4 ms·
I've been getting around this lately... While I'm working, I contribute the max I can to retirement savings (RSP, 401k, whatever it's called in your country) s
by grecy 13y ago
I've been getting around this lately...
While I'm working, I contribute the max I can to retirement savings (RSP, 401k, whatever it's called in your country) so I reduce my taxable income by that amount.
In the years I'm not working (don't want to, travel, etc.), I take money out of those retirement savings. If I take out less than the tax-free threshold ($10k/yr in Canada) I pay no tax on that money. If I take out more, it will be less than I earned in my working years, so I'll be in a lower tax bracket anyway.
In this way I'm averaging out the taxes I pay over many years, and it takes out the spikes and dips from working/not-working years.
The only downside to this is that once you've taken money out, you can't get that money back again onto your yearly contribution cap, so when I'm old and grey, my retirement savings likely won't be as high as they otherwise would be (but I don't believe in that anyway, so for me, it's not valid)
- maxerickson 13y agoIn the U.S., lots of tax advantaged accounts have withdrawal penalties. (I guess the notable exception is that contributions to a Roth IRA can be withdrawn with no penalty. Earnings would all face the penalty)
- grecy 13y ago>In the U.S., lots of tax advantaged accounts have withdrawal penalties. What's the penalty? Lots of people think that of tax-free retirement savings (and people keep warning me of it) but in fact, the only penalty I've ever heard of is you must pay tax on that money along with other income.. so if you do it in a regular earning year, you pay lots of income tax. Do it in a year when you earn nothing else, and you pay none or very little. That's not a penalty
- maxerickson 13y agoGenerally, 10% extra tax.
- grecy 13y ago10% extra than what? Let's say I don't earn any other income in a year and pull out $5k. What's my tax rate? Let's say I pull out exactly the tax-free threshold. What's my tax rate? (I ask for the clarification because here in Canada, they withhold a very large amount of whatever you take out.. because they are assuming you have other income. It all comes back at tax time though, based on whatever other income you do have. So I ask because I'm wondering if they force the 10% on you, or if they just withhold it and you can get it back at tax time)
- maxerickson 13y agoIt is an additional 10% tax above whatever other taxes you would owe on that money. I'm not an expert, it isn't obscure, you're better off searching if you still don't believe me. Try "401k early withdrawal penalty".
- grecy 13y agoA quick google shows it's 10% more tax than you would have paid, when included with your other income. If this withdrawal is your only income, and you keep the withdrawal below the tax-free limit (looks to be $9k), you won't pay any tax, and thus won't pay the 10% penalty either.
- maxerickson 13y agoThe 10% is figured based on the amount of the distribution, not AGI. (For 2012, it's reported on line 58 of the 1040...)
- grecy 13y agoI'm not American, I need you to explain that please.
- maxerickson 13y ago