4 ms·
Four Reasons a Guaranteed Income Won't Work
- benjohnson 13y agoIt's sad that many who claim to support 'welfare' don't like this idea because it reduces their ability to manipulate people.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoAnother way of phrasing the same thing, is that modern welfare systems (e.g. Australia's) put reasonable conditions on receiving welfare, that make it possible to target welfare to only the people who really cannot find a job, making the disincentive to work associated with welfare much smaller than it would have been otherwise. I actually think it's sadder that you think characterizing people's attitudes using negative terminology is a substitute for a real argument. EDIT: I've never complained about ratings before, but is this really a bad argument, or do basic income proponents just think that everyone who disagrees with them is an evil ignorant person? It seems to me that certain causes attract zealots.
- scarmig 13y agoDon't feel bad--I got net two downvotes above for pointing out the numbers showing that federal spending on healthcare and Social Security together gets us substantially closer to being able to fund it (I'm pretty sure they're not wrong numbers--if so, whoever's down voting, just point it out and I'll happily hash it out). Zealots exist anywhere. Here, have an upvote.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoyeah I shouldn't be so touchy. It's probably just controversial issues in general that make people downvote based on the perceived motives of the poster rather than the argument.
- snowwrestler 13y agoIs all manipulation bad? Ever worked harder because there was a deadline coming up? Or a bonus? Or a funding round?
- svachalek 13y agoIn regards to the first point, I'm not sure what kind of crazy implementation they had in mind with their discussion panel. Pretty much everyone who makes money is paying some kind of taxes, and there's usually some baseline deduction built in there. That's what you convert into UBI for the taxpayer. It's like the flat tax in that the net result shouldn't necessarily be more or less expensive than the current system, just a heck of a lot simpler.
- andrewfong 13y agoOne way of addressing the latter three points (reciprocity, politics, work) in part is to only give a guaranteed income to people who are actually working, regardless of how much they're earning. People would still have to work and contribute to society, but they would receive an income greater than the fair market value for that work. In the U.S., this would basically take the form of boosting the existing Earned Income Tax Credit.
- gremlinsinc 13y agoNo, having any requirement at all puts more bureacracy into it, the point is to get rid of bureacracy -because that requires money for paperwork filing, and management, that could be spend on instituting the policy. The better method would be to have tax breaks for employed individuals. Perhaps each person would be required to pay back $500 in taxes per year if they're not employed, or something similar... Though, I feel we should move away from income tax as well and just have a national sales tax which would fluctuate based on what outstanding debt is and how much is brought in per year. It IS possible to get spending in check, and fix everything, but we need to get rid of a LOT of bloat, there are WAY too many uneeded jobs in congress(especially in congress/and the senate lol). Personally, if I had a gbi, I would NOT work--in the basic sense, I WOULD innovate and do freelance work to earn extra money to put towards a startup idea... That is what I love about GBI -- the fact that entrepreneurs don't need to work but can actually work full-time on their business ideas!
- andrewfong 13y agoTax breaks for employed individuals is exactly what the EITC is. Assuming you stick with an income-based tax system, employment verification is effectively built in and requires little to no additional bureaucracy. A national sales tax comes with its own set of bureaucracy. It's also regressive and shifts the tax burden disproportionately onto the poor (unless you made the sales tax wealth or income dependent, which would introduce the same bureaucracy you were trying to get rid of earlier). I'm not sure a GBI would necessarily be good for entrepreneurship. I see your point, but having a runway disciplines young companies and forces them to get to market in a timely manner.
- jupiterjaz 13y ago"Cutting everyone a check for $1,000 a month, which most people in that room would consider too little to live on, would cost almost $3 trillion." ...What? I work a low skill service sector job and I only make $850 per month after all the taxes and deductions are taken out and I do fine as far as shelter and food are concerned. $1000 a month is plenty if it's after taxes and deductions.
- growupkids 13y agoI think the authors point was that the people in that room consider $1000 a month to not be a livable wage. Therefore, the inference is that those people would want to see more than $1000 a month, which would be even more costly. Perhaps the author just picked $1000 for ease of mathematical illustration.
- benjohnson 13y agoI certainly agree - I've been in situations where I've made about $850 per month and did especially fine if I pooled my money among others.
