6 ms·
Diet Drugs Work: Why Won’t Doctors Prescribe Them?
- power2u 13y ago>The drugs work by suppressing appetite, by increasing metabolism, and by other mechanisms that are not yet fully understood. Why would FDA approve something which it we don't fully understand?
- return0 13y agoWe also don't understand the mechanisms of a very large number of the drugs we use (e.g. anesthetics).
- Coffeewine 13y agoBecause you don't need to understand the mechanism of a drug to have a strong understanding of the effects of a drug. Numerous widely proscribed psychiatric drugs have at best conjectured mechanisms of action.
- refurb 13y agoI think you'd be shocked by how little we understand about the mechanism of action of a lot of the drugs out there. The FDA's job is to ensure that approved drugs are (1) safe and (2) efficacious. Knowing the mechanism of action (MOA) of a drug can help further define the safety/efficacy parameters for a drug, but in it's absence you can still get a very good sense of the risk benefit analysis. The best example of a lack of understanding of drug MOAs is Lyrica (epilepsy drug from Pfizer). The drug was designed to target the GABAase enzyme. It got approved and then several years later it was realized that the main MAO is the drug's impact on the glutamate neurotransmitter, an entirely different MOA.
- pgrote 13y agoThere are many drugs where this is true. Antidepressants, especially. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pharmacology_of_antidepressants http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pharmacology_of_antidepressants
- johnward 13y agoI was going to say this. Most antidepressants are not really understood. Also I have central sleep apnea (brain forgets to breath when sleeping). They give me a machine but they don't know exactly why the machine helps but it does. It's approved for use.
- drzaiusapelord 13y agoBecause they're ultimately beholden to big business? I mean, we have no idea how many drugs work yet the FDA goes after 23andme and other organizations (selling stevia as a sweetner before they allowed it recently, etc), etc with questionable motives. I think there's an obvious double standard when it comes to big pharma. I'm not attacking the FDA per se, but the entire USG. It seems like the buck stops with congress and congress is simply beholden to their financial backers. It doesn't help that SCOTUS is largely conservative (money is speech, citizens united, etc) and the POTUS's direction of the FDA is mystifying as well.
- refurb 13y agoUltimately beholden to big business? Tell that to all the drug companies who have either had their drug denied by the FDA or pulled after approval [1]. [1]http://www.fda.gov/safety/recalls/ http://www.fda.gov/safety/recalls/
- drzaiusapelord 13y agoThey played the game wrong. There are counter examples of drugs that should never have been approved rushed to approval.
- refurb 13y agoI think my example is pretty good evidence that the FDA isn't "beholden to big business".
- drzaiusapelord 13y agoVioxx, Rezulin http://www.cbsnews.com/news/fda-whistleblower-resigns/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/fda-whistleblower-resigns/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Graham_(epidemiologist) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Graham_(epidemiologist) I hope no one you know is taking Avandia right now.
- 13y ago
- Symmetry 13y agoSo, what do you think would be the costs and benefits of waiting to approve a drug until we fully understood how produced it's intended effects? Clearly waiting until we understood every possible interaction for a drug would prevent any sort of mistake, but I'm not aware that we understand any drug in that detail. I hope you wouldn't suggest we abandon antibiotics because theres a chance that any given person taking one for the first time might have a unique allergic reaction. My best guess on the numbers is that waiting to understand all drugs mechanisms beyond existing testing would, over the course of the FDA's history, have saved dozens of lives at the cost of failing to save millions.
- spodek 13y agoMore relevant questions: - Why don't we stop subsidizing corn so much? - Why don't we teach effective nutrition and cooking in school? - Why don't we teach effective exercise, sports, and fitness in schools? - If we can ban alcohol and tobacco sales to children, why not things like added sugar, hydrogenated oils, corn syrup, etc? - If we can ban alcohol and tobacco advertising to children, why not products with added sugar, hydrogenated oils, corn syrup, etc? - Why don't we limit advertising on fast and junk "food"? - Why don't we provide healthy lunches to school children instead of using them to subsidize agricultural conglomerates for low quality food? - Why don't we stop subsidizing fossil fuels so much so people would walk and ride bikes more? - Why don't we align our medical system with prevention instead of expensive and risky cures? You can come up with plenty more questions that would mostly obviate the need to wonder about obesity and wonder drugs to cure it. The overwhelming majority of people would benefit from changes in diet and exercise requiring no chemicals needing FDA approval. Fresh fruits and vegetables seasoned with fresh herbs and spices taste better than anything, at least to me, and it's hard to eat too much of them. Few feelings feel better than the exhaustion of even moderate exercise. EDIT: reduced cynicism based on eli's welcome comment.
