3 ms·
Basically, America is separating into aristocrats and peasants. There's one very, very important difference: aristocrats were generally in a heritable position
by jseliger 13y ago
Basically, America is separating into aristocrats and peasants.
There's one very, very important difference: aristocrats were generally in a heritable position that couldn't be taken from them, and peasants were generally in a heritable position from which they couldn't rise. In the U.S., at least, relatively wealthy / successful people can fall and relatively poor / unsuccessful people can rise. In classic feudal societies, this was basically impossible without revolutions.
To be honest, I have no idea what will do the trick. There is unlikely to be another WW2, another G.I. bill, another 50s-type broad-based economic boom.
This is really true, and it's arguably the most important part of this blog post, of Tyler Cowen's recent book Average is Over, and in many of the more honest discussions by people who are trying to get a handle of what's going on in the larger world.
- smtddr 13y ago>>There's one very, very important difference: aristocrats were generally in a heritable position that couldn't be taken from them, and peasants were generally in a heritable position from which they couldn't rise. In the U.S., at least, relatively wealthy / successful people can fall and relatively poor / unsuccessful people can rise. In classic feudal societies, this was basically impossible without revolutions. That's true for now. But the way things are heading; the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. The barrier dividing the 2 gets a little harder to cross every year.
- Spooky23 13y agoYou're right -- Ye olden aristocrats had land, and land produced rents and taxes. Today's plutocrats aren't in as stable a position as a feudal lord, but many are in effect landlords, either literally or figuratively via control of critical businesses. The postwar US was a totally different story. Europe and Asia's losses were our gain. The government had billions of dollars in off book debt, (ie. social security trust fund) and used that capital to launch the computer revolution. Will it happen again? I wouldn't dismiss it... No nation is more strategically embedded in the new information economy than the US. At the end of the day, the US is the devil the world knows and needs.
- userulluipeste 13y ago"At the end of the day, the US is the devil the world knows and needs." Probably easy to grasp and agree with this political thought when you're being part of the US, bot otherwise... could you elaborate?
- Spooky23 13y agoThe US provides order. The seaways, markets, etc are largely what they are due to US power. Sort of like the British Empire v2. Consider 2013 vs 1913. A 21st century WW1 scenario could be set off by some two bit nuclear power like Pakistan without US dominance. Everything isn't all roses, but I think the net impact is positive.
- jshen 13y agoEconomic mobility is declining in the US. So which rung of the ladder you are born on is having a greater influence on where you end up.