14 ms·
Google’s $179 Moto G puts every single cheap Android phone to shame
- msoad 13y agoI love watching race for enabling next billion people with cheap smartphone. We will see double of people on Internet today just in five years.
- alan_cx 13y agoWell, all I can say is that until last week I was still using my Nokia 6500c. This Moto G is the fist smart phone that for me does enough to warrant the price; UK £120, unlocked. So, I bought one.
- bcraven 13y agoI am in the same boat. Had it for a few weeks now and loving it!
- sushidev 13y agoI've got good recommendations on Lenovo A820 (http://www.gsmarena.com/lenovo_a820-5462.php http://www.gsmarena.com/lenovo_a820-5462.php) which has about the same price but a little lower. What would you buy? A Moto G or a Lenovo A820?
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoIt looks like Moto G has slightly better screen, newer OS, and better integration with Google services, while A820 has micro sd slot and better camera. If none of that is critical for you - I would say get a feel for both of them and go with one you like better. There is nothing fundamentally better about specs on either phone.
- coolnow 13y agoKeep in mind the A820 has an MTK SoC which could affect the timely adoption of later firmware vs the Moto G's Qualcomm Snapdragon 400, which is well supported by many ROM authors.
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoGoogle is making a big play on smartphone for everyone model. Now if they could get carriers to agree to cheaper data model, their hand would be really strong. To some extent this favors T-Mobile and other no-discount/cheaper plans carriers.
- skelsey 13y agoThey don't need to. You can get an unlimited data + 100 minute no contract plan from t-mobile for $30/month.
- aphexairlines 13y agoUnlimited 2G data. LTE is limited to 5GB per month. I've hit their throttle before, and while it's nice that you don't go dark, it's not for normal use.
- pkulak 13y agoNot many people can use 5GB of data in a month. I'd say "normal" use is nowhere near 5GB.
- girvo 13y ago5Gb on a handset without tethering isn't "normal" use, even with LTE...
- hvidgaard 13y agoIt depends. 1.5 hours of facetime will use ~1gb, and streaming 1 hour of music every day will run at 1gb over the month. Add browsing during commute and you're getting close. It's probably not "normal" in the sense of average, but for the heavy consumer, they will have to moderate their usage.
- mortehu 13y agoWhere's that? I can only find $50, $60 and $70 plans: http://www.t-mobile.com/cell-phone-plans/individual.html http://www.t-mobile.com/cell-phone-plans/individual.html
- martinald 13y agoThis is getting really interesting. Between this, the Nexus 5 and the various Lumia's a $649 iPhone is starting to look very, very expensive. Smartphones at the moment seem to have got 'good enough'.
- mpg33 13y agomacs are also a premium price compared to PC's....not sure how comparably this is
- Macha 13y agoAnd the Mac market share compared to PC market share shows which is far more dominant.
- lotsofpulp 13y agoA sustainable business with larger profit margins is usually better to have than one with smaller profit margins. Also, a business with clients who have deeper pockets is better than a business dealing with those who have less disposable income.
- ido 13y agoApple vs Amazon models, both have their pros and cons.
- prodigal_erik 13y agoApple's strategy had them circling the drain for many years, with too little volume to build a decent supply chain and hit sane price points. They all but gave up on making open tools and moved down to crippled appliances, and even then I was honestly surprised they survived.
- eropple 13y agoWhat you call "crippled appliances", other people call "things people want."
- pedrocr 13y ago>It's tempting to think of the Moto G as some kind of "Nexus Jr.," a cheaper way to buy into the clean UI and quick software updates that Google's reference phones have always received. However, Google is making no promises about versions of Android beyond version 4.4, and speculating about whether Android 4.5 or 5.0 or whatever will roll out to the Moto phones as quickly as KitKat is a pointless exercise. Again shooting themselves in the foot.
- stusmall 13y agoHow so? The quick software updates is a selling point to devs but not so much to consumers. We aren't their target market. It seems like a good place to cut costs since you don't have the huge reaccuring engineering costs and there is much more freedom on part selection
- alexmat 13y agoAnecdotal point, but my Mom is much happier to get an update with a new phone than to have an old phone updated.
