3 ms·
> How to be a responsible engineer who doesn't get people killed. Actually, the above oath will maximize the number of people killed if the sworn engineer happ
by munificent 13y ago
> How to be a responsible engineer who doesn't get people killed.
Actually, the above oath will maximize the number of people killed if the sworn engineer happens to be working on a weapon. There is absolutely nothing in that oath about not doing harm.
- jff 13y agoThere's a difference between a collapsing bridge (the original reason for the oath) and a weapon. You knew from the start that the weapon was going to kill people. I'm ok with designing weapons; my ethical beliefs allow that. It would be unethical to accept the project but deliver a weapon that didn't work properly.
- psykotic 13y ago> I'm ok with designing weapons; my ethical beliefs allow that. It would be unethical to accept the project but deliver a weapon that didn't work properly. Sabotage for a good cause is unethical? You have strange ethical beliefs.
- saraid216 13y ago> Actually, the above oath will maximize the number of people killed if the sworn engineer happens to be working on a weapon. That depends on the weapon. If a weapon malfunctions and kills its operators, that will help maximize casualties. But it would still be a failure on the engineer's part. If it's supposed to kill its operators, then it wasn't.