5 ms·
If Google's plan is to leave the high-end of smartphones to its Android "partners" and stake out the low end with Motorola, that seems pretty smart. Its partner
by justin66 13y ago
If Google's plan is to leave the high-end of smartphones to its Android "partners" and stake out the low end with Motorola, that seems pretty smart. Its partners get to keep the high-margin hardware business that Google doesn't need anyway, Google puts a floor on how bad the low-end phones can be and still make it to market. And yeah, Google isn't in the position of competing with companies that it needs.
- naner 13y agoThe Moto X and Google's own Nexus series appear to be pretty high end. I don't think this is their plan at all.
- justin66 13y agoMotorola doesn't manufacture the Nexus phones.
- aroch 13y agoThe poster doesn't imply that it does...
- minalecs 13y agothe moto x and Nexus line has always been considered mid tier, not the latest everything and many compromises made but not low end.
- The_Double 13y agoEvery Nexus except the S and Galaxy had the best SOC available at the time (The one and 4 had them before any other android phone). The Galaxy was the first 720p smartphone. They are high end, just not at all costs.
- bookwormAT 13y ago"has always been considered" by whom? "mid tier" is a very generic term. Most critiques and opinions I know of consider these devices best in class.
- cabbeer 13y agoThe divide between "High end" and "Low end" devices is beginning to blur. The improvements to high end devices are providing diminishing returns, while all the "essentials" have trickled down to low end devices.
- glesica 13y agoThis is actually why I've got a Moto G on order. This will be my first smart phone. Before I heard about the Moto G I always assumed my first smart phone would be a Nexus device, because I refuse to sign a carrier contract and I would rather have a dumb phone than carry around something that cost $600 in my pocket every day. But with the Moto G, I get a cheap-ish device with all the features that actually matter to me (high res screen, good camera, reasonably fast processor, decent amount of RAM) and it doesn't come with a contract or a crazy price tag. I saved $150 over buying a Nexus 5, and I doubt I'll even notice the difference (if anything, I'll like it better because, IIRC, the Moto G is a bit smaller than the Nexus).
- gcb1 13y agohope you don't plan to travel. nexus 5 would work on most network. also get ready to be disappointed with the camera. even the motoX gets owned by old nokia phones. the sad thing about google/moto only churning out low end phones, is that we now will have to give in to weird rooting/unlocking if we want basic features, like a simple sd card or removable battery. i dread the day i have to abandon my old nexus and start fiddling with Odin and whatnot to unlock a high end phone. (odin is code you have to use to unlock samsung phones. nobody has the source, and it is allegedly stolen property from samsung... shady stuff, and that is what will update you phone bootloader. no thanks) anyway, really wanted to have a high-end option that was free as the nexus claim to be (claim because the radio, camera driver, etc are never open source. but thats the best we can get, well, could.)
- SifJar 13y agoHTC and Sony both allow their devices bootloaders to be unlocked via simple procedures involving fastboot, a generic (& simple to use) Android tool supplied with the Android SDK (and AFAIK, open source). Both manufacture high quality, high end devices. As for Samsung devices, there is Heimdall, an open source, cross platform alternative to Odin. Of course, whether via official means for HTC & Sony, or unofficial for Samsung, unlocking the bootloader will void your warranty (just as on Nexus devices). It comes down to a question of whether or not AOSP is worth it to you. Of course, there are also the "Google Play Editions" of phones like the HTC One and the Samsung Galaxy S4 which come with what is essentially AOSP, giving a "Nexus-like" experience on a non-Nexus, high end phone (including officially unlockable bootloader, although that may be unnecessary if all you want is AOSP). The S4 has micro SD card support and a removable battery.
- mtgx 13y agoI'm not so sure they will just "leave the high-end market" to the rest, but they may try changing things up at the high-end, such as with highly customizable "ARA" phones: http://www.theverge.com/2013/12/7/5185768/dennis-woodside-interview-project-ara-moto-maker-convergence http://www.theverge.com/2013/12/7/5185768/dennis-woodside-in...
- katemcintyre 13y ago> And yeah, Google isn't in the position of competing with companies that it needs. Why not? Motorola's Moto X is pretty high end and Google is spending $500M on just advertising it this year[1], beating Samsung's and Apple's ad spending. In watching a couple of hours of primetime TV in the US, I usually see 3 to 4 Moto X ads, and almost the same number of Windows 8/Surface ads. However, sales seem to be quite sluggish[2]. Motorola can't be making all that much money on Moto G and it seems to be Google's loss leader just like Microsoft's Lumia 520/521 at $69 to $99 unlocked(Surprised the article didn't mention it at all or compare it against the Moto G, it's a surprisingly fast phone for that price). Meanwhile Motorola's losses continue to grow every quarter and continue to be a drag on Google's earnings [3] . I guess the pressure is on Motorola to deliver, but even if this phone sells well, I doubt it's going to help them unless they're going to make money from ads and/or Google Play sales on those phones. [1] http://9to5google.com/2013/07/11/moto-x-would-be-most-heavily-promoted-smartphone-ever-if-googles-planned-500m-spend-is-true/ http://9to5google.com/2013/07/11/moto-x-would-be-most-heavil... [2] http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-motorola-moto-g-moto-x-20131113,0,1287681.story#axzz2mqkumSRE http://www.latimes.com/business/technology/la-fi-tn-motorola... [3] http://mobilenewsblog.co.uk/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Screen-Shot-2013-10-18-at-10.26.36.png http://mobilenewsblog.co.uk/wp/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Sc...
- Touche 13y agoThe Lumia phones are not fast. Fast scrolling, sure, but apps take 3-4 seconds to open and don't stay in memory very long.
- girvo 13y agoIt's user interface is responsive, but it's not a powerful handset. That's the best way of describing them, and to be honest for a lot of first-smartphone buyers, that's more than good enough in my experience.
- amaks 13y agoAnd the reason is that UI is written in native code (read C++) using internal native APIs while 3rd party apps written in managed code (using different APIs. Of course it takes more time to launch managed apps. This is clearly a disparity between 1st party and 3rd party apps.
- natch 13y agoI love this "puts a floor on how bad the low-end phones can be" -- YES that's the really great thing about this. Very good for consumers, and competition, and the mobile ecosystem, and keeps pressure on Apple and everyone else involved to keep cranking up the awesome.
- Someone 13y agoA floor, at $179? I bet companies will find a cellar or two below that price point, at lower quality. $179 is a lot of money to many people, even inside the USA.
- jaredmcateer 13y ago179 off contract, on contract it will probably be $0-$50