- hannibalhorn 13y agoThe $600bn spent on "income security" excludes social security, no? That's a huge chunk of change, and a basic income could in effect replace the need for it. That said, any sort of transition would be difficult to implement (and political kryptonite.)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- philwelch 13y agoYou still end up with about a $2000bn net cost even after taking social security into account.
- scarmig 13y agoIt definitely does exclude Social Security, which as a program amounts to ~$750 billion a year. And Medicare and Medicaid, which amount to another $600 or $700 billion. Combine them and the $600 billion on income security, and you get about $2 trillion, which is enough to fund a huge chunk of it. I don't understand the how McArdle thinks that $12,000 per year is too austere for most people to live comfortably on and simultaneously decries how it will make many people drop out of the workforce. She should address what (many) advocates of it want. Political concerns are, of course, another question.
- philwelch 13y agoBasic income can't be a drop-in replacement for federal health care programs, because to get equivalent care you'd either need considerably more basic income or some other mechanism for providing health care. The most generous assumption from an accounting perspective is probably that the US adopts, wholesale, the Canadian medical system with equivalent per-capita costs borne by the federal government.
- scarmig 13y agoWhy? People know best how to spend their money. The government shouldn't effectively force people to consume healthcare. Especially when there's evidence out there that programs like Medicaid provide no net healthcare benefit to recipients. Health outcomes might even improve, if the money that would be going to Medicaid instead goes to people spending more time on self improvement and health. ETA: That said, feasibility is always the question. Given that, I'd be happy as a duck to make the basic income only $8,000 a year or whatever. Then again, I'm one of the austere basic income advocates--I'm on the fence about the Swiss proposal because I think it's far, far too generous, even considering the higher COL there.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoThe "cost" and "work" arguments really need to be combined together (this is also why economists prefer models to verbal arguments - it forces some amount of internal consistency and avoids endless arguments about definitions). The primary difference between conventional welfare and basic income, is that you can have extremely high effective marginal tax rates for people on welfare. E.g. in Australia your effective marginal tax rate while on welfare is around 50%. For each dollar you earn, you get $0.50 less welfare (and pay a small amount of tax too). Usually high marginal tax rates are associate with a disincentive to work. However since when you are on welfare, the government makes you report your job-seeking activity, you are forced to try to look for work even though without this monitoring there would be little financial incentive to work. So having strings attached to welfare allows a higher effective marginal tax rate for people on welfare, and is therefore "cheaper" in some sense.
- scotty79 13y ago> I would not be opposed to a system of guaranteed jobs that paid $10,000 a year, or whatever we think this basic income should be. It already exists. It's called civil service/public sector and the problem with it is that there's not enough money and not enough made up jobs to hire everyone.
- gruseom 13y agoMost of these objections (e.g. the reciprocity thing) seem absurdly made-up; you could just as easily make up something opposite. But a couple of points are substantive if not substantiated. For example: But if you means-test it to control the cost, or try to tax most of the benefits back for people who aren’t low-income, you rapidly lose the efficiency gains and start creating some pretty powerful disincentives to work. Why? I can see how "means-test" might imply bureaucracy and thus inefficiency, but what's wrong with using tax policy for this? It seems like an obvious way to ensure that people who don't need the money don't get it, and no more inefficient as everyone has to fill out their taxes anyway. Come to think of it, isn't that so obvious that the debate ought to start there, rather than end there? Otherwise the objections start to seem rather straw-man.
- didgeoridoo 13y agoThat's not it. The issue is that "means testing" a basic income results in an effectively negative marginal tax rate for those below the means-testing line. The argument is that this is a strong disincentive to attempt to climb out of dependency.
- gruseom 13y agoOh, I see now. That at least makes some sense. But surely you could construct some formula to mitigate that effect, if not eliminate it? I fear that many arguments about incentive and disincentive are just morality tales anyway, based on beliefs about human nature. It's easy to imagine opposite stories. Maybe there will be a social incentive to work. Maybe there won't be enough jobs for everyone anyway. Maybe the disincentive to work will make wages go high enough that they become an incentive to work again. Maybe the disincentive to do menial jobs will free up incentive to do creative things, a net win for society. It's easy to make these things up, and everyone mostly does it based on whether they already like or dislike an idea. (I rather like this one. Megan Mcardle presumably doesn't.) But do we have a good way to decide between them?
