10 ms·
Google employee shouts down protesters as they block private Google shuttle
- rtpg 13y agokinda depressing that all the money that companies pay for these buses couldn't simply be used to offer better service in the public system. Maybe BART could offer bus rental services for companies wanting these lines? At the very least it would help to pay for infrastructure for the rest of us. Maybe I'm biased by the fact that I've lived in cities with usable public transportation
- nostrademons 13y agoThere may be a bureaucracy problem rather than a funding problem. When Google pays a shuttle company directly, everybody is incentivized to make everything move smoothly: Google benefits from having its employees get to work on time, the employees benefit from having free wifi and not having to drive in rush-hour traffic, and the private companies that provide the buses get Google's money and have a strong incentive to keep their business. In the public system, the people who run the program are often very different from the people who use the program, and so if it's a mess, they're like "Eh, I get to keep my government job." It's interesting that the cities with decent public transportation - Boston, NYC, DC - all have strong cultures of public transportation and large percentages of people that don't have a car. It's very likely that the transportation commissioner in NYC takes the subway to work; it's somewhat less likely that whoever runs the buses in SF takes them to work.
- calbear81 13y agoThe problem is that BART doesn't go down to Mountain View. You have to do a transfer at Milbrae to Caltrain and your fares end up adding up to $20+ for a round trip which is more than the cost of gas for the same trip. When I lived in the Inner Sunset, trying to take public transportation to my job in Mountain View (not at the G) meant hopping on an N-Judah for 30 minutes to get to the Caltrain station then sitting on a Caltrain for 45 minutes to 69 minutes (depending on train) which adds to 1 1/2 hours each way not to mention having to deal with the Muni and having a Caltrain person wake you up to "see your ticket".
- nostrademons 13y agoCaltrain is actually faster than the G-Bus with recent Bay Area traffic - it's not unusual to sit on 101 for 2 hours for the SF -> Google commute. A number of Googlers have recently switched from shuttle to Caltrain, eating the cost out of pocket, which may be more sustainable in the long run but in the short run is putting a strain on Caltrain capacity.
- rtpg 13y ago2 hours? Is living in SF really that great? Or is there just nothing interesting close to Google?
- nostrademons 13y agoI don't personally think it's worth it - I live 2 miles away from the Googleplex, and bike to work weather/schedule-permitting. But a number of my coworkers just really want to live in the city. I think it's a generational thing - the majority of people my generation seem to prefer city living.
- pmiller2 13y agoPublic transportation starts looking a lot better if you have to pay for parking. It would take me roughly $12 in gas for the round trip in my car, so if I have to pay $10 for parking for the day (which would be cheap by SF standards, though I don't know how it would rate in Mountain View), I come out ahead monetarily taking Caltrain. It still might not be worth it in light of other inconveniences, though.
- ryanobjc 13y agoAre you sure about that? I wonder how much the shuttle system costs Google. It's hard to say for certain, but its probably in the millions of dollars a year. Now, let's contrast that to the BART extension to SFO, which was completed in 2002 and cost $1.5 billion for 8.7 miles of new track. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Bay_Area_Rapid_Transit#San_Francisco_International_Airport_extension http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Bay_Area_Rapid_T...) Extending BART service to San Jose (which is hardly a politically trivial affair) would cost a few bucks to say the least. There is also the east-side extension which would compete with a west-side extension: http://www.bart.gov/about/projects/wsx http://www.bart.gov/about/projects/wsx Unfortunately companies can't really just give money to the government to do their pet projects. It's been tried before and it kind of ends up poorly.
- mathattack 13y agoCould the anger be that companies aren't paying as much taxes as they used to, and hence there's not enough money for BART to be fixed? I'm not saying this is or isn't the case, just trying to get inside the mind of the protesters.
- hnriot 13y agoisn't the answer obvious. Google can call a bus company and have a solution in place in a day, or contribute billions to a goverment project that will take 15 years to finish (just look at BART, SJ light rail etc etc)
- theorique 13y agokinda depressing that all the money that companies pay for these buses couldn't simply be used to offer better service in the public system. Very different pools of money.
