3 ms·
I wonder if there was a bit of 'tech' clash with old school 'medicine' clash. Basically tech folks take the position of move forward and fix things that break,
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
I wonder if there was a bit of 'tech' clash with old school 'medicine' clash. Basically tech folks take the position of move forward and fix things that break, rather than wait until you are 99.999% nothing will break and then move forward. If that were the case, I could imagine a product manager getting incentivised to get the kits out the door and testing ramped up in spite of FDA reservations because 'hey it isn't like its something people take or anything.'
It would make an interesting short story (fiction of course) of a Doctor who invents a cure for cancer and starts giving it to people in his family who have cancer, and curing them but gets thrown into jail by a regulator, whose spouse dies of cancer during the clinical trials. The character conflict of someone who is doing the right thing at great personal cost, compared to someone who did the wrong thing for personal benefit, vs the overall 'right vs wrong' of the entire system. If someone picks up this story line add a thank you to me in the forward :-)
- cube13 13y ago> I wonder if there was a bit of 'tech' clash with old school 'medicine' clash. Basically tech folks take the position of move forward and fix things that break, rather than wait until you are 99.999% nothing will break and then move forward. If that were the case, I could imagine a product manager getting incentivised to get the kits out the door and testing ramped up in spite of FDA reservations because 'hey it isn't like its something people take or anything.' Replace "product manager" with "marketing exec", and I think you have it right here. The FDA's problem with 23AndMe isn't with the tech, it's with the marketing. The FDA has asked for studies proving that 23AndMe's marketing is correct, and so far, 23AndMe has not produced the results of the studies. This isn't anything new, too. Here's what the FDA said to General Mills about their Cherrios advertising in 2009: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheerios#2009_Drug_Claim http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheerios#2009_Drug_Claim
- micro_cam 13y agoThere is a somewhat proud history of Doctors self experimenting: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-experimentation_in_medicine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-experimentation_in_medicin...
- Crito 13y agoI doubt the FDA would find the time to care if the people at 23andMe were just sitting around diagnosing themselves like a bunch of hypochondriacs. Their interaction with the public is what has gotten the FDA's attention. There is a rather shameful history of doctors experimenting on others in an improper fashion.