- scarmig 13y agoIt creates a steep marginal tax rate. Imagine that there's a basic income of $12,000/year. It's means tested so that people making $36,000/year don't receive any funding. If you go with a simple flat implementation of this, it amounts to a 33% tax rate on the first $36,000 of income. And that's at best--if you go with something that causes basic income to phase out only between $24,000 and $36,000, you go from $24,000 regular + $12,000 basic income to $36,000 regular and $0 basic--a 100% marginal rate. You can make it phase out over larger and larger income ranges--say, make it phase out at a flat rate between $0 and $100k--but at that point you get very little of the cost benefits of means testing.
- 3pt14159 13y agoThe whole point is that some people won't be working because they are being made obsolete with the advent of computerized robotics. I don't want the uninformed and skilless clamouring to be in the work force, I want them out of the way. As for the cost, that is simple. Don't just look at federal numbers. Basic Income should be at National, State/Province, and City level to iron out regional differences. Don't forget that there are a lot of other costs that go away with a Basic Income, like minimum wage and socialized housing.
- philwelch 13y agoIt will be nice to give everyone a basic income when robots have automated away all the jobs, but what do we do this decade? Don't be lazy. If you think basic income is feasible with state and city assistance, run the numbers for San Francisco and California. Otherwise one side has numbers and you have idle, unquantified speculation.
- marknutter 13y agoPeople have been predicting the demise of the workforce ever since the industrial age (and probably before that, too). With every technological innovation we cry "it's the end of work as we know it!" Yet here we are, hundreds of years in the future, with jobs abound. I'm skeptical that will ever change. We humans are great at coming up with shit for people to do for a dollar.
- brownbat 13y agoOr, "There is a long history of exaggerated concern, rightly derided by economists, with the replacement and hence displacement of workers by machines." http://www.becker-posner-blog.com/2013/03/automation-and-employment-posner.html http://www.becker-posner-blog.com/2013/03/automation-and-emp... Abrupt technological advances can disrupt certain industries very quickly, and it can take a while for the wages and the workforce size to find a new equilibrium. But I agree, that's much different than the sudden and dystopian end of all labor.
- waps 13y ago
- jfarmer 13y agoThese arguments are specious. Most Libertarian proponents of a guaranteed income don't favor it because it will "save money," but because it's the least economically distortive way of redistributing wealth. The arguments goes, "Well, as long we're going to be handing out money, we should do it in a way that minimizes the number of strange incentives." There are also ways of implementing a guaranteed income that don't involve mailing a bunch of checks to people every month, e.g., a negative income tax. Overall the article appears to be arguing against a particular and very naïve implementation of a guaranteed income.
- philwelch 13y agoSo how does a negative income tax get implemented, you mail people a "refund" after they file their taxes for 0 income for the previous year? What do they do until then?
- ds9 13y agoWell here is one way it could be implemented, and this would also solve the issue of cost. Imagine it's offset against earnings. That is, if you earn more or less than the benefit amount, you get paid the difference - in one case by the employer, in the other case by the government. You can see how this solves the cost problem: the society overall is already paying the total cost is of whatever people are currently paid; this just puts a floor on the range. Clearly this would get rid of much of the extreme inequality: it would amount to a kind of minimum wage; the net effect would be to give workers a larger share, and more bargaining power, and leave less for the upper-middle and the 1% - at no more cost than the current system.
- patmcc 13y agoTo the cost argument: to say "it would be hard to manage efficiently" makes it looks like most first-world countries don't already have a massively successful income tax collection program of some kind. They do. Tax rates could be set so anyone at the minimum income wouldn't pay; anyone at that level to "middle class" (or whatever) would pay back part of it in taxes; and anyone above a certain level would pay back more than the minimum income. Would some people be taking home less overall? Yeah, sure. Same as any other welfare service. As for the idea that people won't work anymore and society would crumble - people like xboxes and new iphones and clothes and nice cars and even feeling productive. I tend to believe they'll keep working. Some will stop, sure. They're the same people who don't work now or are criminals.
- marknutter 13y agoThe problem is when people start to say that money for xboxes, clothes, and new iphones should be covered by a basic income.
