6 ms·
This article is almost self refuting - objection (2) is killer. Immigration is probably the most important issue of our time. If we have a BI, we can't have im
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
This article is almost self refuting - objection (2) is killer.
Immigration is probably the most important issue of our time. If we have a BI, we can't have immigration in any form remotely resembling what we have today, let alone some ideal situation where we have drastically more immigration. It's as simple as that. The cost of a BI (and the welfare state in general, really) is that millions of people are stuck in Haiti, India, Afghanistan and other desperately poor locales.
http://econfaculty.gmu.edu/bcaplan/pdfs/whyimmigration.pdf http://econfaculty.gmu.edu/bcaplan/pdfs/whyimmigration.pdf http://dipeco.uniroma3.it/public/WP%20163%20Liberati%202012.pdf http://dipeco.uniroma3.it/public/WP%20163%20Liberati%202012....
I'm not an open borders activist. Most of the countries I mentioned are desperately poor due primarily to the people living there - any immigration policy needs to turn Haitians and Sudanese into Americans rather than turning the US into Haiti. But at the same time we need to recognize the tremendous humanitarian benefits of immigration.
If we prevent a Haitian person from selling his full time labor to an American employer for $7.25/hour, we are cutting his income by 90% (Haiti has a GDP/capita of $1300, cost of living adjusted). I can't see any benefits from a BI that would remotely justify doing this to millions more people. In fact, near as I can tell, virtually any policy which requires further restricting immigration is almost certainly a nonstarter for this reason.
A much better policy is the Basic Job, which is like Basic Income but you need to work for it (see FDR's CCC, jobs are things like improving public parks, planting trees, etc). This also has no disincentive effects and you get some productive labor out of the people who choose to make use of it.
- tokenizer 13y agoSimple solution, have X amount of savings, or a job lined up. I'd love your opinion on the merits of anyone else being allowed into a country without X amount of savings, or a job lined up.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoA glib response: I'd love your opinion on the merits of deporting unemployed Americans with $0 in savings to Liberia. More seriously, suppose we had no BI or other welfare state - what is the harm of allowing an Indian to show up in NY with no money or job? The only cost I see is that he might annoy 30-100 potential employers before he finds someone to pay him $7.25/hour to wash dishes, making him richer than 95% of his countrymen. He might sleep on the street for a little while. Now, there are real worries - he might eventually become a citizen and vote for Indian-style governance (see, e.g., the voting behavior of Mexican Americans), contribute to a corruption-tolerant culture, or other such things. But those are second order worries.
- tokenizer 13y ago> I'd love your opinion on the merits of deporting unemployed Americans with $0 in savings to Liberia. Don't import them and provide them with a basic income? I was just saying that while we'd actually have to review some other policies that would be affected, many of our policies are sub par at best, so I fail to see how either limiting immigration to X amount of people a year or simply paying them X a year is a fail for basic income. > What is the harm of allowing an Indian to show up in NY with no money or job? I'd rather look at MI as an actual citizen's benefit. Maybe a year wait from immigration? If our current policy is to bring people over who have no means of funds or help or work, and who require assistance, then IMO that's a bad policy. Also, what would be the largest difference between our current system and one where everyone who's lived in our country for a year, and is currently living in our country, gets X amount yearly? If you ask me, the risk for this person remains the same, and our obligations only begin once the person has established themselves within society at large by way of working or find assistance from family or friends or loans.
- klipt 13y ago> $7.25/hour to wash dishes, making him richer than 95% of his countrymen. Once you adjust for NYC's cost of living, he'd probably be poorer than his countrymen. Even a large percentage of Americans couldn't afford to rent an NYC apartment.
- Locke1689 13y agoTo bring your proposal into more modern times, how does it compare to the EITC?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoBy "proposal", I assume you mean Basic Job? If you can't find a job, you don't get EITC. A Basic Job means the government gives you a job if you can't find one. You show up, tell them you are unemployed, and they give you a job cleaning the DMV, filling in potholes, picking up trash at the park or whatever. At the end of the day they give you 8 hours x $7.25/hour. If you find a McJob paying $8.00/hour you quit the Basic Job and go take the McJob.
- nawitus 13y ago>Immigration is probably the most important issue of our time. If we have a BI, we can't have immigration in any form remotely resembling what we have today, let alone some ideal situation where we have drastically more immigration. It's as simple as that. The cost of a BI (and the welfare state in general, really) is that millions of people are stuck in Haiti, India, Afghanistan and other desperately poor locales. No. There are countries that have comprehensive social security and have immigration resembling what we have today - e.g. these countries have immigration that they already have.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoCould you explain how to have both a welfare state and a lot more immigration? How do you make the numbers work?
- nawitus 13y agoA lot more than what? One can have welfare state and a degree of immigration. Usually more immigration means that it's more expensive. Sweden has considerable immigration when compared to many other countries, and is also a welfare state. Immigration doesn't mean open borders.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoFor humanitarian reasons, it's important to get as close to open borders as we can. What benefits of a first world welfare state do we gain that are worth consigning a human being to live on $1300/year (the GDP/capita of Haiti)? Sweden is a pretty terrible example to cite. Go read the blog of Tino Sanandaji (an Iraqi immigrant to Sweden) - he does a great job showing why it's a failed policy and prevents some of the best arguments against immigration that I've read.
