8 ms·
Harder drugs are already legal - alcohol and tobacco. They were classified as more harmful in a study by professor David Nutt in the UK. He was then sacked as G
by collyw 13y ago
Harder drugs are already legal - alcohol and tobacco. They were classified as more harmful in a study by professor David Nutt in the UK. He was then sacked as Government adviser.
- Nursie 13y agoHe also said MDMA is safer than horse-riding. This annoyed the politicos no end, especially as a lot of them are from the horse-riding classes. It sounds like a flippant remark until you realise it was triggered by him knowing people who have died or become brain-damaged pursuing equestrian hobbies. He then did the statistical calculations and found out that the risks of horse-riding were higher but roughly comparable to those of MDMA use. People think MDMA is more dangerous mostly because of intense press coverage when someone does die from it. When was the last time you saw "girl dies in tragic polo accident" on the front page?
- hrkristian 13y agoI understand the sentiment, but lets not get away from ourselves here, there is a huge difference between acquiring skills through physical activities and ingesting chemicals for a short period of bliss.
- widdershins 13y agoNot in terms of risk there isn't, at least in this case.
- Nursie 13y agoNo, no there's not. Both are leisure activities some people choose to indulge in, and they have similar risk profiles. I'm not sure what you mean by 'getting away from ourselves', but considering one worthy and the other not is purely subjective and I would say prejudicial.
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoHorse riding is a leisure activity. Any "skill" involved is objectively useless and unproductive. (Disclaimer: I've used horses recreationally. No, I did not inhale. I do not recommend inhaling. They smell bad.)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- diydsp 13y agoThe "difference" is in your values, not in the responsibility of governments. You value acquiring physical intelligence. You do not value spiritual exploration. FWIW, MDMA is not "bliss" and it's not "short." It's longer than your average horse-ride, and it's much more complicated than simple bliss (as I've read in numerous reports on erowid.org) It is the government's responsibility to protect us through sharing appropriate information [1], not to ruin our lives through imprisonment when we undertake solo activities with no risk to others. BTW, I'm not even an MDMA enthusiast. I just don't feel like it, too busy, but for those who want to, I just want them to be safe, have their stuff tested, etc. [1] So, why are articles like "Death rates from ecstasy (MDMA, MDA) and polydrug use in England and Wales 1996–2002" [2] only available through a paywall!! [2] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14533133 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/14533133
- orasis 13y agoPsychedelics are more effective at acquiring useful knowledge about reality and consciousness than horse-back riding.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Nursie 13y agoYes, that was kinda the point of the rest of my post!
- alan_cx 13y agoIt really annoys me that people who get things wrong feel the need to delete their post, rather than just reply saying something like, "Ooops, sorry, your right." Why is that so hard?
- jaredmcateer 13y agoI suspect some of the reason is that even admitting your mistake it often won't save you from getting down-voted.
- vidarh 13y agoEven when you do see "girl dies in tragic polo accident", compare that to "girl dies after taking illegal drugs", and the expected slant on the respective articles. The former would likely be framed exactly as a tragic unavoidable accident that is not her fault, while in the latter chances are good the article will be full of comments from people who can't understand how she could have possible fallen so low as to take dangerous drugs, and implicitly it is her fault, and she had clearly gone from being a good girl to a bad girl and that is how she ended up dying. Coupled with some blurbs about how many people use drugs and recent deaths and statements about what a problem it is. Imagine if the "girl dies in tragic polo accident" was slanted the same way, and listed recent horse riding accidents and interviews with people warning about how more and more young people ride horses...
- klinquist 13y agoI often tell people there is a similar disconnect (yet similar risk) between motorcycle riding and skiing. Break a leg on a bike and you shouldn't have been doing that dangerous thing! Break a leg skiing? Oh man bummer! Hope I see you on the slopes next season!
- mseebach 13y agoYou have to get back on the horse that bucked you.
- diydsp 13y agoHahaha. It makes me laugh/cringe to think of the "risks." Risk #1 - You may hurt yourself Risk #2 - You may discover the emperor wears no clothes and you don't have to spend your life in servitude to the ruling classes. Which one does the government _really_ fear?
- gph 13y agoIf you can't discover #2 without drugs... I don't know if you're really understanding anything.
- Nursie 13y agoYeah, I find this whole meme quite weird. There seem to be a fairly large group of people that are convinced that some or other drug will 'open up' the minds of the populace, we'll all somehow 'realise' that we're being screwed by the man, suddenly everything will be awesome and we'll all live in harmony. It's about as convincing as "and they all lived happily ever after" at the end of a fairytale.
- diydsp 13y agoi am one of those people who believes that, only I don't think it's as simple as 1. take drugs, 2. figure out we're slaves. 3. ??? 4. Profit. There are a great number of activities which slowly, in turn, help reveal that all power is within ourselves. Basically, any activity which takes us by surprise, including psychedelics but also including extreme sports, international travel. Hell, reading a good book. and it's not as easy as realizing it to get out of the trap. that's like saying is easy to become an entrepreneur. it's about spending the rest of one's life devoted to seeking reality....
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Nursie 13y agoPersonally I think that psychedelics, particularly the very famous ergot derivative, are very good at inducing a false sense of the profound. >>All power is within ourselves >>Spending the rest of one's life devoted to seeking reality... And these are exactly the sorts of meaningless profundities I was talking about!
