6 ms·
> Mandela was a symbol of non-peaceful resistance Yes, and: "Umkhonto we Sizwe (translated as "Spear of the Nation") was the armed wing of the African Nationa
by SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago
> Mandela was a symbol of non-peaceful resistance
Yes, and:
"Umkhonto we Sizwe (translated as "Spear of the Nation") was the armed wing of the African National Congress (ANC), co-founded by Nelson Mandela, fought against the South African government....
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umkhonto_we_Sizwe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umkhonto_we_Sizwe
Indeed, let's not allow anyone to sanitise history. It's a fact that Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher and PW Botha all called him a terrorist.
- cm2012 13y agoWhile this is true, the remarkable part about Mandela is that his greatest accomplishments came 27 years after leaving the path of violence. He left prison not seeking revenge when it was possible, but offering forgiveness and hope.
- mcantelon 13y agoMandela was a pragmatist. Non-violence was a tactic that fit the strategic need.
- lennel 13y agotactic yes, but also a great appeal to his humanist intellectual position.
- capex 13y agoHe could've been out of jail in a moment if he ever wanted to be a pragmatist.
- Crito 13y agoWould leaving jail under those circumstances have helped his cause? If not, then doing so would not have been pragmatic.
- tptacek 13y agoI'm not sure that being called a terrorist by PW Botha is all that meaningful.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoTrue, but Reagan and Thatcher's statements had economic and military impact.
- tptacek 13y agoThe Reagan administration implemented the Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act.
- tomjakubowski 13y agoThe Act that Reagan himself vetoed, yes.
- refurb 13y agoReagan's explanation for vetoing is the same that many on the left use for advocating removal of the Cuba sanctions: they hurt the people more than they help.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoReagan's real reason (as opposed to his explanation) was that during the cold war the USA would support any regime even really shitty ones like Pinochet in Chile or the National Party of South Africa that was openly anti-communist.
- nashequilibrium 13y agoReagan actually vetoed it, what i find funny is this line: " President Reagan enlisted South African foreign minister Pik Botha to call Republicans on the fence." Pik Botha was one of the hardest apartheid officials, he held out until the end and wanted war. Source below. '''Veto by President Reagan[edit] Reagan vetoed the compromised bill on September 26, calling it "economic warfare" and alleging that it would mostly hurt the impoverished black majority and lead to more civil strife.[10] He again offered to impose sanctions via executive order, while also working with Senate Republicans on concessions to avoid them overriding his veto. Reagan's veto was attacked harshly by anti-Apartheid leaders like Desmond Tutu who said Reagan would be "judged harshly by history".[11] In the week leading up to the subsequent vote, President Reagan enlisted South African foreign minister Pik Botha to call Republicans on the fence, though this was seen to backfire.[12] Veto override[edit] Reagan's veto was overridden by Congress (by the Senate 78 to 21, the House by 313 to 83) on October 2.[13] This override marked the first time in the twentieth century that a president had a foreign policy veto overridden.[2] Apartheid opponents in America and South Africa applauded the vote, while critics argued that it would be either ineffectual or lead to more violence.[12][14]'''
- moocowduckquack 13y agoIt's a fact that Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher and PW Botha all called him a terrorist. Is a bit like being called a wanker by Onan. edit - pekk, it won't let me reply at the moment, but in answer to your comment, Thatcher was no idiot by any stretch of the imagination, but she did send the SAS to train Pol-Pot led forces, while Reagan put up the money, so I think she definitely had more than a little blood on her hands. - http://www.newstatesman.com/node/137397 http://www.newstatesman.com/node/137397
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y agoIn hindsight, yes.
- pekk 13y agoMargaret Thatcher (to pick one) was a terrible idiot, but not a terrorist.
- jessedhillon 13y agoTerrorism is a term used to describe almost exclusively violence conducted at the intersection of non-state endorsement and non-Western. A definition of terrorism which is derived from the impact and motivations of the violence would be impossible: state-sanctioned and non-sanctioned violence are separated by very blurry lines in those dimensions. Therefore to say Margeret Thatcher is not a terrorist is like saying "blue things are not yellow." Duh. The term exists specifically to describe violence conducted by people who are not Thatchers.
- darkr 13y ago> Therefore to say Margeret Thatcher is not a terrorist is like saying "blue things are not yellow." Duh. The term exists specifically to describe violence conducted by people who are not Thatchers. Unless you're Mark Thatcher http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Thatcher#2004_Equatorial_Guinea_coup_d.27.C3.A9tat_attempt http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Thatcher#2004_Equatorial_G...
- 13y ago
- statguy 13y ago> Indeed, let's not allow anyone to sanitise history. It's a fact that Ronald Reagan, Margaret Thatcher and PW Botha all called him a terrorist. That says more about them than it says about Mandela.
- mcv 13y agoWhat's more, he was on the US terrorist list until 2008. I think the fact that Mandela was on it until 2008 is pretty much all you need to know about the US terrorist list. It can't be a very good list. One man's freedom fighter is another man's terrorist. But Mandela fought for a very important cause: the freedom of an oppressed people. And he always used the most effective and appropriate weapons to fight that fight. Anyone who calls him a terrorist is a crook.
- 72deluxe 13y agoI have no views on political matters but anyone who feels oppressed and fights back would by your argument be perfectly acceptable and their violence legitimate. If I feel oppressed, is violence by me perfectly acceptable? I suppose it depends who is defining what "oppressed" means.
- mcv 13y agoIt's not about feeling oppressed, it's about being oppressed, and not having any democratic means to change it. Use the soap box and the ballot box first. It's only when they take away your right to vote and your right to express your political ideas, that violence becomes your only option for change.
- ottovondog 13y agoThe US is a symbol of non-peaceful dominance but somehow, thats okay, because 'destroying WMDs' or 'getting rid of the Taliban' are all better reasons to use violence than decades of systematic oppression.