- nawitus 13y agoI didn't argue for Sweden's immigration policy - I argued that Sweden's immigration policy is possible.
- AnthonyMouse 13y agoThere is a simple solution to this: An immigrant can become a citizen but doesn't receive the basic income until they have been here for 25 years, but also doesn't pay income tax until the amount they would have paid in tax exceeds the amount they would have received from the basic income. Thus, the immigrants who would have been a drain on the system become breakeven and net productive immigrants see no difference in practice from any other citizen.
- chc 13y agoHow does having someone do busy-work in exchange for the basic income address any of the objections?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoObjection (1) - a BJ creates no disincentive for work. You can earn $7.25/hour at the BJ or $7.50 at McDs. Objection (2) - it reduces the incentives of immigration with the intent of collecting welfare, thereby reducing the objections to immigration. Objection (3) - due to the fact that it has no disincentives for work, and the economic cost will be far less than a BI ( I did some back of the envelope calculations here http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/basic_income_vs_basic_job.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/basic_income_vs_basic... ), it's far less likely to reduce growth than a BI.
- chc 13y ago> Objection (1) - a BJ creates no disincentive for work. You can earn $7.25/hour at the BJ or $7.50 at McDs. If the work they are doing has little value — which seems like it would have to be the case, since otherwise we'd already be paying all these people $7.25 an hour to do it — I don't see how it's substantially different from idleness. It seems like you're basically replacing "Do whatever you want and we'll pay you a basic income" with "Do a meaningless ritual as half-heartedly as possible and we'll pay you a basic income." In fact, I'd say a Basic Job program might disincentivize meaningful work more than a Basic Income. Somebody could start a business using their Basic Income, but a Basic Job would not provide the same opportunity.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoWith a BI you have three options while still getting paid - productive work, unproductive work or Halo 3. With a BJ, you have only two options - productive work or less productive work. Some of the people who would (given the option) choose Halo 3 will now choose productive work. That will be a net gain for society. Further, we will get some value out of the Basic Jobs. We might pay $7.25/hour for the DMV to be $3.00 cleaner, for a net loss of only $4.25 rather than $7.25. We tried this scheme once already and got a national park system for our trouble: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_Conservation_Corps http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civilian_Conservation_Corps It's also vastly cheaper than a BI because most people will choose not to use the BJ. Rather than giving $7.25 to 300 million Americans you only give it to 30-40 million.
- bryanlarsen 13y agoA lot of BI proposals pay the BI only to citizens. New immigrants aren't citizens; it takes many years to move from permanent resident status to become a citizen. This would create an underclass of immigrants & refugees, and create incentives for voters & politicians to make getting citizenship even harder than it is today. This is definitely not a good situation, but it is better than forcing people to stay in Haiti or Sudan.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThis is a possibility - but so far the US tends to not do this very well. I don't have great data on the subject, but I've seen at least one study suggesting immigrants with children tend to be a net drain on the US. http://cis.org/immigrant-welfare-use-2011 http://cis.org/immigrant-welfare-use-2011 Don't get me wrong - I'd love to do what you propose, though I think a BJ is a better policy than BI regardless of immigration. But I'm not aware of any western society that actually manages to do it.
- edraferi 13y agoThe linked article does not support your assertion that "immigrants with children tend to be a net drain". it simply says that the majority of this population uses at least one welfare program. it highlights low levels of education as the main driver of this, with the benefits usually going to the american-born children. I suspect programs like Head Start and the school reduced/free lunch program account for a significant portion of the reported welfare use. Do you think that a poor immigrant family with working parents that uses these programs is a "net drain" on society?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe linked article estimates tax liability for immigrant families and shows this is less than welfare consumed. Like I said, not great data, but I don't have anything better. If you do I'd love to see it. Given that Head Start doesn't even have any measurable benefits, I definitely think those consuming it are a drain (if they pay less in taxes than Head Start costs).
- dllthomas 13y agoA "Basic Job" is not a "much better policy" at all. Paying people to take care of our public spaces is worthwhile (and should be done regardless, and much is done regardless), but makework is a disease. With BI, I have assistance when I work on my startup or retrain for a different career or take care of my children or volunteer in my community - there's no bureaucrat judging my activities and deciding what is and is not worthy.
- lxmorj 13y agoWhat about a Basic Job for non-citizens, Basic Income for citizens?
- dllthomas 13y agoI am not convinced that BI and open borders are incompatible. So a lot of people move to the US - how is that harmful? Historically, increased immigration has lead economic happytimes. It's unlikely to get overcrowded; if the entire population of the world moved to the US we'd still be substantially less crowded than Singapore, and there's no freakin' way that would happen. If we find that BI has problems, we roll it back. If we find that the only problem with BI is immigration related, we can encourage other countries to implement it too - possibly coupled with aid, if they need it. I'd want to take a closer look before doing it, but it doesn't seem as crazy as common wisdom would suggest.