- tibbon 13y agoI don't live in SF, and I really don't fully understand the issues at hand here. But from what I've seen, writing checks to public transit systems (like the MBTA here in Boston) is a sure way to make sure that nothing ever happens. Case in point, the "Green Line Extension" has been talked about for dozens of years now, and funded many times. They keep losing/wasting the money. I don't think Google wants to wait 10-30 years for the Bart system to catch up with their needs (if ever at all). But I also don't understand why a company providing private shuttles is such a polarizing idea. No one gets bent about hotel shuttles or ones at convention centers, and putting more people in a shuttle is far better than each of them individually driving.
- ocfx 13y agoGoogle employee has a point...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- objclxt 13y agoNo, he doesn't. Although I suspect here on HN there will be a segment - hopefully a small one - of people who agree with him. Gentrification is not always bad, but this guy's arguments are. Breaking down some of them: > You can't afford it? You can leave. I'm sorry, get a better job That isn't how it works in the real world. People can't 'just leave'. If you seriously think moving to a more affordable city is an option for everyone you are sadly mistaken. I don't think I really need to go into why "just move" is very naive argument. > "I'm sorry, get a better job." Again, this isn't how life works. If it was so easy to 'get a better job' we'd all be out doing it. > "This is a city for the right people who can afford it." Who are "the right people"? Who gets to dictate who can and cannot live in a city? Many people being priced out of San Francisco have lived there for generations, far longer than people moving to work in tech. Why are the latter "the right people" but not the former? I am not saying I totally agree with the protestors, either. Gentrification in general brings many positives and negatives. It's a tricky balance. There are good arguments to be made on either side - "if you don't like it, just move" is not one of them. "You're not the right people" is even worse.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jamiequint 13y agoThe "right people" are the ones who can afford it, its not anyone's god given right to live in a particular place of their choosing.
- crbnw00ts 13y ago> Who are "the right people"? Who gets to dictate who can and cannot live in a city? Not that I agree with the guy in the video in any way, but I 100% •guarantee* the protestors (and the writers at the Guardian for that matter) have their own ideas about who the "right people" people are to live in SF, and that these ideas are not exactly absent from their motivations when protesting or discussing these issues.
- logjam 13y agoI regularly drive down 19th Avenue in SF. Just south of Geary, the Google bus regularly parks blocking one lane of 19th Avenue for extended periods of time (tens of minutes) apparently waiting for employees to board, and creating a traffic jam on 19th Avenue behind it. I'm not sure why the bus has to stop on 19th Avenue, as there are numerous side streets it could stop on -- and not one of the major north-south thoroughfares in west SF. The difference with Muni buses, of course, is that they stop, let people off/on, and then get out of the way almost immediately. I'm not sure why the rest of us are waiting on Google employees for extended periods. EDIT: I'm not sure how some of the peanut gallery here is reading anti-public-transportation sentiment into my comment. I'm a big fan of BART and Muni and use them regularly. What I'm marveling over is why Google employees and/or their bus driver(s) can't seem to tell time sufficiently well to not require illegally blocking a major SF thoroughfare for extended periods of time. The Google bus blocks and delays Muni and other forms of public transportation on 19th Avenue just as effectively as it blocks autos. Muni doesn't do that.
- yannk 13y agoI hope whatever comes out of this mess, is some positive change for everyone. I'm annoyed at shuttles (not sure which company) at the Caltrain station which park in the townsend st. bike lane every single evening, making it dangerous for cyclists. This intersection is sufficiently messy as it is.
- mathattack 13y agoHaving dual modes of transportation does drive people nuts. In NYC it's the black SUV motorcades that sometimes double park on streets. I would love to see the solution being Google using Big Data to improve SF traffic.
- qq66 13y agoAlso, the MUNI buses are authorized to stop in the bus stops. I'm not opposed to private buses, but they should have to pay for the right to use public streets to transact their business, just as businesses operating in Central Park have to pay for their locations.
- yannk 13y agoI feel sorry for this employee who created a PR disaster this early in the week...