- adamnemecek 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slippery_slope
- oakwhiz 13y agoYou're saying that people should not be allowed to purchase clothing with money from social assistance programs. I'm fairly certain that clothing is a basic human necessity, especially during the winter. The problem is when people start to say that they ought to have control over other people's lives.
- adamnemecek 13y agoFor anyone unfamiliar with the author, she has close ties with the Koch brothers so remember that while reading the article. EDIT: You can read more about her at http://shameproject.com/profile/megan-mcardle/ http://shameproject.com/profile/megan-mcardle/.
- cies 13y agoFunny, I already had the idea she was on that "side" of the game when I read it. :)
- yetanotherphd 13y agoI don't quite get why you think this is useful info. Koch brothers are just people promoting a political agenda, like George Soros or any political party. Everyone has a political viewpoint, and it's hard to see anything wrong with writing articles consistent with that viewpoint.
- adamnemecek 13y ago> I don't quite get why you think this is useful info. Because I'm repulsed by everything they stand for. The world would be a better place if they were dead. > Koch brothers are just people promoting a political agenda, like George Soros or any political party. Well I guess I should get rid of that shrine devoted to George Soros that I have then. Or what's your point? > Everyone has a political viewpoint, and it's hard to see anything wrong with writing articles consistent with that viewpoint. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Propaganda
- yetanotherphd 13y agoYou haven't addressed the issue of relevancy. Let me put it another way: How much do we need to know about the journalist's views beyond the views that are expressed in the article? As far as I can tell, the article already reflects the author's ideology. So by reading the article you are not going to be mislead. The page you linked cited some instances of people promoting policies that would help the Koch brother's commercial interests. In that case the link is relevant. But if someone writes something right wing and you post "LOOK OUT EVERYONE THIS GUY IS A RIGHT WINGER", that does not add useful information.
- Houshalter 13y agoCost can be dealt with by making it a negative income tax. That way not everyone is getting the full amount. People that are already making money only get a little from the system, whereas truly poor people get more. The new tax would be set just enough that it pays for itself. It probably wouldn't start at an amount that replaces current systems like welfare, but even $3,000 would help considerably towards evening out wealth inequality. "People not working" is a good thing IMO, because many jobs have/are being automated and we can actually support people not having to work. The market rate for labor is pretty low. Things like the minimum wage prop it up even further from what the market rate would be. A lot of people not working would not actually cost the economy that much. And as I said, the minimum income would probably start at a low amount, so people would still have a large incentive to work for the time being.
- cies 13y ago> because many jobs have/are being automated and we can actually support people not having to work. Nicely put... I just want to dream on to this thought for a few minutes before I go on with my life :)
- philwelch 13y agoNegative income taxes are an elegant solution, but they entail literally paying people to commit tax evasion, not just in the "if I evade my taxes I won't have to pay as many" sense but also in the "if I evade my taxes the government will give me money" sense.
- wwweston 13y ago>"At any given point, a minimum-wage job may be very unattractive compared with spending more time with your family. But over the long run, it’s very hard to get a “good” job if you have been living on a basic income rather than working; employers do not like the signal sent by resume gaps." If a guaranteed income does in fact provide enough of the labor force with an incentive to drop out as an alternative, then it seems likely that employers would have to stop thinking of resume gaps as an indicator. Which, really, would be win-win, because my guess is that resume gaps are possibly less helpful in evaluating a candidate than most of the rest of the usual cargo cult surrounding hiring.
- mgkimsal 13y ago" then it seems likely that employers would have to stop thinking of resume gaps as an indicator." Exactly what I was thinking. I don't understand why it's so hard for people to consider that when social changes are introduced, some of the current ways we value things will change, and current judgements can't necessarily be used as a gauge for future behavior. Employers looking at 'gaps' and never ever inquiring from anyone remotely interesting why those gaps occurred are just throwing potentially great workers to the competition. "I took 18 months off to care for my dying parents, who passed away last month" is a totally different type of person from "meh - there's just too much quality day time television beckoning me to sit on the couch to bother looking for work".
- johnpmayer 13y ago> I don't understand why it's so hard for people to consider that when social changes are introduced, some of the current ways we value things will change, and current judgements can't necessarily be used as a gauge for future behavior. Ceteris paribus is quite prevalent in economic discussion.
- marknutter 13y agoThere will still be people who have employment gaps and those who don't, even with basic income. With enough resumes to filter through, that will still be a factor.