- eli 13y agoNot sure why you are so cynical. It seems like there's pretty clear progressive movement on several issues. I never thought I'd see a black president in my lifetime.
- thefuzz 13y agoI don't see him as being cynical. I think these are questions worth asking given that the OP is asking why diet pills aren't prescribed. It's looking at a problem in a systemic way rather than isolated events, at least according to me.
- awjr 13y agoAllowing the prescription of diet pills treats the symptom and not the cause. Anecdotally I've been overweight most of my life and it is only through a change in lifestyle (cycling to work and a shift to low carb diet i.e. low sugar) that I have seen significant weight loss. That's not to say prescription diet pills wouldn't work, but without underlying lifestyle changes I would expect the person to using the pills to be going on and off them for the rest of their life.
- brianbreslin 13y agoThis is an interesting issue. If you're morbidly obese, a 5-10% reduction in weight could add up to significant LBs/KGs lost. So it would seem to me like this would be a great way to jumpstart and re-enforce the other aspects of weight loss. Many people give up because they don't see results fast enough. So much of weight loss is mis-understood, but a lot of it boils down to convenience, will power (choosing to resist going through McDonalds drive thru), food choices (i.e. I don't know how to cook, and no healthy options are affordable and quick). I am a firm believer that weight loss is 75+% diet, and the rest exercise (disclaimer: I lost 30lbs [17% bodyweight] doing the 4 hour body diet).
- bryanlarsen 13y agoA major point of the article is that obesity is not a single disease, it is many different diseases. It might be one of various neurological, psychological, endocrinological or digestive problems, or a combination of several. Not surprisingly, cure or mitigation will differ from individual to individual based on the underlying problem. IOW, what works for you may or may not work for others.
- cLeEOGPw 13y agoI have the opposite problem - can't gain weight. Doesn't matter if I eat more or less, what kind of food, how many times a day and if I am training or not - it just stays the same no matter what. Recently it's been even worse - a simple 2 hour exercise would leave me with -1 kg and I had to wait like 4 days to gain back that 1 kg lost in one exercise. I think the hormones almost singlehandedly decides what you look like. I knew people that were obese and gained weight simply by drinking water and not eating anything. I thought maybe "survival instinct" would help me gain at least fat, where it supposedly activates when you are eating very little, and that is supposed to be the reason why not eating does not help fat people lose weight, but my weight even then just stays the same. I occasionally go for a whole day without eating (not intentionally) and never start to gain fat. It's really frustrating. Sometimes I just wish I could be fat and just go to gym.
- johnward 13y ago
- refurb 13y agoIf you want to see a biotech start-up working on a very interesting obesity drug, check out http://zafgen.com/ http://zafgen.com/ They just release the results from their Phase 2a trial and results are amazing. After 12 weeks on the highest dose, patients lost an average of 24 lbs, which is competitive with bariatric surgery. If the drug makes it to approval, it could be a real game changer for the healthcare system.
- wil421 13y agoBecause the markets have been flooded with either snake oil products or unproven chemicals like ephedra. Nothing is a replacement for diet and exercise. Diet drugs should be used in tandem with proper diet and exercise.
- hackinthebochs 13y ago>Nothing is a replacement for diet and exercise. I don't know why people say this. The benefits of exercise are simply initiating biochemical processes that cause your body to grow and become more efficient (drugs that target the SIRT1 gene are an example). There's absolutely no reason why we can't develop drugs that initiate that same process. Same goes for preventing fat accumulation. Claiming that there's no substitute is a cop-out and its an unfounded assumption.
- wil421 13y agoFor some people its simply an over indulgence problem. You could easily counter by saying why don't people just throw up after eating problem solved. Yet in my experience quick fixes often have other consequences that may not be immediately known. I don't believe you can simulate complex bio mechanical processes like muscle tearing but you may be able to allow you body to be more efficient when you do these things.
- tocomment 13y agoWould anyone be able to give or link to a summary of the four drugs it mentions? How would a person evaluate which would be the best one to try?
- memracom 13y agoHere is what Dr. Joel Fuhrman, M.D. has to say about weight loss: http://www.drfuhrman.com/weightloss/ http://www.drfuhrman.com/weightloss/
- tocomment 13y agoCouldn't another part of the problem simply be lack of marketing for these drugs? Everyone is aware there are goto drugs to toenail fungus and restless leg syndrome from all of the commercials. Shouldn't drugs like these that apply to even more people be all over the airwaves?