- winterswift 13y agoI kind of wonder if that's because a lot of updates are rolled out poorly to older devices. On my previous two phones, I've ended up running CyanogenMod or another third-party ROM, even at the same base Android version at the stock OTA updates, because many times even the RC versions run better than what's getting pushed by the carrier. Verizon customer here though, so I don't know if other networks are better about that. I also wouldn't be terribly surprised if that effect (wanting a new phone over an update) is intentional.
- derekp7 13y agoPart of it is just change. One day, I needed to pull up the map on my Nexus phone -- and it had a completely different interface to it. I had to sit in a parking lot for an extra 15 minutes to get it to do what I wanted. Now I've got KitKat, and the phone dialer has changed -- I have to hit an extra button to get all my contacts, and I don't like the "premium" spots being automatically populated (there are only 3 large icons, and room for two smaller icons, in the quick-access screen). The most important contact is the one I need right then. Oh, and I also have to re-agree to the license terms on a number of apps whenever I launch them the first time after an upgrade. And my tethering is no longer working. And the flashlight app that worked fine is now rebooting the phone randomly after it is on for a few seconds. At this point, I'm ready to wipe and re-install the older OS version.
- justin66 13y agoIf Google's plan is to leave the high-end of smartphones to its Android "partners" and stake out the low end with Motorola, that seems pretty smart. Its partners get to keep the high-margin hardware business that Google doesn't need anyway, Google puts a floor on how bad the low-end phones can be and still make it to market. And yeah, Google isn't in the position of competing with companies that it needs.
- naner 13y agoThe Moto X and Google's own Nexus series appear to be pretty high end. I don't think this is their plan at all.
- justin66 13y agoMotorola doesn't manufacture the Nexus phones.
- aroch 13y agoThe poster doesn't imply that it does...
- minalecs 13y agothe moto x and Nexus line has always been considered mid tier, not the latest everything and many compromises made but not low end.
- The_Double 13y agoEvery Nexus except the S and Galaxy had the best SOC available at the time (The one and 4 had them before any other android phone). The Galaxy was the first 720p smartphone. They are high end, just not at all costs.
- bookwormAT 13y ago"has always been considered" by whom? "mid tier" is a very generic term. Most critiques and opinions I know of consider these devices best in class.
- nnnnni 13y ago$179 is way too much for a phone that sends all of your login information for different pages and services to Motorola's servers in plaintext...
- ye 13y agoWhat are you talking about?
- ehPReth 13y agohttp://www.beneaththewaves.net/Projects/Motorola_Is_Listening.html http://www.beneaththewaves.net/Projects/Motorola_Is_Listenin...
- laureny 13y agoJust the regular "NSA/Google is evil/wake up people" troll. Ignore and carry on.
- ehPReth 13y agoNah, this one is credible: http://www.beneaththewaves.net/Projects/Motorola_Is_Listening.html http://www.beneaththewaves.net/Projects/Motorola_Is_Listenin...
- byjove 13y agoThis is pre Google acquisition, pre Google models.
- zobzu 13y agodefault android phone sends your location to google, as well as your contacts, app list, app usage, calendars, todo list and some other things. You can disable a good part of it manually, thanksfully. Still, he sure has a point.. its not like if that data wasn't sent. It fucking is.
- kllrnohj 13y ago
- quaffapint 13y agoI can't wait for a Verizon version (apparently 1Q 2014) to pare up with PagePlus, so I can dump my VZ contract and only pay half of what I do now.
- localuser 13y agoI bought 3 moto g's and on the day they arrived switched the entire family to tmobile. I had enough of Verizon and now my bill is $100 a month. Can't beat that.
- quaffapint 13y agoI would like to leave VZ too, but I'm simply too afraid that the coverage will not be there on tmobile and at&t - and especially I need to consider the WAF.
