5 ms·
London Stock Exchange to abandon MS Windows
- TrevorJ 17y agoThe article doesn't seem to indicate that LSE will be dumping windows -just dumping a third-party product that happened to run on windows. It is unclear what platform the new vendor will be using. It is also unclear that the trouble outlined here was the fault of the OS or just a poorly-coded program running on top of it.
- wyday 17y agoBut you don't get thousands of clicks if you title your article "Bad Programmers Create Shitty Programs".
- maukdaddy 17y agoProgrammed by Accenture. There's your problem.
- zen53 17y agoThere is a great comment in the article from a person who worked at Accenture... "I finally quit after walking out of a berating meeting from a boss who reckoned I'd done a project too fast and produced an executable that was too small. "We quoted them three point two million for this. We can't give them a 500 Kb executable after a week and say it's done"
- jodrellblank 17y agoI'd be annoyed if that's all I got. For 3.2 million, I'd hope for some good documentation, guides, and some fanfare, preferably some evidence of the QA procedure it's been through, too. You can't put ten thousand dollars+ of polish on a project in a week, can you?
- dtf 17y agoI can't imagine why anyone would ask Accenture to program something as critical and technically demanding as a trading platform. Their public record here in the UK is appalling - the NHS and British Gas are two horrendous cock ups that spring to mind. How on earth do they win these kind of contracts? Brown envelopes?
- ams6110 17y agoAbsolutely. You know who writes code at Accenture? 22-year-old liberal arts and business majors, in their first job out of college, who've had about 6 weeks of training in programming.
- christofd 17y agohmm... I was surprised several years back by the announcement when LSE (London Stock Exchange) moved to MSFT server products, since people in banking mostly tell me that Java/Unix is standard.
- mrtron 17y agoIf people in banking tell you that Java/Unix is standard (which it is), why does one exchange moving some components to MSFT products impress you?
- gaius 17y agoThere is no "standard". In any investment bank you'll find everything from MUMPS to MATLAB, VAX Pascal, APL, Haskell. The result of a) many acquisitions and mergers and b) a culture of if you need something, build it yourself, out of whatever you have to hand. I've seen NeXTStep and OS/2 and even an Amiga on trading floors.
- christofd 17y agoWait a sec, that's not infrastructure there running in individual trading departments. Major transactional backbones in banking almost all run on Java/Unix as I understand.
- gaius 17y agoFor the really mission-critical systems there's more COBOL, C++ and even VAX Basic (I'm not kidding) than there is Java, and there's a lot of mainframe and VMS too, and weird Unixes like Dynix. A lot of it is stuff that people outside the industry will never even see anymore. One project I worked on in fixed income was C++ based, it could handle a few hundred trades per second on modest kit. When I left I think the J2EE rewrite was up to 6 trades per minute...
- dtf 17y agoTradElect was launched at the same time that BetFair, a big internet betting exchange, announced its own FlyWheel platform. FlyWheel took 2 years to develop internally (apparently with two different dev teams initially competing against each other) at a cost of around £1m. It runs on Oracle/JBoss/Linux/x86 on £25k worth of kit, and does up to 1m TPS (compare with TradElect's £40m to achieve a target of 68k TPS, which apparently it never achieved).
- imajes 17y agoI heard about this. It's a real shame that BetFair's system isn't being implemented for the LSE- i hear it far out strips any 'real world' use cases and can handle it all really well. Sounds pretty awesome to boot. :)
- Quarrelsome 17y agoWhat the hell? So when a driver of a Toyota car crashes into a tree it's Toyota at fault as opposed to the driver? I have no idea why the author has decided to crowbar their own bias on platform preference into this article. There doesn't appear to be any information that states its the platform at fault.
- martin 17y agoI stopped reading at the point he described the existing solution as "a custom blend of C# and .NET programs." He obviously doesn't have a clue about the platform he's bashing.
- mustpax 17y agoSteven J. Vaughan-Nichols has quite a thing for Linux and OSS in general. Check out his articles here: http://blogs.computerworld.com/sjvn http://blogs.computerworld.com/sjvn I mean, I derive no pleasure from using bloated MS software myself (cough Outlook cough), but this guy clearly has an agenda that guides his reporting.
- StrawberryFrog 17y agoAgendas can be Ok, if you have a clue, and some idea of where the real story lies coughAccenturecough. Where I would start - What was the spec for the system? Did it change? What development method was used? was it agile? What test coverage did the system have? How many developers were on it, and how experienced were they? Leaping from "a windows-based system failed" to "anyone ever fool enough to believe that Microsoft software was good enough" and mentioning .Net and MS SQL Server as specific examples is just moronic and ignorant.
- gaius 17y agoI would say the software fulfilled its requirement 100%. It's requirement was to make a boatload of cash for Accenture.
- buugs 17y agoLots of diggs for someone who doesn't proofread his articles. I'm guessing he relates well to their user base.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoHe tells bigots what they want to hear. That's a true success formula. (disclaimer: I use Windows, Linux and OS X and I'm not enthusiastic about any of them)
- olefoo 17y agoMy painful discovery of the day was the sad revelation that in 2009 Microsoft still has not yet moved on from case-insensitive filesystems. I'm sorry, but if your operating system cannot distinguish between ['ass','Ass','ASS'] then it is a toy and not a tool. Modding me down does not erase this painful truth.
- gaius 17y agoA case insensitive filesystem needs to convert everything into a single case before doing any string comparisons. The only reason Unix doesn't do this is because they couldn't spare the CPU to do it in the original implementation. So not only are you offtopic, but you have your chronology backwards.
- olefoo 17y agoSorry, but a filesystem that doesn't preserve exactly what I put into it is broken. And the only chronology I mentioned was my surprise that Windows is still broken, even in it's latest iteration (Vista). I am glad that I only have to deal with Microsoft product on an extremely occasional basis. I feel sorry for people who are so emotionally invested in their operating system that they can't see that OpenBSD is the answer... ;-)
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y ago> Sorry, but a filesystem that doesn't preserve exactly what I put into it is broken. I work with non-hackers, non-computer people who use computers as tools. They are constantly surprised that Linux does make a distinction between cases. They remember the words they used as the names of documents, letters, reports, etc., and they don't want to have to remember whether it was capitalised or not. Dictating names of documents becomes a chore when you have to specify the capitalisation. Just the other day my wife was trying to find a submission of mine here on HN and ended up phoning me in frustration, exactly because the system remembers/keeps exactly what was put into it. Your attitude, quite rightly here for a hacker, is that you want the system to do exactly what you want. For entrepreneurs and others who deal with non-hackers, knowing that most of the world don't see things the same way, and occasionally want something "obviously wrong," is important. (edited for typos)