3 ms·
>> If there's no government, would you not have the right to defend yourself or your property against an aggressor? You're claiming a piece of land as your ow
by Nursie 13y ago
>> If there's no government, would you not have the right to defend yourself or your property against an aggressor?
You're claiming a piece of land as your own but I don't see how you have any more right to it than any other human born on this earth. You initiate force to remove me from what you see as your land. Who's the aggressor? Where does your right to land derive from?
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoGenerally, improvements and occupation make it your home. Somebody coming in to take land containing a house you built, a barn you raised, cattle you bred on a crop you are growing, are taking what's yours. Take this away and nobody would use land at all. Been done in history again and again; result always the same : collapse of farming, which means collapse of the govt.
- Nursie 13y ago>> Generally, improvements and occupation make it your home. Somebody coming in to take land containing a house you built, a barn you raised, cattle you bred on a crop you are growing, are taking what's yours. So nobody should be able to own land they aren't using for anything and I should be able to just go and occupy it? Cool. >> Take this away and nobody would use land at all. Been done in history again and again; result always the same : collapse of farming, which means collapse of the govt. And now we've moved onto a pragmatic rather than moral absolutist argument, which I agree with entirely. Now that we're in this territory, let's talk about a bunch of other human-friendly pragmatic moves we could make as a society that might improve everyone's lives, eh?
- anoncowherd 13y ago>> So nobody should be able to own land they aren't using for anything and I should be able to just go and occupy it? Cool. Why would the same rule not apply to you? In other words, you can't just "occupy" land, you'll have to use it, just like everyone else.
- Nursie 13y ago>> Why would the same rule not apply to you? In other words, you can't just "occupy" land, you'll have to use it, just like everyone else. Who's saying I wouldn't use it? It's pretty radical for a hard-property-rights libertarian to concede I could just go up and take someone's land if I judge it's not in proper use!
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoYou are actually right. Unused land you occupy can eventually be yours, to some degree. Its called 'squatting' and while it has issues it can correct some imbalances. I agree moral absolutism is tricky. But think of it as first principles. You have to argue from something or its all situational ethics, which depend entirely upon your point of view.
- Nursie 13y agoDeriving from a first principle that's so broken and so subjective seems to me basically pointless. Moral absolutism is only useful if you have an absolute. We don't have one, not one we share anyway (him and me, no idea on your views really), so berating me for not joining in when you start deriving from it seems a bit off. It's one of the things about objectivism that really gets me - "we're the only philosophy based on objective reality!" "But these things are highly subjective?!" "Shut up you sociopath/leech/parasite!" The squatting thing is interesting, most people hate it instinctively but I'm unsure where I stand.