- localuser 13y agoI understand. Coverage was what kept me on VZ for 10 years. What finally got to me was the fact that when I'm overseas I can just swap a sim and T-mobile's coverage has been improving exponentially.
- gcb0 13y agodepending on the plan, on tmobile, you don't even have to swtich the sim. they have international calls included.
- mhb 13y agoI'd like to do that. Which plan?
- tostitos1979 13y agoStandard family plan. No contract! Spotty service coverage but can't beat the price.
- 13y ago
- linux_devil 13y agoRight move to target market in India and China , its way affordable than Iphone 5C and comes with the brand name too.
- aseembehl 13y agoUnfair to compare Iphone 5c with Moto G. Iphone 5c vs Moto X is a more meaningful comparison.
- linux_devil 13y agoComparing only with respect to price and only with respect to articles which referred Iphone 5c is targeting Asian markets especially India and China.
- JohnTHaller 13y agoWe're comparing entry level but quality phones. 5c is Apple's entry level phone at $549. Moto G is Motorola's at $179. There are lots of cheaper Androids as well as Androids that match the 5c in CPU and screen for less money as well as deals you can get on refurbished/last years phones from both companies, but we're specifically comparing what a new entry level phone is.
- hbharadwaj 13y agoNot yet. They need to beat Lumia 520's price. Agreed, the specs are higher but most people in that space don't care.
- vidarh 13y agoChina is overflowing with cheaper, better spec'ed phones than the Moto G. And their own homegrown high end phones that compete for the Iphone end of the market, like e.g. Xiaomi and Huawei phones priced in the same price range as the iPhone.
- ttflee 13y agoXiaomi competes for the consumers who are jealous of the UX of iOS but could not afford a real iPhone. Also Xiaomi fails to match the demands to its flagship products time and time and always runs into shortages.
- 001sky 13y agoIs Moto-G now good enough to replace an iPod touch? for a no-contract 'smartphone' that doesn't need to be up on 4g all of the time (say w/good wi-fi acesss)? Because it sure seems like a better deal in terms of functionality. The main limitation/constraint IMHO is the memory [8 or 16 GB NAND flash], which seems arbitrarily low. (ie, >5 years out of date).
- blinkingled 13y agoYeah barring the storage part - it is definitely a great iPod Touch replacement. You might be able to live with the 16GB if you stream stuff instead of playing it locally. There are many media player apps (Archos one that I use is great - even the free version) that can play videos from SMB shares etc.
- av500 13y agoArchos developer here, glad that you like the app :)
- blinkingled 13y agoAny plans for Chromecasting/AirPlay support? I know it's not that simple but would not mind paying $4.99 if the paid version supported it. Thanks!
- av500 13y agoLooking into it. I understand there might be legal issues around Airplay and that Google did something to Chromecast to disallow "unofficial" use cases :(
- vidarh 13y agoIf you just want a media player, pick up almost any current generation chinese Android phones from Alibaba/Aliexpress. Many will be as cheap or cheaper, with plenty of them offering 1920x1080, and pretty much all of them supports 32GB or 64GB SD cards.
- kombine 13y agoMy Lenovo P780 was only $80 more expensive, but its battery has the highest capacity on the market, 4000 mAh. The phone holds the charge for >2 days of quite intensive use. I had Samsung Galaxy Note before this one, but now don't understand why anyone would choose top end phones from the brands like Samsung or Apple, if half of the cost of a phone goes to profit their shareholders.
- eli 13y agoIf battery capacity is your main issue, you can do better with an aftermarket one. I got a 4500 mAh for my Galaxy S3 for $30! Of course, it requires a new case because it's enormous...
- kombine 13y agoIt wasn't my main issue, until I got it. I was very restricted with my Samsung before, because I would always end up with dead battery during just a one day of intensive usage. As for the size, it's absolutely manageable, maybe a little thicker than most of the 5" phones.
- eli 13y agoFair enough, this thing looks ridiculous. Works great, though.
- btian 13y agoDoes your phone support LTE? Does it run a modern version of Android? Does it have a modern SoC? Does it sync with my Fitbit? Is it widely available in the US? Can I get after sales support?
