4 ms·
I'm curious, as a publicly traded company, why are these specific earnings not public? Presumably this would be a crucial element in any valuation of Microsoft
by crazygringo 13y ago
I'm curious, as a publicly traded company, why are these specific earnings not public? Presumably this would be a crucial element in any valuation of Microsoft shares, since it would affect the future value of Microsoft in relation to Android market share.
Forgive me for my ignorance, but what determines the level of scrutiny that a publicly traded company has to make available, in terms of its sources of revenue? How far do they get broken down, either by law/regulation or by custom?
- WildUtah 13y agoYou can read Microsoft's SEC filings.[0] As is typical for large public companies, nothing very useful can be gleaned from these filings about any business smaller than Windows or Office licensing (maybe XBox?). Everything else is buried in noise. And the SEC is really more interested in seeing the regular boilerplate than informing investors. It would take extraordinary leadership to make any large regulator operate in a more truly informative way. [0] http://www.microsoft.com/investor/SEC/default.aspx http://www.microsoft.com/investor/SEC/default.aspx
- tedunangst 13y agoIf investors really wanted to know, they could make a big stink about it and MS would release more detailed numbers. But the investors have (quite rightly, imo) decided the precise breakdown doesn't affect the quality of the investment. On the other hand, announcing to all of your competitors exactly how you make your money and from which products seems like a poor strategy.
- tanzam75 13y ago> Forgive me for my ignorance, but what determines the level of scrutiny that a publicly traded company has to make available, in terms of its sources of revenue? How far do they get broken down, either by law/regulation or by custom? Companies are only required to provide an aggregate financial statement. They are not required to provide a line-item breakdown. They're not even required to provide a breakdown by division, although companies usually supply that. There is no convention. Two different companies in the same industry may provide different breakdowns. Typically, companies provide the same breakdown that they have historically provided in the past. However, as they grow, they tend to roll things up into ever-larger chunks. So you lose some granularity.