2 ms·
Your reasoning is wrong, here. Taxation is zero-sum in dollars. Trade of dollars and unmodified material goods is also zero sum in those dollars and goods, an
by dllthomas 13y ago
Your reasoning is wrong, here.
Taxation is zero-sum in dollars.
Trade of dollars and unmodified material goods is also zero sum in those dollars and goods, and can still be positive-sum in utility.
If you have X kg gold, and I have $Y, and you value that X kg gold at less than $Y, while I value that X kg gold a more than $Y, we can make a trade, all be subjectively better off - a non-zero sum transaction - and yet there is no more gold and there is no more dollars.