- kombine 13y agoDoes your phone support LTE? I don't know if it does, but I live in Europe so that is not an issue for me. Does it run a modern version of Android? 4.2.1 Does it have a modern SoC It has more than enough horsepowers for what I do on a smartphone. It's quad-core, as for details - I never bothered. Is it widely available in the US? Can I get after sales support? Again, I don't know much about US, but I would imagine that a big company like Lenovo would be present there in one form or another.
- suchusername 13y agoI like my Nexus 4. They barely mention it.
- yachtintransit 13y agoI'm surprised they didn't mention more about the Bluetooth 4.0 (low energy) support. I would take ble support over NFC . good writeup otherwise.
- yachtintransit 13y agoI'm surprised they didn't mention more about the Bluetooth 4.0 (low energy) support. I would take ble support over NFC . good writeup otherwise.
- yachtintransit 13y agoI'm surprised they didn't mention more about the Bluetooth 4.0 (low energy) support. I would take ble support over NFC . good writeup otherwise.
- yachtintransit 13y agoI'm surprised they didn't mention more about the Bluetooth 4.0 (low energy) support. I would take ble support over NFC . good writeup otherwise.
- yachtintransit 13y agoI'm surprised they didn't mention more about the Bluetooth 4.0 (low energy) support. I would take ble support over NFC . good writeup otherwise.
- vidarh 13y agoThat price point is now full of phones with 1920x1080 5" screens; 1280x720 is very much "last year". The camera specs are beaten roundly by my year old $200 phone. The physical design is almost identical to said year old phone (which is to say it looks pretty much like the Galaxy SIII). And said phone also has removable battery, dual SIMs, and support for a 32GB SD card. This might put ever single "cheap" Android phone of a brand well known in Europe and the US to shame, but from the specs given it's middle of the pack fo cheap Android phones overall (it's likely to be a bit faster and with better graphics performance than most low end Android phones, but lower resolution and lacking camera and storage e.g.)
- KVFinn 13y ago>That price point is now full of phones with 1920x1080 5" screens; 1280x720 is very much "last year". The camera specs are beaten roundly by my year old $200 phone. The physical design is almost identical to said year old phone (which is to say it looks pretty much like the Galaxy SIII). I think you missed the fact that that's the non-contract no subsidy price... Your $200 dollar phone was probably 500 or 600 off contract so this costs about 1/3 as much.
- vidarh 13y agoYou are jumping to (wrong) conclusions. My $200 phone was without contract. . Here's a few examples of current Chinese phones in the Moto G's price range or below: 2GB RAM, Quad Core MTK CPU, 5" screen, 12.8 megapixel camera down to $121: http://www.aliexpress.com/item/Full-1-1-i9500-MTK6589-S4-Phone-Android-4-2-2-Quad-core-2GB-RAM-1/1494987491.html http://www.aliexpress.com/item/Full-1-1-i9500-MTK6589-S4-Pho... MTK based Galaxy S4 clone for <=$150: http://www.aliexpress.com/item/Mtk6589t-S4-1-1-Perfect-Galaxy-Siv-I9500-2G-Ram-16GB-32GB-Rom-Quad-Core-1920x1080/1520496758.html http://www.aliexpress.com/item/Mtk6589t-S4-1-1-Perfect-Galax... Note 3 clone for ~$190: http://www.aliexpress.com/item/3200mAh-battery-Galaxy-N9000-N9002-Note-3-III-phone-Android-4-3-MTK6582-Quad-core-5/1401325774.html http://www.aliexpress.com/item/3200mAh-battery-Galaxy-N9000-... Most of these phones are very good quality and the main "problem" to be aware of is that the MTK SoC's are not the fastests alternative. Then again, neither is the one in the Moto G.
