2 ms·
Success means "not extinct".
by anamax 17y ago
Success means "not extinct".
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoYes but among those who survive, is the common cold virus more successful than ebola? I don't think there's a good answer to that.
- anamax 17y agoThat's because "more successful" is not a good question. Unless one or the other dies out, they're both successful and that's all that you can really say. The common cold is more common than Ebola. That may help the common cold survive longer. If it does, and we suspect that it does, then "common" was useful. If, on the other hand, that "commonality" makes us so mad that we go all out to kill it and succeed (like we probably have with small pox and might soon with polio), "common" worked against it.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoI agree with what you say, but I was trying make an entirely different point, which is that I don't think success is the right word to describe anything related to evolution. Success implies goals and evolution has no goals. A particular species surviving or not is just like rolling a die and observing that the 3 has come up and the other numbers didn't. It's useless to say that 4 wasn't successful. Nobody would say that, but when it comes to evolution people start to talk about success as if nature had intentions.
- anamax 17y ago> Success implies goals and evolution has no goals. I agree, but evolution does have results. The one that drives everything is survives.