- calbear81 13y agoHe'll probably become a meme soon. I can already see a t-shirt with his face and "Let them eat cake" emblazoned over it.
- yannk 13y agohuh? Allegedly it's a fake employee. https://twitter.com/torrez/status/410138380690022402 https://twitter.com/torrez/status/410138380690022402
- spiek 13y agoEh? Torrez says "@edcasey If last week taught us anything it is that everything on the internet is fake. So I am covering my bases." Doesn't seem like he is seriously alleging that this guy is a plant.
- calbear81 13y agoI don't see how planting a fake would make sense at all to their cause. They might get a temporary bump from outrage at the insensitivity of the Google employee but once Google starts to investigate and figures out that this wasn't an employee you bet your ass the local protestors will lose credibility.
- protomyth 13y agoYou would think that wouldn't you. Unfortunately anyone who followed the Tea Party or Occupy can tell you that the follow-up truth has a low chance of getting reported. Some of the most amazing "true" stories about both were proven false but not as widely reported. If it isn't the first tweet or video on youtube, then it doesn't really matter. For an interesting example, follow the case of the waitress who claimed to have not been tipped and hateful message left. The initial claim was widely reported, the follow-up about it being a lie doesn't quite seem to have reached the same major outlets with the same coverage time. "this wasn't an employee you bet your ass the local protestors will lose credibility" I doubt they will. Its all about the noise and creditability isn't tracked very well. Too, many groups (or new names replacing the old) and not enough knowledge about the membership connections.
- calbear81 13y agoYelling "this is the right city for the people who can afford it" is definitely not going to help. Maybe the recent real estate buys from Google aren't for office space but for private residences designed to house Google employees instead? Given the price for housing and the lack of decent modern housing in the South Bay (all the new condos for rent are priced as high as SF places), wouldn't having private below-market housing available to employees be a major perk that will also yield more work output in off hours?
- sp332 13y agoIf anyone's wondering, the bus is more of a symbol than a real problem to the protesters. The issues caused by rich tech employees changing the city and ignoring poorer people have been discussed here before. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5189580 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5189580 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5665437 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5665437
- cromwellian 13y agoIf there is one constant, it's that cities will change. You change the demographics, ethnicity, nationality, or language distribution, you get change. Where is it written that people have a right to live in an unchanging world? The same things these people are complaining about are the same thing old Southern white racists complain about -- this becoming a minority majority country. These people wanted America to be a Ollie and Harriet whitebread nuclear family country, and diversity increased and changed the culture. "Poor culture" is not intrinsically more valuable than "rich tech culture", it's just different, and there's no a priori justification that one groups has a set of preferences and rights that supercedes the others. The anti - gentrification people are cultural conservatives and don't realize it.
- sp332 13y agoAre you really so "progressive" that you think people should roll over and die as soon as someone richer moves into town? There has been a recent rash of evictions by landlords hoping to cash in on the influx of Googlers. That means people are literally homeless heading in to the winter because they can't compete for housing.
- cromwellian 13y agoIt is not the fault of the people seeking the housing. When gas prices went up a number of years ago due to a surge in demand from China,should we "roll over and die as soon as Chinese start driving more cars?" Other people's demand for products drive up prices if there is a supply constraint, in what moral code can you blame them for desiring what you have? In the case of SF, there are people who want to live there. That demand drives up the probability that landlords will want to raise rent, and if they can't because of rent control, arrange an eviction. What should tech workers do? Realize that the people currently living in SF have some kind of nativist right to live there and new immigrants to the city are persona non grata? I'm not even sure we should blame landlords for wanting to raise rents. I'm sure if you owned a house in the city, and someone was willing to offer you 10x the current rent controlled price you're collecting, you'd be seriously questioning how 'progressive' you feel towards your tenants. San Francisco has demand that outstrips supply. Either increase supply, or recognize that the city is going to continue to get more expensive to live in. San Francisco cannot escape the fate of London and other cities in this respect.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- philip1209 13y agoI do not understand why people are protesting that a bus is being used to replace 50 cars that would take up parking, cause additional congestion, and be far more polluting.
