7 ms·
Occupy Google: Income Inequality Backlash Hits Silicon Valley
- visakanv 13y agoWow. I thought this was satire. I guess this kind of happens in Singapore, too. As the billionaires come in, the poorer locals encounter rising housing costs. And unlike the US, Singapore is an island-city-state, so there's nowhere to run. I can't think of any solutions to this. Anybody have any ideas?
- bishnu 13y agoBuild more housing?
- tehwalrus 13y agoIn the UK, and it sounds like San Fran too, there are lots of special-interest-inspired laws making building new housing difficult. In Singapore, unlike many other countries where people think they're out of space (including the UK), they may well be really running out of space - I believe there are similar problems in Hong Kong.
- gaius 13y agoYou mean like the green belt? Once various plans to rebalance the economy away from London come to fruition (e.g. HS2) things will return to normal.
- tehwalrus 13y agoLOL. Train lines connecting places to the capital just cause the capital to grow further[1]. New high speed lines between Manchester and Sheffield, and up from each to Glasgow and Edinburgh would help rebalance the economy as you suggest. But they're not planned for decades. [1] https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/no-stone-unturned-in-pursuit-of-growth https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/no-stone-unturned... and/or http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-20142837 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-20142837 - "The Heseltine Review" isn't a primary source of evidence for this assertion, but it's through this coverage that I learned of these ideas.
- visakanv 13y agoI think we're working on it, but the island is highly land-scarce, and if I understand correctly, prices are being driven up faster than new housing can adequately correct.
- michaelt 13y agoIn many countries we place control of local planning/zoning issues in the hands of local residents - the very people who benefit most from the supply being restricted. I would love for there to be more houses in the place I want to live but can't. But I don't get a vote because I'm not a resident.
- Pxtl 13y agoThat. The lack of intensification in some of the most valuable real-estate in the world is absurd. Build up! Also, while it stinks for people who are already tied into careers, having money flood into your community isn't exactly a bad thing for somebody entrepreneurial. I mean, if the new wealthy folks want to blow that cash locally, there's a lot of money to be made. It's demeaning in a "trickle-down" services sense, but it's cash to be had.
- umsm 13y agoWill this increased building activities cost less than the current housing market rate? If a new property costs $500k to build, as a builder you would need to at least cover that cost. I can't imagine that this helps the poor unless it's government sponsored.
- saosebastiao 13y agoThe housing market rate will be lower with new housing than without it.
- zorked 13y agoRemote work?
- protomyth 13y agoLow income people tend to be doing jobs that cannot be done "over the wire" such as service jobs.
- visakanv 13y agoYep, the blue-collar folk are the worst hit.
- famousactress 13y agoActually I think the better argument is for the tech-companies to support remote work, so that they stop importing wealthy home-needers. I think it's a really good part of a solution to this problem.
- michaelochurch 13y agoWhen I was at Google, you pretty much needed to be in MTV to get a good shot at the most interesting projects. I'd argue that if you want to have a career there, you should go to the main office where your hallway serendipity is more likely to involve people who can actually bring you into a career-making AI project (instead of typical drudge work). Of course, it's different for everyone, and I was only there for 6 months, but if I were to do it over again, I'd work in MTV. I'd also advise everyone, regardless of traffic or weather, to show up in the physical office 5 days a week. To make remote work work, you need a culture where in-crowds and promotions and ladders don't matter (they'll always exist, but some companies give them more weight) and where people are pretty much assured that, even if they never get another title bump-- because those things happen less when you're not in-person-- they'll continue to get work that they're happy with.
- famousactress 13y agoYeah, I agree that remote working at a company that hasn't completely embraced it tends to be a bad idea. I'm suggesting more companies completely embrace it. For GOOG that'd be an interesting challenge. I don't know if the last sentence in your first paragraph was advice for Googlers or portable but I'd advise literally everyone to avoid traffic at every possible opportunity... though as I get older I'm much more 'ambitious' about happiness than title bumps, so YMMV.
- paul_f 13y agoThis made me chuckle: "haves" versus the "have nots". How about we change that to: "made smart decisions, studied hard, work hard" versus the "made bad decisions, jealous of others"
- gnaritas 13y agoBecause that's fallacious thinking, specifically the just world fallacy. Your view of the world is faulty.
- gaius 13y agoGood luck being rich in a city without street sweepers, waitresses, barmen, firemen, nurses, teachers... In fact the whole point of you buying that swanky apartment will evaporate overnight without service workers.
- darkarmani 13y agoNurses? Why are they on that list?
- sanderjd 13y agoBecause they are service workers who are not very highly paid.
- bryanlarsen 13y agoThe average RN salary is $66K. However, that's just the base salary. Most RN's work some night shifts and some overtime, which can very quickly push that above $100K. In most of the US $66K - well over $100K is a lot of money. It doesn't go very far in the valley, though...
