3 ms·
"This is what happens when you don’t stigmatize engineers: you get a country full of engineers, self-identifying as engineers, growing up dreaming of being engi
by edw519 17y ago
"This is what happens when you don’t stigmatize engineers: you get a country full of engineers, self-identifying as engineers, growing up dreaming of being engineers."
Er, no, this is what happens when the rest of the world won't allow you to have an army because of what you did when you had one.
Your engineers have nowhere else to go but into the private sector where they are much more visible.
In the U.S., many of the best and brightest end up in the military or government service. We don't know what many of them do. I guess that's the price we're still paying for winning World War II.
- sp332 17y agoI actually think it goes back to the War of 1812, when a handful of mechanized British troops very nearly retook the US capitol. It really put the lie to Thomas Jefferson's ideal agricultural society (the pirates at Trinidad didn't seem to wake people up the same way).
- TriinT 17y ago"In the U.S., many of the best and brightest end up in the military or government service." Would you please care to provide examples? If you said that the best and the brightest are funded by military and government, I'd agree. After all, that's what DARPA and NSF are for. But I have never met one bright person who enjoyed working for the U.S. military or government. Not one. They all quit their jobs after a while, and came back to academia, or the private sector.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI've never met a tall person who did anything worth a damn either, but that tells more about me than it does about tall people.
- erlanger 17y agoI'm sure there are plenty of intelligent, power-hungry people working for our government in either a martial or administrative capacity. Dick Cheney is an example of such a person.
- TriinT 17y agoYour certainty that there are intelligent people working for the U.S. government stems from 1st hand experience, or does it stem from wishful thinking? I thought Cheney was no longer in the government. And if he's so smart, why didn't he anticipate the Iraq quagmire? Maybe he desired one?
- erlanger 17y agoYou can be very smart and still be incorrect at times. Blunders happen.
- TriinT 17y agoIt's relatively easy to measure how smart a mathematician is. How do you measure how smart a politician is? Then there's another problem: in certain organizations, it does not matter if you're very smart because you can't act on it. There's no better career suicide than making your superior look dumb in the corporate world. Your co-workers may feel threatened and conspire against you. In government, you can't do certain things because the powerful interest groups or public opinion just won't let you. Hence, I ask again: how do you measure the performance or the smarts of a politician? BTW, Cheney himself said in the early 1990s that going to Baghdad in 1991 would have resulted in a Vietnam-like quagmire. How ironic.
- DTrejo 17y ago
- baguasquirrel 17y agoI don't buy it. The Germans had the best tanks in WWII, and the best submachine guns. They practically invented the assault rifle with the MP44.