- hbags 13y agoThe cars wouldn't block the lane of a major artery for long periods of time, as per https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6876464 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6876464
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bronbron 13y agoHey, yet again, citizens arguing at each other instead of focusing their anger towards the government. If the bay area had decent public transportation, these buses wouldn't exist. You know how google employees from Westchester get to work in Chelsea? They take the train + subway. Because it isn't completely terrible. That being said, this guy is obviously doing himself or google no favors and looks like a douche.
- muzz 13y agoShuttles exist because their offices are not near any existing or feasible transit. Urban areas have a lot more pre-existing transit, and transit that can be used by more people than just work at one company, than the Shoreline Amphitheater area of Mountain View. If the company has it's offices in downtown, they wouldn't need to run shuttles. AFAIK, there is no intra-city shuttle for their employees who work in their SF office, only Mountain View.
- mseebach 13y agoThese are not "citizens arguing", it's professional protesting 101.
- williamcotton 13y agoI don't agree with the tactics used by these protesters at all. I don't see how this creates anything but animosity. Obviously the explosion of tech and the intrusion of the industry in to the city is causing a LOT of problems. Obviously there are a lot of people being displaced who feel they have no say. It seems like the tech industry is just shouting from a bullhorn. "LEARN TO CODE IF YOU'RE POOR" seems to be the message. "WE'RE THE SOLUTION PEOPLE" seems to be the message. "TECH AND CAPITAL WILL SOLVE EVERYTHING" seems to be the message. And yeah, part of the fucking problem is that everyone in tech is a "solutions" person. People have their spiritual energies, their moralistic energies, just blindly and naively stowed away behind some screen, literally and figuratively. It is ethically bankrupt and it is total fucking bullshit. It is basically how a teenager envisions the world. So yeah, I'm just as fucking pissed off at all of these newcomers. I think Radiohead summed it up pretty well: Karma Police, arrest this man, he talks in maths, he buzzes like a fridge he's like a detuned radio. Karma Police, arrest this girl, her hitler hairdo, is making me feel ill, and we have crashed her party. Or how about The Flying Burrito Brothers: This old earthquake's gonna leave me in the poor house. It seems like this whole town's insane. On the thirty-first floor your gold plated door won't keep out the Lord's burning rain. So maybe you're getting my drift here... kidnapping a bus full of people, no matter how strongly you feel about things, is NOT the fucking answer. It is just more SHOUTING. All we end up with is people SHOUTING and SHOUTING. Well, fuck all you people, on both sides. We should be SINGING to each other and with each other. And yeah, tech industry, you need to shut the fuck up. But you know what? I'm just gonna SING.
- bhewes 13y agoI for one hope this gets blown out of proportion. And Google wises up and realizes if they fund public transit they can win public opinion and make the city they live in better for everyone.
- jedmeyers 13y agoThe problem with public transport in Bay Area is not the lack of money. It's mostly politics and inefficient management.
- bhewes 13y agoYeah that part is a pain in the ass in LA. But I am pretty sure Google has the chops to tackle that. And if they shame Apple and the rest of the Valley into it and they could lobby the hell out of the city. It works for the feds it will work on the local level.
- jedmeyers 13y agoWhat makes you think Google haven't tried reasoning with the local governments before starting it's own shuttle program?
- bhewes 13y agoI am sure they tried. It is just reasoning and politics don't go together very well. Even then the current time frame for muni infrastructure projects is decades before completion. Long term I would say something like a Silicon Valley PAC is setup to fight for its employees best interests. And lobby the locals as effectively as SV lobbies Washington.
- saalweachter 13y agoWhat do you mean by "fund public transit"? Google can't just magic a transportation system out of pocket; the (NYC) MTA's 2012 budget was $14.2 billion; Google's 2012 profit was $10.7 billion. Are you expecting them to cooperate with Facebook and Apple to work something out between themselves? Do you want Google to just voluntarily send random checks to various city, local, and state governments, with "for mass transit" in the memo line? The lack of mass transit is the fault of the citizens. Get off your asses, pass some legislation at the appropriate level of government, tax the living daylight out of whatever megacorps and billionaires are in your tax base, and build yourselves some mass transit with it.
