3 ms·
How would you have come up with an X and Y at the start of tulip mania?
by dllthomas 13y ago
How would you have come up with an X and Y at the start of tulip mania?
- baddox 13y agoI'm not saying I could have, but I would expect anyone making a definitive claim that it's a bubble to also produce a testable hypothesis.
- dllthomas 13y agoI don't want to discourage that, by any means. I just am not sure "knowing it is a bubble" necessarily means knowing much about how it is going to burst.
- baddox 13y agoWell, if it never bursts (for some definition of "never"), then it's not really a bubble, right? If the claim that something is a bubble isn't testable in some bounded time period, then it's not a meaningful claim.
- dllthomas 13y agoMaybe. Let's simplify our model a bit. Let's say we have a bag of devices of two types. Both kinds of devices, you push a button and a light turns on. One type of device (type A), the light stays on forever (we're ignoring physics for now). The other type of device (type B), the device has a mechanism to randomly turn itself off, calibrated such that over any 10 minute span of time where the device starts "on" there is a 10% chance it turns the light off. You pull a device out of the bag. You push the button. The light turns on. Is "this is a type B device" a meaningful claim?
- baddox 13y ago"This is a type B device" has more meaning than "Bitcoin is a bubble" because "type B device" is well-defined whereas "bubble" isn't. Of course, since the well-defined attributes of type B devices involves probability, the testability is also limited to probabilistic negative conclusions, i.e. we cannot conclude with 100% confidence that a light which remains lit is not a type B device. This probabilistic nature is the key difference between your analogy and Bitcoin. For the analogy to be perfect, we would have to create a well-defined notion of what a "bubble" is that involves probability.
- diminoten 13y agoMy claim was not specifically that Bitcoin is experiencing a bubble, but really more that not many people would argue that Bitcoin is experiencing a bubble. I did also say Bitcoin is experiencing a bubble, but for reasons you're suggesting, I won't defend that claim. It's a belief, and while somewhat justified, it's not necessarily true and not fully justified.