- nicholassmith 13y agoIt looks great, but as I've mentioned here before, I have some concerns about the cost. It's a great short term boon to consumers getting a device of this high quality at this price point, but the margins have to be razor thing on it, so how do they make money for R&D? What about Company X? What do they do, slice prices to match to keep market share or hope they retain a profit share? If they slash where do they get the R&D budget from? The smartphone market is starting to get truly interesting, I just hope it doesn't get dominated by the companies with the deepest pockets, it's a short term gain for consumers (we all like things cheaper), but could long term stagnate the market.
- Brakenshire 13y agoYou can see this with Jolla- interesting new entrant, aims to provide a less monolithic, more hackable device, built on the Nokia N9, which was widely acclaimed. But it's double the price of the Moto G, with equivalent or even slightly worse specs. If Google is selling its handsets at or near cost, and relying on the long-term value of advertising and data, then it will be almost impossible for anyone without the same revenue streams to engage in serious competition.
- dageshi 13y agoI guess if you're google, you might worry that someone could come along and do this to you. Someone say for instance Amazon decides to sell a very good quality phone at near cost and starts to capture marketshare. From Google's perspective, better for them to preemptively do that if that's where the market is heading anyway.
- pekk 13y agoAssuming the only spec that matters is a CPU frequency etc., which is as incredibly silly and naive today as it always was
- TrainedMonkey 13y agoGoogle is not in business of making money with selling hardware like Apple and Samsung. Google is selling a platform, and then makes money from people using it.
- pandeiro 13y agoI've used this phone and the lack of dual-band wifi causes some issues with wifi-connectivity. Its range is less than my Nexus 4 and it will sporadically lose connectivity over wifi, more often than other Android devices I've used.
- kunai 13y agoI'd extend this statement and say that the Moto G puts every single cheap phone to shame. Not just Android. It becomes very hard to justify a Lumia at $400 or an iPhone 4S at a ludicrous $450 when we have a flagship Nexus at $350 and now the Moto G at $179. Combine that with the defiant cries against consumerism and wastefulness with Project Ara, and Google has really raised the bar by quite a bit for what a mobile phone OEM is capable of. It will be interesting to see what happens 3, 4 years down the line when the market fully resaturates with more price-friendly and DIY-friendly phones.
- Zigurd 13y agoMoto G is a great balance of price and performance. It is also much more sensible for a Google-owned OEM to pursue a distinctive niche in the market than to compete with Google's partners across their whole product line. BUT that's just one handset. Nobody knows what Motorola will do next. Is Google shining it up to sell? That would be sensible. Motorola is a huge addition to Google's headcount that produces far less than the typical Google product group. Motorola competes with Google's partners. Google would be better off with Motorola as an OEM partner than as a subsidiary.
- ForHackernews 13y agoMy understanding is Google bought Motorola primarily for their patent portfolio, so they'd have some weapons to aim at Apple and ward off lawsuits through mutually-assured destruction. Is it possible for them to sell off Motorola's hardware operations while retaining their IP?
- Zigurd 13y agoMany people assumed this is what would have happened by now. Maybe it's a problem Google is avoiding: What if OEM + patents adds up to nowhere near $12B? Google risks distracting management and annoying partners by dithering.
- dools 13y agoI hope someone at Motorola loves the Pro+ as much as I do and they bring out a low end candy bar qwerty. Every time a company releases a new touch screen keyboard, God kills a kitten.
- dschiptsov 13y agoWhy, it is Nexus 4 with half of RAM and cheap plastic case.
- ye 13y agoExcept you can't buy Nexus 4.
- yc-kjh 13y agoBattery NOT User-Removable. Phone NOT User-Buyable.
- userbinator 13y agoTo me this was a huge WTF? If they went to the trouble of making the back easily detachable, why did they deliberately do that? Almost feels like they're trolling the user: "Ha! Fooled you!" Even more so when they officially refer to it as the "battery door" in the documentation! https://motorola-global-en-roe.custhelp.com/app/answers/prod_answer_detail/a_id/97374/p/30,6720,9050/action/auth https://motorola-global-en-roe.custhelp.com/app/answers/prod...