- tlrobinson 13y agoThe guy was an ass, but I don't see how protesting the Google shuttle is going to help either. Perhaps if San Francisco allowed more housing development it wouldn't be so expensive. If you live in a desirable place it's going to be more expensive, especially if supply is restricted.
- untog 13y agoWell, the protestors are asking for Google to pay the city for using city infrastructure (bus stops) - that money in turn could/would go to affordable housing. In theory.
- mwnz 13y agoThat really isn't a significant sum of money.
- Cookingboy 13y agodraconian zoning laws and absolute stubborn against new development is, ironically, causing a vicious cycle that's driving up the price and increasing the rate of "gentrification" of the city. You can't fight the changing time by stubborning holding onto what you are used to in the past, because in the end, as long as this remains a free country where people can live wherever, the rule of supply vs demand always wins.
- DanBC 13y agoIsn't Google missing an opportunity here? Provide some funding for regular public transit, fit them with WIFI, slurp the data and invade privacy, serve some ads, etc. That way they get to continue running their buses. They pay an informal tax or money towards advertising, which they can possibly write off as some community benefit thing. They improve the air quality, which improves employee health. And it's a nice thing to do, and all people need to keep a bank of the nice things they do that they can point to when they're caught behaving like dicks.
- magicalist 13y agoSeveral people have mentioned this, but I don't think the scale works out. SMFTA's expenditures alone are nearly a billion dollars a year (and then there's BART and Caltrain). Some of these companies (Google, Apple, etc) have that sort of capital, but short of going into the public transportation business, the jump from carting around a few (tens of?) thousands of people to making a significant impact on that number is not just "provide some funding".
- DanBC 13y agoThey don't have to have any impact at all - all they need to do is provide the same number of public buses as private buses. Or not even that many. Seeing the secret white Google buses will annoy some people. Sometimes for rational reasons, but also because people like being annoyed by stuff. Pointing to a bunch of Muni transport with "This bus provided by Apple!" or "This carriage provided by Google!" will help raise the good-guy profile of those companies and offset against the drone-bus thing. tl:dr - it's just an image problem.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- stephencanon 13y agoThe cynic in me half-expects that the guy was a plant and not an actual Google employee. It’s hard to imagine that someone could be that tone-deaf and blissfully unaware that they’re being caught on camera. Unfortunately, some people really are that unaware. UPDATE: apparently my cynical side called it correctly.
- GuiA 13y agoOr maybe he was having a shitty morning and really needed to get to work, and that made his morning even worse and he lost his temper. Humans are, well, human.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jballanc 13y agoRight out of college I worked swing shift at a corn refinery doing dry starch QA for $12/hr. Later, I went to grad school and had to get a part-time retail job at $9.50/hr to supplement my TA stipend in order to make rent. Today...let's just say I make a lot more than $12/hr. There are many jobs and not all of them pay the same, but not all of them are "career path" jobs either. Some simply require long hours, hard work, and putting up with horrible work conditions (and, sometimes, horrible people). Sadly, I think it is taken as given that some people will spend their entire lives working crappy jobs for low pay, while others get to enjoy high-paying careers. Underneath is a sentiment that some people "have it" -- whether "it" is talent, intelligence, or something else -- and others don't. But I think that's wrong... If everyone left college to become a computer programmer, nobody would be left to cook the burgers, so obviously this is not a solution. But not everyone has to immediately leave college and dive straight in to the career they will someday retire from. I think a simple solution to much of what is wrong with the US economy (and the direction it's heading in) is to begin to expect newly minted graduates, or even high school seniors on a "gap year", to work the crappy jobs. Because you know what? They may be crappy, but there are things you can learn doing those kinds of jobs that they don't teach in school, and that you will probably never learn if you jump straight from school to the cubicle. Yes, I realize I'm posting this on Hacker News, "Home of the Early-20-Something Entrepreneur"™. No, I didn't build a photo/ride/house sharing app in my 20s. I trudged through ankle-deep drifts of corn starch and waist-deep drifts of snow at 3 AM. But now that I'm nearing my mid-30s, I feel like if and when I do decide to start a company, I'll be able to approach the task with a maturity and appreciation for hard, and smart, work that I didn't have when I was 21. So why post this diatribe here? Because without knowing a thing about the gentleman in the video, I can almost guarantee he never worked a day of retail, food-service, or manufacturing in his life...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- 300bps 13y agoMy parents forced me to work in a grocery store job at the age of 16. I was very resistant. Looking back, I am so very glad that they made me do it. I also worked in a grocery store when I was 16 and it was a ridiculously cushy job. I did everything from bagging to grocery return to cart collection to being a checker. My dishwasher job at 14 was easy peasy too. Scrape off plates, rinse them off, put them in the dishwasher. Came home filthy but the work was definitely not hard. My work wasn't part of a character building exercise given to me by my parents though. The amount of work I did directly controlled how many holes my clothes had when I went to school.
