3 ms·
Similarly, gasoline has chemical energy which can effect work, and this would still be true if every other human disappeared. But those properties have no "val
by dnautics 13y ago
Similarly, gasoline has chemical energy which can effect work, and this would still be true if every other human disappeared.
But those properties have no "value" without humans to extract its "value" by using it, and/or desiring it. The point being, that there is no objective standard of "value" and that concept is hoplessly entangled with human desires and needs. For example, you could make the argument that there is "intrinsic value" in whale oil, but it doesn't matter because we can extract it from the ground in a cheaper fashion (that's arguably more ethical, too). The market for whale oil - outside of a very rare few corner cases that are more than taken care of by the strategic sperm oil reserve - is effectively zero.
- dpark 13y agoI think you are mixing several different things here. The size of the market for a thing does not define its intrinsic value under my definition. In fact the value assigned by the market is the opposite of intrinsic value, and my definition explicitly addressed this. The fact that whale oil has a very limited market and more efficient alternatives does not mean that it has no intrinsic value. As for value being tied to human want/needs, obviously this is true. A thing can have value by its very nature as opposed to value created by a market, though. Whale oil will heat my house even if no one else is interested in buying it. That is what I call the intrinsic value. The intrinsic value of a thing may be hard to extract without other people (e.g. Industrial uses), but this is different from saying that the value is tied solely to others' desires.