3 ms·
Nice self righteous racial stereotyping there - thanks.
by bloat 13y ago
Nice self righteous racial stereotyping there - thanks.
- talmand 13y agoIt's not stereotyping if it's a quote, but then again, we don't know the accuracy of the quote.
- 001sky 13y agoOk, but "quotes" can be used to further sterotypes, tho. in addition to accuracy there is always context...I'm sure the nazi's quoted a couple of jews in their day.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- talmand 13y agoWell, sure it could. But to me, if a quote from a person somehow reinforces a stereotype of a group the quoted person is labeled as part of, then that implies more about the person hearing the quote than the person stating the quote. A person can use a quote out of context all day long but it doesn't truly reinforce the stereotype until a person hearing the quote agrees with the out-of-context usage. For example, if a person from Mars says something stupid and someone provides me with a quote. Do I say to myself; "That person is stupid" or "Martians are stupid"? If I go with the second then the problem is within me, not the quote nor the person who provided it. So, did the Nazi's quote Jews out of context to further their aims of denigrating them? I'm sure they did. But it only worked for people who agreed with the idea in the first place.
- clebio 13y agoQuotes of any person's speech aren't normally written in quasi-phonetic slant-accent jibberish.
- talmand 13y agoIt should be if it were spoken that way, otherwise it's not accurate. Of course, that could depend on the context of the quote. If you are just communicating the information given then, sure, correct for grammar and whatnot. If it's to communicate the personality and/or attitude of the person, then you quote verbatim as it was said. That's why the term "sic" exists for quoting people, you are acknowledging that it is known the quoted statement appears incorrect. Because that's the way it was stated.
- clebio 13y agoThat's a good point about using 'sic', but then the OP didn't.
- sfg 13y agoHas the comment been edited? It does not, as it currently appears on my screen, mention any particular race for the people in the dialogue given.
- velis_vel 13y agoThis kind of 'well if it doesn't explicitly mention race it can't possibly be stereotypical' belief is nonsense. If I go 'oh me so solly!' everybody is going to know I'm stereotyping Asians (specifically, Chinese/Japanese) people.
- bassclef 13y agowhere did I stereotype? Did I make a blanket statement about any race? I'm not sure I did.. Seems you don't even know the definition.