2 ms·
My feeling is that your proposal makes no economic sense. What's the market? How big is that market compared to the external market? People pay to have their ar
by dalke 13y ago
My feeling is that your proposal makes no economic sense. What's the market? How big is that market compared to the external market? People pay to have their articles published. The price ranges between $100 and $1,500. As a reward, people get prestige and career advancement.
Others journals a free to publish, but the readers pay an access fee.
In any case, in most cases the publication fee is much smaller than the time and effort needed to write a paper.
So a pittance fee - even $100 for all error corrections per paper - isn't enough to change that overall market. You need to have serious money to make a difference.
If someone has evidence which, say, shows rabbits and velociraptors co-existed, then it's more cost effective to publish that paper in its own right. I can't figure out why another publication/error correction system would be more effective.
Consider also that many research fields are very small. The next person to understand the paper well enough to correct it might not come around for 10 years. Market-based solutions don't work well on long timescales like that.