3 ms·
Somehow, every other VRBO site (such as VRBO.com) manages to comply with local laws. AirBnB doesn't--by choice. It refuses to comply with local laws because th
by gamblor956 13y ago
Somehow, every other VRBO site (such as VRBO.com) manages to comply with local laws. AirBnB doesn't--by choice. It refuses to comply with local laws because this lets it avoid the costs of compliance. Ultimately, AirBnB's competitive edge over its competitors is simply regulatory arbitrage.
This is why AirBnB generates such apathy. Take the regulatory arbitrage away and AirBnB isn't a technical startup or a market disruptor; it's just another VRBO site with pretty CSS.
They are overkill and would be the same as if Congress, at the federal level, had passed laws saying that YouTube-style services should be banned because they can facilitate copyright infringement that hurts others.
No, completely different, and as a lawyer you know this. Local issues are valid concerns for local laws. If New York wants to pass an across the board tax on temporary rentals, it is absolutely not the same as if Congress passed a country-wide ban on Youtube-style service.
The key to all this is to deal with the abuses while preserving the values conferred by the new services. If there is antipathy toward the wrongdoers, there is no basis for directing this to the innovators themselves.
Existing laws already do this. And as a business that injects itself into the market governed by such laws, AirBnB has taken on the burden of complying with such laws. Moreover, AirBnB isn't an innovator--it's a copycat. The only innovation AirBnB provided was sub-unit rentals (i.e., just a room or a couch), which is no longer the mainstay of its business.
- brudgers 13y agoThe illegal hotel use in my neighborhood was primarily offered on VRBO.
- gamblor956 13y agoLet them know. My building had an issue with a unit being offered through VRBO.com and AirBnB despite COA rules against it. VRBO.com took the posting down after I sent them a complaint with a copy of our COA rules, and they flagged it in their system so it couldn't be reposted. AirBnB did nothing, and the listing is still there. (However, the COA has since seized the unit and changed the locks since the unit owner failed to pay his COA dues or provide proof of property insurance, so any person trying to rent the unit through AirBnB will be SOL.)
- brudgers 13y agoThat was not a legal option in our case, the covenants upon the Deed of Title were not enforceable by the impacted neighbors because an interest in the legal person that sold the lots did not convey with the lot - i. e. there was no HOA or COA. Instead, covenant enforcement would have required locating the heirs or successors of the' legal person' who platted the neighborhood and their goodwill toward enforcing covenants some thirty five years later, assuming such use was against the covenants upon the Deed of Title. Our case was not a private dispute, or rather it was intractable as one, and in any event the use was illegal. Thus it took overcoming the normal bureaucratic wall of mud at the enforcement arm of the city zoning department and eventually offering testimony before Judge Jim* in Municipal Court on a Tuesday afternoon last spring. *Judge Jim had been the Miss June's diforce attorney several years before his election And a fellow Rotarian of another testifying neighbor.
- jessaustin 13y agoIn all of those details, I don't see any indication that VRBO continued a listing that it knew to be illegal. Sometimes the legal process just takes a long time. Short-circuiting the process doesn't serve the interests of justice.
- pbreit 13y agoI rarely use airbnb because it's so hard to find non-couch-surfing situations. And I think you are clearly understating the ingenuity and improvements that airbnb has brought to the industry.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- subsystem 13y agoFrom what I've seen I agree with your first point. AirBnB is more like The Pirate Bay than YouTube.
- walden42 13y ago> Take the regulatory arbitrage away and AirBnB isn't a technical startup or a market disruptor; it's just another VRBO site with pretty CSS. Apparently a lot of people are attracted to AirBnB for this very reason. This shows how badly regulations affect so many different kinds of markets.
- gtirloni 13y agoOr how badly people in this market care for laws.