- umsm 13y agoThose numbers are extremely generous. I know a few nurses and none make $100k.
- somewhat 13y agoWhy is "Google" the default shothand for "silicon valley"? And not just in this case.
- protomyth 13y agoBecause they are the most visible and get the most press. It is very much like every article with "Apple" in the title. Apple is too old to be the poster child for the valley, so Google takes the hit. Plus, Google is visible in this scenario due to their buses and outspoken executives.
- somewhat 13y agoIf I'm not mistaken Apple, Facebook, and twitter also shuttle employees via buses. I don't get the "outspoken executives" comment, specially in this context.
- protomyth 13y agoGoogle is the biggest web company and Eric Schmidt likes to make a lot of newsworthy statements.
- somewhat 13y agoNot about this stuff. Also "newsworthy" is your definition, I don't think it's accurate.
- protomyth 13y agoEvery time he says something about privacy or drones, it hits the front page of every news website. That would be newsworthy. Doesn't really matter that he hasn't said anything on this issue, just as it really doesn't matter that Apple is not the only tech company using Chinese manufactures that have histories of employee abuses. It is what gets attention. Google has some sins of its own. The airplane fuel deal was seen as a sign of taking advantage of the taxpayer. It is a big company and will make headlines in this regard.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- visakanv 13y agoWhat about Google's marketing do you find to be pretty bad? Come to think of it, what's Google's marketing strategy, apart from "build stuff people use"?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- michaelochurch 13y agoI have really mixed feelings about this. First of all, the "victims" were probably Google peons, not the insufferable royalty. The vast majority of Googlers are people I like (I worked there) and they aren't responsible for the problem. Like I said in another post here, the engineers doing all the work will soon be priced out to make room for product narcissists and those horrible executives that VCs implant to grant a favor to a friend, making twice as much money as engineers while working 11-to-3. It has already happened in New York, except it's bankers and traders. At least traders are respectable (it's pretty meritocratic) and the bankers actually work. Startup executives tend to be the people who failed in New York and in finance, so they seek them some VC coattails to ride on into someone else's company. In 2008 when Wall Street tanked the economy, people were saying, "I wish all that talent were somewhere useful like Silicon Valley." This seems laughable now. Silicon Valley? Useful? Anyway, "tech" had the good faith of the nation for a long time, we were the "good rich" as opposed to the people on Wall Street-- and, in the next 5 years, fucking blew it thanks to debacles like FWD.us, Sean Parker's wedding, and all the bad behavior that Valleywag so excellently chronicles. We were the good guys. We still should be. Most of us, by population, are. The fuckers at the top, who don't even code and 90% of whom are MBA/private-equity types, have ruined not just our industry but our reputation. Now, people associate "techie" with spoiled brats, misogynists, and entitled, crypto-right-wing fuckheads (like the character played by the union organizer when impersonating a Google engineer). Engineers and technologists and real visionaries (not executive bikeshed painters) need to take technology back. Now. No fucking excuses. We are the good guys-- the bad guys are private equity douches with no business in our world-- but if we don't take back our industry, it and our work will be used for bad (as we see in the Bay Area) and we will be the ones to get the blame.
- visakanv 13y agoLove your passion. I see nothing mixed about your feelings. :p
- michaelochurch 13y agoI have mixed feelings, specifically, about the bus blockade. It hurts the wrong people. I love technology and there are a lot of wonderful people in this world, but I hate what has been done to it, mostly by MBA-culture outsiders who'd be better for the world (and make more money) as passive backers, but their ego gets in the way and they have to act as an executive caste. "Business" should be about creating value for all (including oneself) and not about wielding and accumulating power.
- LearnAndBurn 13y agoThis and yesterday's thread [1] are fascinating. Here we have lower-classes seeking direct retribution against higher-classes. Contrast to yesterday's article involving upper-classes discussing how to uplift lower-classes via social policy changes and enforcing certain belief doctrines, e.g., do XYZ, not ABC. Of course it's easier to rail against the the former camp than the latter; we all believe in some degree of property rights, i.e., you bare the fruit of your labor. However, I propose both positions are unjustified and both parties need to bow out of one another's business. Not trying to push libertarian beliefs (I am not one). But everyone is an asshole, out to serve their own ends, trying to sculpt the world in the way they would have it. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6885226 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6885226
- gnaritas 13y ago> One is punished for success via taxes, fees, fines, etc. by the "have nots" Care to explain that more, the tax system certainly does not punish the haves; it in fact rewards them. By the very nature of the marginal utility of money, the current tax rates hurt the have nots far more than the haves. The burden is quite simply not equally shared by all, it is born mostly by the have nots.
