3 ms·
Disclaimer: I am definitely being contrarian here and do not necessarily advocate Dijkstra's position. In Dijkstra's essay "On the cruelty of really teaching c
by the_af 13y ago
Disclaimer: I am definitely being contrarian here and do not necessarily advocate Dijkstra's position.
In Dijkstra's essay "On the cruelty of really teaching computer science", posted here multiple times, he states:
"Right from the beginning, and all through the course, we stress that the programmer's task is not just to write down a program, but that his main task is to give a formal proof that the program he proposes meets the equally formal functional specification. While designing proofs and programs hand in hand, the student gets ample opportunity to perfect his manipulative agility with the predicate calculus. Finally, in order to drive home the message that this introductory programming course is primarily a course in formal mathematics, we see to it that the programming language in question has not been implemented on campus so that students are protected from the temptation to test their programs. And this concludes the sketch of my proposal for an introductory programming course for freshmen."
(Do read his guesses about how his suggestion would be attacked and ridiculed. Reasons he obviously didn't agree with).
- jerf 13y agoI wish we could consult a Dijkstra of today. He faced radically different costs of sitting a student in front of a computer. His opinions might change if he could do what we do today, both simultaneously, for what might as well be "free". As I said, study still has its place, do not get me wrong, but I see no reason to hold the student back from a compiler/REPL even as we are formally educating them.