4 ms·
"the bigger issue is whether it is a basic human right to receive treatment regardless of your economic situation." Isn't housing a basic human right? How abou
by ars 17y ago
"the bigger issue is whether it is a basic human right to receive treatment regardless of your economic situation."
Isn't housing a basic human right? How about clothing? Or food? Or heat? Why is health care singled out?
There are programs to help the poor with those things, and there are programs that do the same with healthcare. Not all states fund it to the same level. Just increase the funding, and be done. There is no need for a national program.
- grandalf 17y agoMore succintly, if each state (or municipality) had its own program there would be a chance to learn what works best. Having a single national program is like doing an experiment with a single petri dish... unscientific and absurd.
- dflock 17y agoThis is how things are generally arranged in national health systems. In the UK for example, the NHS is actually made up of many local Primary Care Trusts (PCTs) which run the hospitals and whatnot in a local area; in larger cities a PCT can be one very large hospital, in more rural areas, maybe a whole county or two's worth of healthcare facilities. PCT's are funded centrally based on performance and patient load but managed and run locally. There is a reasonable attempt to learn from and spread best practice between PCT's but, obviously, no system created by humans is perfect.
- grandalf 17y agoNHS is an exception in that it constantly self-evaluates, etc. In one case it published a report admitting that it would have been better off (for outcomes and costs) simply contracting Kaiser (a US firm) to deliver care. This sort of honesty is truly unprecedented.
- mrtron 17y agoI would call those basic rights. In some of the developed world you can receive food, clothing, housing and heat already. Unfortunately, due to illness, addictions and other problems the programs often have difficulty reaching the people in need.