5 ms·
Wait, seriously? That's it? that's the patent MS uses to force cellphone manufacturers to pay them for Android? The Dos 8.3 / long filenames thing? That's i
by Pxtl 13y ago
Wait, seriously? That's it? that's the patent MS uses to force cellphone manufacturers to pay them for Android? The Dos 8.3 / long filenames thing? That's insane. It's the obvious solution and not terribly hard to implement in the first place. The pseudocode for this would be like 5 lines.
- ProblemFactory 13y agoMost amusingly, it was Linus Torvalds who published the same solution in a mailing list 4 years before the patent was filed: https://groups.google.com/forum/#!searchin/comp.os.minix/long$20filenames/comp.os.minix/0rgZpprg_Eo/i52eYrwT7wkJ https://groups.google.com/forum/#!searchin/comp.os.minix/lon...
- derekp7 13y agoWhat is even more strange, is that modern Android phones (at least the Nexus line) don't support mounting the internal memory as a fat-32 device -- they use MTP or PTP for file transfers. So as far as I can tell, there is no reason for them to use fat-32 internally anymore. Or am I missing something?
- delinka 13y agoOf course, they still need to implement FAT-32 if they ever want to mount SD cards that are interoperable with other phones, cameras, etc.
- Mindless2112 13y agoRecent Nexus devices are incapable of this because they lack an SD card slot.
- JohnTHaller 13y agoWhich is one reason why the entire Nexus series, Moto G/X, HTC One, etc don't support SD cards. That and Google wanting everyone to use the cloud.
- Pxtl 13y agoWhat happens if you plug in an SD reader or a FAT-formatted USB stick into the USB port via OTG? That would still require support for FAT in the OS.
- josteink 13y agoIt would, but on a default, non-CM Android-build it would also require you to run StickMount or OTGHelper to mount it somewhere where the apps and OS will be able to use it. And for that you may or may not need root. And if you're already there, why not just use a custom kernel (with FAT support) while you're at it?
- wvenable 13y agoPretty big leap from root to a custom kernel. But on my Nexus 7 with root and stickmount, the stock kernel does support mounting FAT drives. So support is baked in there.
- zmmmmm 13y agoI guess it comes down to, when you have to jump through enough steps, some of them unauthorised and requiring the user to install additional software, in court you can make a reasonable argument that you are not selling the device with that functionality enabled, therefore you aren't liable for patent infringement.
- rtpg 13y agoIs this why a lot of phones stopped having sd card slots? That is probably the single most frustrating regression in tech for me ( I use my phone as an MP3 player).
- derekp7 13y agoThere's actually a couple other reasons, in addition to the unstated reason of avoiding the FAT patent. First, if you put in a cheap (yet large capacity) SD card in a device, then it will take an extremely long time to index the files on it (such as getting the id3 tags out of the mp3 files). That in turn makes the phone appear to be a low-quality device for a lot of users. Now add onto that the current trend that the user doesn't need to know where files are stored (they aren't stored on devices or file folders, they are associated with specific applications), then you have a usability problem.
- tanzam75 13y ago> Wait, seriously? That's it? that's the patent MS uses to force cellphone manufacturers to pay them for Android? No, that is not "the" patent. That is one patent. Microsoft has more. They also have patents that they're not even revealing, because they like to do blanket cross-licenses. One could argue that it is Microsoft's strongest patent, and therefore its loss puts their patent revenues at risk. This is a version of the Oracle/Google scenario, but for patents rather than for copyright. On the other hand, one could also argue that it is Microsoft's weakest patent, which they threw out there as a sacrificial lamb. Any patent that they revealed would be subject to intense scrutiny. Thus, it's safer to use a large number of trivial patents rather than a small number of more involved patents. (Especially if the legal system is so broken that both types of patents have an equal chance of prevailing. If it's totally random, then you don't gain anything by using a stronger patent.) This would be the IBM/Sun scenario. IBM went to Sun and claimed that they were violating a patent. Sun replied that the IBM patent was obvious, so it would easily get struck down. Then the IBM lawyer pointed out that IBM had tens of thousands of patents. If Sun could get this one patent struck down, then IBM could just repeat the process with another patent, and they'd never run out. So in the end, Sun ended up buying a blanket license for all of IBM's patents.