- LearnAndBurn 13y agoSorry, removed that piece from the original post as I feared it would detract from the main point. The use of "haves" versus "have nots" was intended as an example of divide and conquer. It was not intended as two distinct groups, with obviously distinguishable beliefs. Persons shift beliefs to exploit ends that are most beneficial to them. For other readers, he's referring to: > This is classic "Us versus Them" (divide and conquer) that systemically makes it worse for most everyone, especially the individual. One is punished for success via taxes, fees, fines, etc. by the "have nots"; while the "haves" punish you for practicing a different set of ideals or lifestyle choices that go against societal norm. Again, I meant to show an example. Whether the "haves" or "have nots" are in camp "punish by taxes" or camp "control lifestyle" is irrelevant. Persons shift between camps, when it's convenient. Similarly, all sorts of other camps exist towards other ends.
- robomartin 13y agoThis has nothing to do with dumb vs. smart, lazy vs. workaholic or privileged vs. unprivileged. It has to do with the fact that decisions in life have consequences. I can't help myself and have to quote a fantastic line from Star Wars: Your Focus Determines Your Reality. Coincidentally, I had a long conversation with my oldest son, now in High School, last night. He screwed up in a big way. He was given a book project a month ago. He had to read "To kill a mockingbird" and annotate it profusely. He read the book over several nights but procrastinated when it came to the annotation work. The work was due today. On Sunday he came to realize he made a big mistake. What did he do? He stayed up 'till 2:00AM every day to get the project done. He decided to do this on his own. Neither my wife nor I made him do it. He recognized his mistake and made the decision to right it entirely on his own. Up until yesterday afternoon we had no idea why he was working so hard. I have never been a micro-manager, professionally or at home. I assume and expect responsible behavior of others and, of course, try to lead by example. So I asked my kid if he really needed to stay up late doing this work and, when he said "yes" I just got out of the way and supported him by staying up, making tea and generally being there for him. I would get down to the bottom of it once he got done. He got done last night. We had a talk. He is getting an A in English. This was extra credit work he didn't need for grades and didn't really need to complete. Yet, he told me he had committed to doing the work and explained how sorry he was he procrastinated and to such a degree. I think my reaction surprised him. He's never screwed up on anything to this extent. He thought I might be angry or disappointed. The summary of a two hour conversation boils down to this: In life we are guaranteed to make bad or non-ideal decisions from time to time. Not one person is immune to this. What matters in life; what defines a man is how he chooses to deal with these mistakes. Some will cave in and sink into a dark hole of self pity and agony. Some will find every possible creative way to deflect the blame and rationalize what happened as being someone else's doing or fault. And yet others will look you straight in the eye, own the problem and do whatever is necessary to fix it. I said: "Son, you screwed up. You took responsibility for your actions and worked incredibly hard to make good on a promise you made to yourself and nobody else. You didn't need to do this for a grade. You already had an A. You did it because you are becoming a man with high values, morals, ethics and honor. I am proud." I almost cried when i said this. It is an incredible feeling as a parent to see your kids make the right decisions. In a country like the US the whole business of income inequality has two facets. The first is that of Liberal politicians manipulating the masses because it is far easier to get them worked-up en-masse with stuff like this and then you get their votes...by e millions. That's the nasty reality of the Liberal party: They benefit directly from low education voters' suffering because that is easy to convert to votes. This is the oldest trick in the books and it is not monopolized by US politics. I lived in Argentina for a while and learned quite a bit about their Politics and history. Evita was known for sending trucks into poor neighborhoods to give out blenders, refrigerators and other vote-buying crap. At the same time they kept the poor down because, not surprisingly, without them they'd get no votes. Things are not done the same way here but it really is the same. Pit the masses against the successful, throw them a bone here and there (minimum wage, union pay and pensions, etc.) sit back and collect the votes. It's sick. It's all about pandering and manipulation. The other aspect of the income inequality situation has to do with a massive change in the work ethic of the American worker and American youth over decades. We have devolved into an entitlement society where people want it all, don't want to work hard for it and everything is someone else's fault. When I owned an electronics manufacturing business I made it a point to hire students from the local junior college. I would say maybe one out of ten, if not twenty, had a reasonable work ethic. I had a couple who stole components and expensive tools (crimpers, etc.). Others screwed around and played on the Internet if nobody was watching. In general, most were down-right disappointing in their performance and attitude towards the job. A select few were absolutely exemplary. I have no doubt the will become valued members of society. What will become of the rest? Once they realize their mistakes in life, rather than work hard to correct them they will fall back on the simple idea of blaming it on others. They will undoubtedly become tools of the only political party that will roll down the street handing out virtual blenders and refrigerators. They will scream bloody murder at someone like my son who will get where he is going because he worked hard, made good decisions and, when he made bad ones he busted his ass to own and fix them. It's about the decisions you make in life and whether or not you are man (or woman) enough to own them. Your Focus Determines Your Reality.