3 ms·
Nutty by name, nutty by nature. Turns out he was working on "smart drugs" and had a vested interest in alcohol being restricted to boost his market! http://www
by gaius 13y ago
Nutty by name, nutty by nature. Turns out he was working on "smart drugs" and had a vested interest in alcohol being restricted to boost his market!
http://www.livescience.com/4060-hangover-free-buzz-star-trek-synthehol.html http://www.livescience.com/4060-hangover-free-buzz-star-trek...
- matthewmacleod 13y agoThe article you posted is from well before Nutt was kicked out of his post, and it was common knowledge that this was an interest of his. You've stooped to an ad-hominem, implying that Nutt's statistics are somehow faulty because he's got an interest in something which might "compete" with a drug he identifies as more harmful, without providing any evidence that he's wrong. That's slimy.
- gaius 13y agoOh come on. No one robs a granny to buy another single malt. There are people who abuse anything, sure. But it's a stretch to say alcohol is a net negative on society, millions of people enjoy a drink. But crack unquestionably is.
- mattgibson 13y agoIt's no stretch at all. If you read his article, they discriminate between 'bad for the users' (crack is worse) or 'bad for society' (alcohol is worse). http://www.theguardian.com/society/2010/nov/01/alcohol-more-harmful-than-heroin-crack http://www.theguardian.com/society/2010/nov/01/alcohol-more-... Alcohol is toxic to most major organs, is one of only a tiny number of drugs that can make normally passive people become violent, and is the world's most prolific date-rape drug. If you've ever seen the emergency room in a typical hospital on a Saturday night, you'd see that many of the millions who enjoy a drink get violent and antisocial, injuring themselves and others. Then there's domestic abuse, drunk driving, risky sex, etc etc. You'd need to take figures on all of those effects into account before deciding whether it's a 'stretch' or not. Which is exactly what Prof. Nutt did in his paper.
- matthewmacleod 13y agoThat's a total non sequitur, given that I was objecting to this silly personal attack. I do not believe that alcohol is a net negative to society. I'm pretty confident that crack cocaine is more damaging, especially to the individual user (and in fact you'll find that borne out by Nutt's research). However, while perhaps "nobody robs a granny to buy a single malt," alcohol can very obviously have damaging effects, especially if it's misused. Sexual assault and drunk driving are just two examples. That these exist does not mean that alcohol should be banned, and that crack is more damaging does not mean that the most effective tool to prevent it's use is criminalisation.
- aneisf 13y ago>Oh come on. No one robs a granny to buy another single malt. No, they rob granny to buy another bottle of $15 vodka.
- mattgibson 13y agoOr, he has a vested interest (as we all do) in reducing drug-related harm, and is trying to do so via any means possible. Developing a 'smart drug' that is as much fun as alcohol, but without the toxicity is probably the best way to try to accomplish this. Also, getting publicly sacked from your job is not great marketing, so seems inconsistent with the money-focused approach you are suggesting. However, it is entirely consistent with standing up for your belief in harm reduction above all else.
- auntienomen 13y agoNutt didn't advocate restrictions on alcohol use. He argued that it was absurd to make other drugs illegal when something as dangerous as alcohol is illegal. (By the way, if that last sentence is giving you cognitive dissonance, you need to stop and think hard about the statistics. The fact is that the most dangerous thing about pot, MDMA, LSD, and the like isn't their biochemistry. It's the fact that ignorant people have made them illegal.)
- gaius 13y agoWell, no, the dangerous thing is a second order effect of the being illegal, namely you've no way of knowing what you're actually buying. FWIW I'd like to see most drugs legalized and sold OTC at Boot's. But Nutt fundamentally failed to understand that a glass of wine with dinner or a pint after work - how most people actually drink most of the time - ARE inherently safer than pills.
- Nursie 13y ago>> But Nutt fundamentally failed to understand that a glass of wine with dinner or a pint after work - how most people actually drink most of the time - ARE inherently safer than pills. That depends what's in the pill, and how often there's a glass of wine, and if it's only ever one pint. Which I doubt. Binge drinking is a very popular passtime here in the UK and is very dangerous. Do you not think that when Prof Nutt makes these sorts of calculations they take this stuff into account? Or do you think he just pulls it all out of his arse?
- gaius 13y agoBinge drinking doesn't mean what you think it does. The recommended alcohol in units is per week recognising that people might drink more on a Friday night. Binge drinking is defined as weekly limit/7 x 2. So you can be a "binge drinker" even if you drink half your units and nothing any other night! The term is just a stupid thing Tony Bliar made up.
- 13y ago