringely might start helping his sister by removing the completely unrelated link to his sister's site from his own, or at least mark it "nofollow". It's really interesting reading the rantings of the grossly misinformed, especially when they are able to dismiss the entire industry of search engine optimization as "bullshit". I bet if the tone of his article was different, he would have dozens of SEOs willing to diagnose the problem and giving tips on how to fix the issues. Oh well, maybe he should get in tighter with Eric Schmidt, so he can personally take a look at the writer's wife's photo pillow website. The entitlement is so rich.
- Rebuildorkillit 13y agoShe has very few links and the ones she did have that were propping her up are dying out. She needs to work on the site more and reach out to other people more.
- mariehaynes 13y agoIf this site used to rank well for things like "photo pillows", it's not because it was the best site to show users, but rather, it was because the site was being propped up by self made backlinks. Here are some of the links that are all anchored with the word "photo pillows": http://www.bobmarketing.com/links/page_Business_Marketing_17.html http://www.bobmarketing.com/links/page_Business_Marketing_17... http://stardir.info/stardir/subcategory.asp?IDsubcate=494&offset=15 http://stardir.info/stardir/subcategory.asp?IDsubcate=494&of... http://www.cyberpathway.com/cgi-bin/recip/internet/recip.cgi http://www.cyberpathway.com/cgi-bin/recip/internet/recip.cgi The majority of the backlink profile is made up of self made low quality directory links. It's possible that the Penguin algorithm has realized this and as a result is not trusting links to the site. But, it's also possible that Google has just gotten better at not counting this type of link when it comes to ranking. It's also possible that the site is under a manual penalty (which would be evident by looking at the Webmaster Tools manual spam action tool.) When I look at the site's keyword positions on semrush.com, it appears that the rankings started a gradual decline as of May 2013. There was a Penguin refresh on May 23, so this is certainly a possibility. If the site is affected by Penguin, then in order to make the algorithm trust the site again, she's going to have to disavow each of the links that are self made. If there are good, truly natural links in the profile then she stands a chance of ranking well again. But, the likelihood is that the site won't get back to the previous rankings by just clearing up the backlinks because those rankings were not deserved in the first place. It's not Google's fault that this site is not ranking well now. But, one could argue that it was Google's heavy reliance on links and on a system that could be scammed that allowed this site to reign for the time that it did.
- memracom 13y agoJust don't trust your business to a "site". If it is your business, then your "site" should include a blog that should have regular articles about all sorts of related things, including about other related sites who hopefully have their own blogs and will write about your site. There needs to be a buzz of activity around your business or people will stop coming in the door. Dirty windows? Spider webs in the doorframe? Trash on the sidewalk? Paint fading? Lightbulb burned out? Sign peeling? These are signs that the business is dying and the passersby will gladly help you out by not shopping there and by telling their friends to avoid the place. Life is like that in the real world; why should the Internet be any different?