3 ms·
The whole idea is to further display and reinforce your own splendour, adding subtle peer-pressure to everybody else. Kinda like academic publishing, right? Pr
by nl 13y ago
The whole idea is to further display and reinforce your own splendour, adding subtle peer-pressure to everybody else.
Kinda like academic publishing, right? Pretty sure the Erdos number[1] was around well before Academia.edu.
To make it clear - I think a lot of Academia.edu's practices are annoying - login wall for papers etc. But academia would be well served if it took better advantage of some of the possibilities online collaboration brought (think of the Polymath projects). CiteULike/arxiv cannot be the high point of online academic publishing.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erd%C5%91s_number http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erd%C5%91s_number
- rmk2 13y agoThe thing is, not all strands of academia have collaboration even as a central focus. I don't see it very often in the humanities that articles or books have multiple collaborators. The normal thing is either the article or monograph written by an individual. The other option are journals or collections made up of these kinds of articles. Sure, it's not unheard of that people collaborate, but even bigger projects usually follow the idea that what you publish is yours, so you are more likely to see a publication series with individual volumes by different people, or the above mentioned collections, where (maybe!) introductions or overviews are written collaboratively. This has partly to do with the dreadful "tooling" in many cases, i.e. in most cases Word with handwritten citations. If you are lucky, people use Endnote or Zotero. If you are really lucky, you might encounter somebody who knows what (Open|Libre) Office is. Your options for collaborations are thus: Google Docs (if people can manage the technical complexity) or mailing around Word files.