- 13y ago
- cies 13y ago"Less incentive to work" Yes! And more incentive to start a company! That's why big-corps/govts that employ a lot of low-wagers don't like this idea; and small-self-owned, small-hi-tech-govt, and potential biz starters without access to funding tend to like it. The level of the guaranteed income can be "low", thereby leaving "some" incentive to work. I like the fairness, low-overhead and the sigma-reduction of this method of wealth re-distribution very much. This method is not directly/economically benefiting the 1% -- sure, I agree on that. But it helps _a lot_ of people to live more comfortable and puts pressure on good labour conditions from the bottom up. Go Switzerland; please lead the way on this one -- it hope and predict it to be a great experiment! Edit: typo.
- chipsy 13y agoI'm coming around to believe that the most promising, direct method of implementing equitable wealth redistribution is through cryptocurrency. Probably not just yet, but within the upcoming generations of protocols; the change in philosophy away from a competitive/speculative, gold-like asset is in part foreshadowed by the growing popularity of proof-of-stake. In Nextcoin[0], for example, mining no longer exists. There are a lot of ways to model a currency so that rebalancing of wealth from richer accounts to poorer ones is a smooth, gradual, automatic process. And the software to do it, and the marketing campaign to popularize it, can be put together much more quickly and cheaply than ramming it through the existing political system. All of which isn't to say that the political process is dead; but there is potential for a revision of government's duties, where software can do the job instead of a bureaucracy. [0] http://nextcoin.org/index.php/topic,104.0.html http://nextcoin.org/index.php/topic,104.0.html
- pfranz 13y agoWorking backwards: 4) 'over the long run, it’s very hard to get a “good” job if you have been living on a basic income rather than working; employers do not like the signal sent by resume gaps' Economics would change significantly. If you wanted a "good" job and lacked the education and training you have the opportunity to pursue it on your own. I have a feeling there would be a huge increase in non-for-profit work (both in the traditional sense and in previously unseen markets), apprenticeships, and likely more internships (working for free at for-profit companies). I can't find any citation, but I remember recently reading about women joining the workforce significantly reduced the amount of volunteers for charities. 3) Politics would be very hard--but politics follow the people's will. If there's enough support, it'll happen (even if the transition is messy). I haven't seen strong, widespread support (or even wide knowledge of Guaranteed Income) just yet. 2) Admittedly, I'm not quite following the point. Society and government are the rules we all decide to make up and follow. The argument sounds very similar to politics, except 2) is convincing the people and 3) is convincing the politicians and people implementing it. 1) Cost is exactly why we're looking more seriously at this now (although, we may not be there yet). Ideally, it would be cost neutral or a net win to transition off of the quagmire of various welfare systems--similar to the argument for a flat tax rate. As a whole (speaking for the US) we're more prosperous and can afford to take on more of a social burden (or transition our social burden from various welfares to a simpler system). We're also moving toward a society where we don't need to have every person working to survive. I don't know if the statistics back up the narrative of city's factories getting closed and a majority of the population transitions to welfare and disability--while on the other side of the coin entertainment and the service industry are the largest growing markets.
- philwelch 13y ago> Ideally, it would be cost neutral or a net win to transition off of the quagmire of various welfare systems Ideals aren't convincing. Numbers are.
- pfranz 13y agoI completely agree. There are two aspects here; what do we want out of a society and what we can do with the resources we have (the numbers). We're clearly moving towards the resources, which is why I hedged so much on the topic of cost (and put it last instead of first). I'm just interested in moving the conversation in that direction. I like the idea, but I'm not entirely sold on it--it would be /very/ disruptive.
- drawkbox 13y agoI like to compare it to free to play. It could possible work if the high end becomes the whales that F2P games require to allow most people to play for free > 95-98% and then the riches made by the highest advancing 2-5% players provide the revenues to provide for the whole system. If there was some base level free to play number, it would be an evolutionary step as big as moving into modernized farming and what created markets, maths and the thinking man/woman due to extra time not having to survive all the time. Somehow the system would have to allow for the tasks noone wants to do though maybe by rewards. It could skew actual needed services ahead of more greedy ones. All of the biggest games and internet product companies are free to play, maybe society is next or it will have to be when labor is limited, new things will have to be created and more freedom is needed to solve these problems.