- dismiss21x 13y agoWebsite is unresponsive. Direct YouTube link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yc6z2oSPdQ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yc6z2oSPdQ
- petercooper 13y agoApplying his tactics.. maybe he should live closer to work then. If he can't deal with the realities of living in a city, he should go move to Mountain View and take a peaceful ten minute walk into the Google campus instead. No protesters down there and he won't waste an hour a day riding a bus.
- devindotcom 13y agoIn the video, a Google employee who hopped off the bus shouts down Erin McElroy, a protester who also heads the eviction mapping project. "How long have you lived in this city?" McElroy asked him. He shouted back "Why don't you go to a city that can afford it? This is a city for the right people who can afford it. You can't afford it? You can leave. I'm sorry, get a better job." "What kind of fucking city is this?" he shouted, and then walked off. That's the nut of the whole article/video if you are curious. Really bad move on the Google guy's point. I suspect he may himself be looking for a "better job" before long - as far as I know, no one at Google is critical enough that they can't be replaced essentially at will. Update: as thrownaway2424 points out, the article has been edited to indicate this was staged.
- thrownaway2424 13y agoI think the nut of the article is "and then walked off." If he was a Googler why didn't he get on the bus? Probably just some guy acting.
- devindotcom 13y agoThe bus was being obstructed, which was his main problem, so he couldn't get to work. But yeah, it could easily have been just some guy playing the part. If he is a Googler, he's got trouble coming. If not, Google will be able to say so - either way he'll turn up sooner or later, with consequences one hopes.
- thrownaway2424 13y agoUPDATE 12:32pm: Various tips have streamed in that this shout-out was staged. Protest organizer Leslie Dreyer talked to us on the phone and verified that this person's identity was Max Bell Alper, a union organizer from Oakland. This person was not a Google employee, and Dreyer was not able to verify if Alper was there in the morning with the group of 20-30 protesters. The Guardian is attempting to contact Alper for comment. Dreyer said she, as an organizer, was unaware of that the "performance" had been planned. We are following this as it develops. http://www.sfbg.com/googleshoutdown http://www.sfbg.com/googleshoutdown
- tomasien 13y agoI've found, in my experience, the average person, no matter what level in society they have achieved or have not achieved, does not understand 1. People who don't live like them 2. How cities work
- donohoe 13y agoIt has not been confirmed that the person works for Google. It would be best to update the Headline to reflect this (UPDATE 12:12 PM -- The Guardian amended the headline to reflect our story more accurately, that though this man exited the bus and claimed he was late for work, we have not yet verified his employment at Google)
- sp332 13y agoPeople aren't allowed on the bus in the first place if they're not employees or at least contractors. So how much verification do you need? Edit: whoops UPDATE 12:32pm: Various tips have streamed in that this shout-out was staged. Protest organizer Leslie Dreyer talked to us on the phone and verified that this person's identity was Max Bell Alper, a union organizer from Oakland. This person was not a Google employee, and Dreyer was not able to verify if Alper was there in the morning with the group of 20-30 protesters. The Guardian is attempting to contact Alper for comment. Dreyer said she, as an organizer, was unaware that the "performance" had been planned. We are following this as it develops.
