3 ms·
"'The very experts who could kind of inform everyone else don't. They actually keep feeding them the information they already know because that helps establish
by tokenadult 17y ago
"'The very experts who could kind of inform everyone else don't. They actually keep feeding them the information they already know because that helps establish a connection,' Fast says."
This is a very good description of a lot of online communication, including many HN discussion threads. But I don't have to tell you that, because you already know it. I guess this generalizes to saying that it feels like swimming upstream sometimes to add significant amounts of new information to an online discussion among casual participants who may not know one another in real life. I find it easier to dig out my references and really lay out a lot of new information in some online networks I participate in with other members of a membership organization. Many of us have met one another in real life, and have already established emotional bonds over a meal or a beer, so on those networks I feel more comfortable challenging conventional wisdom. That CAN happen here on HN, of course, but it feels considerably less natural.
- Radix 17y agoFWIW, you're one of my favorite posters and commenters. Your posts often feel as a new idea. Perhaps your beliefs and views are different enough enough from the established practice (of education or other) that what is old information to you sounds like new information to others (me). You may feel as though you're swimming upstream, but I simply find a new idea to play with. I really do enjoy your posts.
- jlees 17y agoI actually find it interesting that among geek circles, invoking obscure knowledge, including obscure 'celebrities', can build one's credibility. Hence, aren't you more likely to encounter stuff (and people) you didn't know beforehand when talking to hackers - and pretend you knew it all along? It's also a meritocracy, generally smart hackers get famous because they do smart things, not because they release a sex tape.