3 ms·
This kind of thinking only works if all intelligent people end up sharing and following your same ideals. Since that's just not going to happen, is it better to
by MichaelGG 13y ago
This kind of thinking only works if all intelligent people end up sharing and following your same ideals. Since that's just not going to happen, is it better to leave your country in the weak position?
How would the cold war have played out if only one side had nuclear capabilities?
I'm also not sure the NSA intelligence is on the same difficulty as the Manhattan Project. As I understand, most if it is general information retrieval techniques. The same tool I wrote to help troubleshoot our VoIP networks is literally the same thing I'd do if I was writing a mass-spying tool. (Collect and index every single packet, store indefinitely, provide fast on-demand access on any selection criteria.)
Edit: Parent comment was equating NSA surveillance in difficulty to the Manhattan Project, and making the case that if no one like Feynman had worked on it, there wouldn't be nukes.
- sillysaurus2 13y agoSorry about that. I retracted my comment because I felt it was meandering and muddled. This kind of thinking only works if all intelligent people end up sharing and following your same ideals. Since that's just not going to happen, is it better to leave your country in the weak position? Indeed, this is one of the reasons why there's not really much to say on the subject of ethics regarding the NSA's behavior. It's in people's nature to want to acquire as much power as possible, and there are endless justifications for doing so.