- bonemachine 13y agoHere's the article at which the horse-riding classes took such umbrage, btw: Equasy – An overlooked addiction with implications for the current debate on drug harms. DJ Nutt Psychopharmacology Unit, University of Bristol, Bristol, UK. Journal of Psychopharmacology 23(1) (2009) 3 – 5 http://www.synchronium.net/2009/11/02/equasy/ http://www.synchronium.net/2009/11/02/equasy/ Non-statistical anecdote: in my own acquaintance, I've known countless people who have taken MDMA, but never has my attention been called to the fact that any of them suffered from an acute harm episode as a result. However, I do know someone -- very respected in his field -- who suffered from not only permanent nerve damage, but (obviously) noticeable personality changes due to the use (or overuse -- doesn't matter) of painkillers after a rather nasty fall from a horse.
- swah 13y agoCome on, its not like I rob my mother to have another IPA. But the crack cocaine problem in Brazil on the other hand... the drug does seem to make people "crazy" quickly (or its all a media play).
- Nursie 13y agoSome people do though, alcohol addiction is a real problem for some people, and booze kills quite a lot of folks. You're right, though, crack and some others seem to have horrific addiction profiles and I've even heard of Brazilian drug-lords forbidding its sale in their territory because it destroys any sort of community stability and kills the market. I do wonder if many people would bother getting started with crack if other drugs were open to them. I also think that if there wasn't the criminal stigma we could help more of them, sooner. There's no perfect solution, but what we have isn't working.
- lewaldman 13y agoI really believe that the solution to the crack problem would be to provide, for free, crack to crack addicts on controled environment, with controled doses, with a medical staff ready to act in case an emergency, and with the added option to get treatment. I know it will sound a little bit... hmmm... not-what-a-good-guy-would-say but, with this kind of policy in 10 years most of addicts would be dead, dying or getting treatment. It's a darwin-aware policy that would remove the main problems with crack: Drug traffic and crazy killer zombies on the streets.
- Nursie 13y ago>> I know it will sound a little bit... hmmm... not-what-a-good-guy-would-say but, with this kind of policy in 10 years most of addicts would be dead, dying or getting treatment. Unsure. People say this stuff about heroin addicts too, but the truth with them is that, when provided with the sort of service you're talking about, they tend to be able to live normal-ish lives and a reasonable proportion eventually kick the habit. I get the impression that crack (even medically pure) is way more damaging to the body though, so you might (sadly) be right. At least there would be less crime to fund the habit, and we could get help to more of them.
- gaius 13y agoNutty by name, nutty by nature. Turns out he was working on "smart drugs" and had a vested interest in alcohol being restricted to boost his market! http://www.livescience.com/4060-hangover-free-buzz-star-trek-synthehol.html http://www.livescience.com/4060-hangover-free-buzz-star-trek...
- matthewmacleod 13y agoThe article you posted is from well before Nutt was kicked out of his post, and it was common knowledge that this was an interest of his. You've stooped to an ad-hominem, implying that Nutt's statistics are somehow faulty because he's got an interest in something which might "compete" with a drug he identifies as more harmful, without providing any evidence that he's wrong. That's slimy.
- gaius 13y agoOh come on. No one robs a granny to buy another single malt. There are people who abuse anything, sure. But it's a stretch to say alcohol is a net negative on society, millions of people enjoy a drink. But crack unquestionably is.
- mattgibson 13y agoIt's no stretch at all. If you read his article, they discriminate between 'bad for the users' (crack is worse) or 'bad for society' (alcohol is worse). http://www.theguardian.com/society/2010/nov/01/alcohol-more-harmful-than-heroin-crack http://www.theguardian.com/society/2010/nov/01/alcohol-more-... Alcohol is toxic to most major organs, is one of only a tiny number of drugs that can make normally passive people become violent, and is the world's most prolific date-rape drug. If you've ever seen the emergency room in a typical hospital on a Saturday night, you'd see that many of the millions who enjoy a drink get violent and antisocial, injuring themselves and others. Then there's domestic abuse, drunk driving, risky sex, etc etc. You'd need to take figures on all of those effects into account before deciding whether it's a 'stretch' or not. Which is exactly what Prof. Nutt did in his paper.
- 13y ago
- ilitirit 13y agoThis is the same guy who claims he has created a type of alcohol without the negative side-effects associated with it: http://www.mnn.com/health/fitness-well-being/stories/david-nutts-new-drug-mimics-alcohol-minus-the-health-risks-and http://www.mnn.com/health/fitness-well-being/stories/david-n... I'm not deriding him in any way (I hope he is successful with this product). Just thought I'd mention it.
- Nursie 13y agoGiven he is one of the UK's leading scientific minds in this area, and chaired the government's Advisory Committee on the Misuse of Drugs until he fell out of favour, it's really not that unbelievable. There are already other known alcohols that don't metabolise in the same way as ethanol and don't result in hangovers. I'm not sure they're 'safe'. It's possible that Prof. Nutt is talking about a benzodiazepine derivative he's working on, though finding one without the addiction potential of its class would be hard work. And it's entirely possible he's just trolling :) His book, "Drugs Without the Hot Air" is well worth reading. It contains some of the basic neuroscience behind drug actions, explores a lot of societal stuff and, in general was just a good read, if you're genuinely interested in this stuff.
- collyw 13y agoLoads of illegal drugs give less of a "hangover" than alcohol. Cannabis maybe leaves you a little slow the next day for example, but no pain.
- pstuart 13y agoNot a new type of alcohol, but a new drug that would give an effect similar to alcohol. GHB was touted as alcohol 2.0 but is now illegal for being a "date-rape drug". The irony here is that alcohol is already the leading date-rape drug.
- wavefunction 13y agoGHB _is_ alcohol 2.0. The real irony is it's only really effective as a date-rape drug in conjunction with alcohol.
- transfire 13y agoOne size does not fit all. People of Native American decedent are less prone to ailments caused by tobacco. Where as they are more prone to Alcoholism. We need to stop downgrading our freedoms to fit some abstract unit-human.