- throwawayfornow 13y agoFake: https://twitter.com/FitzTheReporter/status/410143990193733632 https://twitter.com/FitzTheReporter/status/41014399019373363...
- cromwellian 13y agoFirst, the Google employee let his emotions get the best of him and should have avoided the confrontation. Second, if these protesters think gentrification is so bad, wait till they get a load of anti-gentrification, like in my hometown of Baltimore, and elsewhere in places like Detroit. If you want to keep the city vibrant, it is a delicate balance, and yes, if you swing too far towards gentrification you get monoculture, but if you swing too far in the other direction, you get a lot of problems I think are far worse than not being able to afford to live in a "cool" city. San Francisco has a basic supply/demand problem. More people have a preference to live there than capacity, and the distribution of incomes of those with that preference form a wide gap, driving up prices. Thus the supply is rationed by price. Either they can increase supply, or they can decrease the number of high-end bidders somehow by making the city less desirable somehow. But to blame the tech workers over this is the height of hypocrisy and irony. Many of the same people at these protest events also complain about suburbia, people driving excessively and not using public transport, etc. People used to avoid the cities, but now there is a trend towards reurbanization, and as more people move back into cities, the natural result of that is an increase in prices unless supply increases. San Francisco is no different than New York, London, Tokyo, or Shanghai, in real estate trends and gentrification and to fixate on the tech workers or Google Buses, which are not the cause of your problem, and not your politicians, who need to figure out ways to mitigate the problem, I think is only likely to damage your cause by making you look like an angry mob.
- foobarkk 13y agoIn addition to this anti-gentrification protest, San Francisco also has a fairly organized faux anti-gentrification cabal in league with SF Police, including "Homes not Jails".
- fiter 13y ago> Either they can increase supply, or they can decrease the number of high-end bidders somehow by making the city less desirable somehow. Another option (which the city pursues) is regulations like rent control, affordable housing, etc.
- 13y ago
- Justin_K 13y agoI'm sorry but we live in a free market. I'm surprised that some of the posters here think the employee is the problem? The guy has a right to live wherever he wants. Where he chooses to live dictates where he pays his taxes, which funds directly to the city. It's irrelevant if he's been there a week or 30 years. Having high income residents in an area is a GOOD thing. It has brought SF a more educated culture and cash for improvements the city desperately needed. Shared buses lower traffic and pollution. Finally, it must be said that the female protester should have thought twice about putting holes in her face, that is a deal breaker for even entry level jobs.
- waterlesscloud 13y ago"it must be said that the female protester should have thought twice about putting holes in her face" Must that be said?
- aboodman 13y agoArgh. My entire office full of Googlers is cringing. This guy doesn't represent all of us (or really any of the people I have worked with at Google).
- aiiane 13y ago+1
- jedmeyers 13y agoHe is not even one of you :) So of course he does not represent Googlers' opinion.
- aboodman 13y agoPhew!
- arnoldwh 13y agogood news: UPDATE: Rodriguez writes that the "Google employee" was in fact a union organizer, staging a confrontation. http://boingboing.net/2013/12/09/tech-worker-to-san-francisco-r.html http://boingboing.net/2013/12/09/tech-worker-to-san-francisc... Still doesn't solve the very real issue of relationship with SF community however.
- protomyth 13y agoIsn't there any parking lots[1] that Google can purchase a space at to use as a loading zone? It seems like they should be able to pay a fee to some store or building owners to create their own stops. 1) Since the only time I've been in SF was when the car I was riding in broke down in 1988. Yeah, let's send the North Dakotan to find a wrecker.
- aiiane 13y agoParking lots? In SF? Surely you're joking.
- protomyth 13y agoWell, like I said, I was last there in 1988 and it wasn't exactly a non-stressful experience. Where the heck do you park all those cars then?