- refurb 13y agoThis is actually a relevant point. Both Qnexa and Belviq were only recently approved. The companies who got them approved are pretty small and don't have the backing of a massive pharma company to help them with marketing. In fact, the maker of Qnexa, Vivus, has had 3 CEOs over the past year and they are getting a lot of flack from shareholders over not putting in enough effort to market the drug.
- rubberband 13y agoI suppose it is potentially, but I have to assume that the people in the pharmaceutical industry understand which drugs they should market (and how, and when) to make the most money. To me it seems that "diet drugs" would basically print money from them, but my point is I believe there is a reason for them doing what they are doing, and that if they calculated they would make that much money, you better believe that they would pour truckloads of money into advertising. Still, it just seems so odd, given the rather... large potential market.
- gaius 13y agoBecause there's nothing wrong. The ability to store energy as fat is a natural survival mechanism. Your body doesn't care about looking good on the beach, it knows that Winter Is Coming and it's tooling up to deal with it.
- skittles 13y agoThe answer is simple. A doctor won't be sued for not giving an obese person diet pills. These drugs aren't very effective, and they have side effects such as raising blood pressure. A typical doctor will just tell you to be more active and eat less.
- 7Figures2Commas 13y agoIt's worth pointing out that "losing weight" isn't a panacea for health. Yes, it would almost certainly be a very good thing for significantly overweight and obese individuals to shed pounds, period, but the article doesn't address the fact that in and of itself this is unlikely to make them "healthy." There are lots of people who are not overweight who have many of the same cardiovascular issues commonly associated with obesity (high cholesterol and blood pressure, insulin resistance, etc.). If the goal is overall health and well-being, the title of this article is arguably misleading. Diet drugs might "work" when it comes to weight reduction, but it would be unrealistic to ignore the fact that without real lifestyle changes (diet, exercise), many of those who use them will likely be plagued by the same serious health issues.
- Killah911 13y agoFinally a well thought out comment. One of the big issues I see with obesity is that the problem is oversimplified, as are the solutions. I know of several people on whom counter-obesity problems have had a significantly detrimental effect. I've seen ineffective gastric bypass surgery which led to a friend gaining even more weight and watched helplessly as he slipped into a very depressed and negative state. As the article points out, if someone said there's a drug that just cures cancer it would be laughable. It is indeed so with weight loss. Phentermine will have minor side effects with impulse control, addiction, paranoia etc. Interestingly enough, obesity is typically not associated with the "poor" in the rest of the world. I have often heard it mentioned as an anecdote to how "wealthy" Americans really are. But therein lies a very interesting problem to which I simply haven't seen a very good answer. Unfortunately the sigtma associated with obesity and the well entrenched and highly profitable "weight-loss" industry gets in the way of significant advances being made in this arena. Again, as is mentioned in the article, there is even a stigma associated with "diet doctors", which surely has dissuaded more than a few brilliant minds to explore the field more. Ofcourse, as a programmer who is very familiar with a sedentary lifestyle and the pizza culture, obesity is a serious issues that does affect more than just the poor. And for crying out loud, I hope someone figures out more about it than pseudo science of obesity we have now. It's not as simple as it looks at first glance.
- gph 13y ago
- riahi 13y agoAnother reason that's not touched upon in the article is that many of these drugs are Schedule IV drugs. While prescribing a Schedule IV isn't theoretically more onerous than prescribing antibiotics, often pharmacy chains, insurances, and the government can combine to make busy primary care doctors less likely to prescribe them. I know many a PCP that rage at the fact that Phentermine is schedule IV, which adds extra complexity to prescribing it.
- Dirlewanger 13y agoArticles like these are so sad to see. They're on the same level of reporting how large the shit was of some celebrity's dog when a national crisis occurred the day before. If journalism isn't dead it's certainly being slowly strangled.
- pessimizer 13y agoBecause they "cause side effects and yield undramatic results." Doctors are protected from the consequences of prescribing statins and SSRIs because everybody else does it too. If you could get a critical mass of them to start prescribing diet pills by directly generating consumer demand, the floodgates would open. We're one good advertising campaign from everybody 5% overweight having a bottle in the bathroom - of a 'new' formulation of course, because I'm sure a lot of these are going out of patent. Then we'll find out that they really don't work any better than placebo and cause nerve damage, but the lawsuits will drag until all patents expire.