2 ms·
I think it changes a lot of peoples thoughts about the question. It moves it from a "let's play with the concept of sound" to a basic question of induction and
by MichaelGG 13y ago
I think it changes a lot of peoples thoughts about the question. It moves it from a "let's play with the concept of sound" to a basic question of induction and physics. At that point, why not ask how can we be sure the tree actually fell at all?
If you chase that rabbit hole, it probably devolves into arguing about what "know" and "is" and "sure" "actually mean".
- gabemart 13y agoI disagree. I don't think the original plays with the concept of sound, I think it plays with the concept of an objective reality. I don't think the thought experiment is substantially different in effect if it's changed to "does a tree fall in the forest if no-one is there to see it" or "does a tree have rough bark in the forest if no-one is there to feel it".
- rjknight 13y agoOr "do bears shit in the woods?"