- williamcotton 13y agoThe secret is to not own a car.
- protomyth 13y agoIts an honest question, I see a lot of cars in the photo, there seems to be shops in the photo, so where the heck do they park in the city and why can't Google buy some spots?
- nostrademons 13y agoI have heard a statistic before that at any given time 50% of the cars in SF are looking for parking. I could easily believe that. It is not unusual, when going up to the city outside of rush hour, to spend 45 minutes driving and then a further 45 minutes looking for parking. Whenever possible I try to park at Daly City or Millbrae and then BART/Caltrain in, but that won't get you to all destinations...
- theorique 13y agoAnd this is employees' fault how?
- davidw 13y agoI think I've mentioned it before, but I'll say it again: I'm pretty happy not to live in that area any more. I loved the weather, but everything else just seems so... bonkers.
- mwnz 13y agoThis is madness. The tech companies are not the issue. The supply and demand imbalance is the issue. If development regulations were relaxed more, then more housing could be developed. The same protestors would probably object to further development. In addition it is counter productive protesting around mass transit. Would they prefer the employees drove, putting immense burden on the already stressed transport infrastructure? The whole argument is terribly misguided.
- muzz 13y ago> If development regulations were relaxed more, then more housing could be developed. This is often tossed around and is often a canard. SF is currently in one of its biggest building booms in history. Building is likely occurring as fast as it can.
- byjove 13y agoWhy not wait until the identity of this person is verified before piling on?
- moultano 13y ago"UPDATE 12:32pm: Various tips have streamed in that this shout-out was staged. Protest organizer Leslie Dreyer talked to us on the phone and verified that this person's identity was Max Bell Alper, a union organizer from Oakland. This person was not a Google employee."
- leothekim 13y agoA claim has been made that the "Google" employee shoutout earlier today at bus protest was staged by union organizer.[1] [1] https://twitter.com/FitzTheReporter/status/410143990193733632 https://twitter.com/FitzTheReporter/status/41014399019373363...
- md224 13y agoThis is one of those times that I can't decide whether or not pg's flamewar detector is doing the right thing. On the one hand, this story is generating vitriol and finger-pointing... but on the other hand, growing inequality in the techno-utopian playground of the Bay Area is a real concern and something this community should be discussing. Unfortunately this particular discussion looks like it's doomed to fall off the front page fairly quickly. (EDIT: Yep, already gone.) I wish there was a way to have a constructive dialogue without degenerating into emotional chaos. EDIT: Rumors are swirling that this guy might've been a plant. If that's true, I suppose burying the story might be epistemically virtuous, as a way to contain the spread of false information. That's a separate issue from the flamewar detector, though.
- michaelrhansen 13y agoThe media is going to have a field day with this.
- throwawayfornow 13y agoThe guy who posted that video: NEW INFORMATION: "Google" employee shoutout earlier today at bus protest was staged by union organizer. https://twitter.com/FitzTheReporter/status/410143990193733632 https://twitter.com/FitzTheReporter/status/41014399019373363...
- patmcguire 13y agoWord on twitter is that there was an update saying it was staged, but I can't get to the actual article. Can anyone verify?
- tlrobinson 13y agoApparently this was staged: https://twitter.com/FitzTheReporter/statuses/410143990193733632 https://twitter.com/FitzTheReporter/statuses/410143990193733...
- sp332 13y agoWell, the protest holding up a bus was real. Only the google employee doing the yelling was fake.
- taopao 13y agoThis is a fiction that was staged by the union organizers. https://twitter.com/FitzTheReporter/status/410143990193733632 https://twitter.com/FitzTheReporter/status/41014399019373363...
- rowoot 13y agoThe fake "Google" employee is union organizer Max Alper http://www.makingchangemedia.org/about-the-team/ http://www.makingchangemedia.org/about-the-team/
- taopao 13y agoThat is Max Bell Alper of Occupy SF.
- panarky 13y agoThe title should be updated to reflect that this was not a Google employee, but the shouting match was staged by protest organizers. See updated article.