- downer90 13y agoSeriously. I take major issue with devices that you can't cut the power to. As far as I'm concerned, that renders it as an eavesdropping apparatus. If I can't remove the battery, I'll never know when the microphone is truly off. I'll never know whether it's logging GPS geolocation data or not.
- contingencies 13y agoHalf price Firefox OS phones like the ZTE Open are more impressive and better for your freedom. Google want your communications, thinking, location, habits... this is worse than Mastercard or Xperian issuing you a phone. It's fundamentally evil, regardless of how they dress it up. Support Mozilla FirefoxOS and internet freedom.
- glogla 13y agoWhile Firefox OS is indeed impressive and good for freedom, for someone used to better screen the 320*480 screen of ZTE Open is pretty terrible to use. I hope that soon we can get something like Moto G with FxOS.
- therandomguy 13y agoThis is what I though iPhone 5c would be.
- auctiontheory 13y agoI don't get it. If you're using a smart phone for all the things that smart phones do (audio, photo albums, video), 16GB just isn't enough. Even my 32GB iPhone requires active file management to avoid hitting the limit.
- fastest963 13y agoI have not had a phone with over 32GB for the past 2 years and yet I've never had to perform "active file management" or delete any media from my phone. I consume all my music through Grooveshark and Play Music and watch videos on Netflix or YouTube.
- auctiontheory 13y agoDo you only use your phone at home or when you have Wi-Fi access? (Do you live in South Korea?) Most US cellular data plans don't allow very much streaming audio, let alone video, before you hit a cap. Certainly not a month's worth. Source: I've easily hit my cap when I mistakenly turned off Wi-Fi.
- fixedd 13y agoSmart music services (such as Play) will use this radical new technology called caching so that you don't have to stream everything you listen to if you have things you listen to more often.
- auctiontheory 13y agoCool. Where are they "caching" the content if not on your device? In the ether?
- evandena 13y agoI think the target demographic isn't a heavy media consumer, so going with lower storage keeps the price down. Also, cloud.
- ceras 13y ago
- fidotron 13y agoI think questions need to begin to be asked about Google getting close to giving the hardware away in return for user information. It gets dangerously close to the kind of practices that got MS in trouble, especially the way it ends up poisoning the market for anyone else. The problem is competition is good, and if users want their privacy they probably should be going to pay for it, but I'm profoundly uncomfortable with essentially condemning those that can't afford it to having to surrender their rights to privacy.
- DCKing 13y ago"I'm profoundly uncomfortable with essentially condemning those that can't afford it to having to surrender their rights to privacy." You appear to be implying that you can get extra privacy by buying a more expensive phone. However, the Moto G does not actually seem to be any more or any less invading of privacy compared to any other Android phone out there (and arguably not moreso even compared to Windows Phones and iPhones). Even if those phones are much more expensive than it. Furthermore, the inevitable popularity of the Moto G only means that you will be able to load it with a custom ROM that gives you as much control as you want, like Cyanogenmod/OmniROM without Google apps. Google rightly gets flak for privacy issues, but I think you're going too far by getting the privacy debate into hardware pricing as well.
- fidotron 13y agoOK, I admit it's not a perfect viewpoint, but I don't think any is! The problem here is these things should be private by default, with the option to break from that, since installing things like Cyanogenmod have external dependencies (like PCs) that cost money and people may not have access to. Features such as weather forecast widgets should not break if you choose not to share your location with Google, and right now many will. Further, I think Google are monopolising areas such as push email to such a degree they should be forced, MS in EU style, to give you a choice of accounts you can use to access things on the device when first started up. For example, there is no technical reason you couldn't use your twitter (or any OAuth) account as your ID, even when accessing Google services like the Play Store, but they are using all this to weasel Google+ in everywhere.
- lnanek2 13y agoAs someone in the US, I'm not really willing to buy a phone with no LTE in this day and age, and carriers will loathe to put them in stores. I think even HTC's Facebook phone from last year is a better attempt than this, goes for free on contract, and could probably be obtained as cheaply off ebay. I doubt this is really meant to sell in the US anyway, though.