3 ms·
> What I find interesting is the chart where they estimate daily mining revenue to be on the order of $10 million/day, assuming current prices. Probably, that
by gwern 13y ago
> What I find interesting is the chart where they estimate daily mining revenue to be on the order of $10 million/day, assuming current prices. Probably, that computation should be easy to verify using the various Bitcoin websites.
One thing I like to point out is that right now mining is over-subsidized by the basic protocol: why is the block reward 25btc (or whatever it is now)? It's completely arbitrary and is paying the miners more than their services are worth (hence the arms race to earn as much of the reward as possible).
The point of mining is to secure the blockchain and render it infeasible to perform double-spends, right? But double-spends are not that disastrous: a few double-spends are an inconvenience and not a disaster for Bitcoin. There is no need to allocate 25btc a block to achieve the current record of close to zero successful double-spends. It is wasteful.
So as the block reward declines, we'll see more reasonable amounts of revenue flowing to miners and hence also a decline in how much computing power (electricity) is spent, eventually converging on what is optimal for securing the blockchain.
- retr0rocket 13y agoare you retarded? 25btc is just an arbitrary number and thats why it can't be too high, it use to be fractions of a penny. now its 25k because that is how much that work is considered to be worth. the end.
- technofinance 13y agodouble-spends are not that disastrous? You've go to be out of your mind. If your bank or credit card allowed you to double spend your account they would be out of business very very quickly. Same thing applies to cryptocurrencies.
- gwern 13y agoAre you sure you understand how double-spends in Bitcoin work? If you did, the right response would not be to double-down and engage in false dichotomies where a single double-spend of any transaction ever is a 100% disaster, and instead, adopt the more nuanced perspective that a few double-spends will not kill the currency, will save vast amounts of computational resources, and users can opt into however much security they require by waiting an appropriate number of confirmations.
- nhaehnle 13y agoSo... you'll have miners who have sunk huge investments into powerful computers who are unhappy to see their investments become worthless, and who have the computer power to force high transaction fees onto Bitcoin users. That'll certainly be interesting to watch. Somebody is going to lose big time. The question is whether Bitcoin as a currency will survive in the fallout.
- gwern 13y agoThe decline in block reward is gradual and predictable enough that your scenario simply won't happen.