5 ms·
According to someone on Bitcointalk.org, it might not be as bad as it seems (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=358341.msg3832549#msg3832549 https://bitcoi
by olalonde 13y ago
According to someone on Bitcointalk.org, it might not be as bad as it seems (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=358341.msg3832549#msg3832549 https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=358341.msg3832549#ms...):
No. You Western guys completely misunderstood the news. To me, this is actually BULLISH!
TL;DR, the document says:
1. Bitcoin is a virtual commodity, not a real currency
2. People have the freedom to trade bitcoin, but they need to take their own risk
3. At this stage, financial institutions cannot denominate services and products in bitcoin, cannot trade bitcoin, cannot run bitcoin exchange, cannot provide bitcoin related services, cannot store bitcoin for clients, cannot establish bitcoin trust or fund, etc.
4. Bitcoin exchanges must be registered, and follow AML and KYC rules
This means major Chinese bitcoin exchanges like BTCChina will stay. You just won't see any Chinese bitcoin ETF anytime soon.
- Grue3 13y agoWhen is anyone at bitcointalk not BULLISH about bitcoin? It's not like they have a financial incentive to let it tank.
- dwaltrip 13y agoWhile many trolls and the like do roam bitcointalk, one can also find the occasional gem of rationality, insight, and common sense. Some people are there because, if you can believe it, they are actually intellectually interested in the complex and novel dynamics (sociological, economic, technical, etc) found in bitcoin (or that may potentially develop as the system grows).
- ashray 13y agoAlso, I'd like to add that most of the FATAL FLAWS (TM) that the mainstream press is discussing today were discussed in great detail on bitcointalk since 2009. It just happens to be a community that has had a great interest in creating and seeing bitcoin succeed. Of course, with growing numbers, the noise hides the signal, but take a look at the relevant subforums and you will indeed see serious discussions about bitcoin viability, previous challenges, future challenges, network security, scalability, etc.
- rplnt 13y agoSimilar what (some?) countries in EMU were saying. It's not a currency, you can use it at your own risk. Also you can't print/create physical representation IIRC, i.e. money.
- yapcguy 13y agoSame same but different. The PBOC has taken swift action, while other central banks have just been talking.
- politician 13y agoA physical representation of bitcoins (e.g. paper) would be terribly cumbersome.
- CodeCube 13y agoTo be clear, this already exists :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_protocol#Paper_wallets_and_.22physical.22_bitcoins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bitcoin_protocol#Paper_wallets...
- dgregd 13y agoSo in China Bitcoin status is equal to World of Warcraft goods (swords, shields, etc)? I mean WoW goods one can buy on eBay.
- vasilipupkin 13y agoSo, bitcoin prices plunge 20% on bullish news ?
- ekianjo 13y agoYeah, like for the Silk Road, until it bounces back with double its value in a matter of weeks. Bullish does not mean instantly bullish.
- jval 13y agoI disagree. This is not good news for Bitcoin. >3. At this stage, financial institutions cannot denominate services and products in bitcoin, cannot trade bitcoin, cannot run bitcoin exchange, cannot provide bitcoin related services, cannot store bitcoin for clients, cannot establish bitcoin trust or fund, etc. I don't speak Chinese so I can't speculate too much, but by the sounds of the Reuters article this basically rules out any hope of a Coinbase equivalent emerging in China, allowing people to transact freely between their bank and their BTC wallet. Banks in China aren't going to touch Bitcoin, or BTC-related businesses with a barge pole now. Not only this, anyone else planning on starting a Bitcoin business will probably have trouble with banks. It's really not good at all for BTC in China.
- pacofvf 13y agoI disagree with you, I think that it means that a chinese Coinbase can't also be a bank, and since they just ruled that bitcoin is not a currency, it will be sold and bought freely as a commodity in this case a virtual commodity
- alttab 13y agoTrading physical goods for virtual commodities? No thank you. The pudding of bitcoin was the promise of a new currency.
- pitnips 13y agoSince it's decentralized, it doesn't need banks to prosper. That's the beauty of bitcoin. It can function as a currency while still being seen as a commodity in the eyes of the law.
- fragsworth 13y agoYes - it doesn't need banks. I think there is lots of confusion as to how this system works. As long as it's legal to own and exchange bitcoins, everyone can be their own financial institution.
- steven2012 13y agoThis sounds like when the dotcom bubble burst, and the so-called experts were saying "No, this is a GOOD thing! All your favorite stocks are on sale!" The thing that propelled BTC from 200 to 1200 was the news that BTC was gaining popularity in China. If this news turns negative, then what is keeping the price high? Then again, given BTC has been so strongly bought up, if it gets bought up here, then it just means it will keep skyrocketing, since buyer sentiment hasn't changed one bit.
- yapcguy 13y agoTime to sell Bitcoin. Merill Lynch just said buy Bitcoin, setting a target of 1300 (I hate the way Wall Street pulls these numbers out of thin air, but they are on the sell-side). This is the same Merill Lynch who collapsed their own company with dodgy investments and had to be passed off to Bank of America, another company laden full of dodgy assets and dodgy accounting. If these guys say "buy", isn't it time to run? http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-12-05/bofaml-sees-bitcoin-fair-value-1300 http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2013-12-05/bofaml-sees-bitcoin...
- JamesArgo 13y agoYou can't extract intelligence from stupidity.
- pitnips 13y agoI worked in Treasury for a Fortune 500 with operations in 80 countries, responsible for FX hedging, and I can say that ALL banks are absolutely terrible currency forecasters. I can't blame them for being inaccurate, since there are so many variables that can impact an exchange rate between currencies, but it's important to note that forecasted currency rates have no merit.
- MichaelGG 13y agoBy taking the inverse of anything they say, you're implying that they have perfect prediction power (even if it's inverted). If you don't trust their predictions at all, then you should treat anything they say the same you would a random number generator.
- guiomie 13y agoI thought the value of BTC in china was that it enables ordinary people to workaround the current financial system. They say "It [BTC] represents an unofficial leakage to the current monetary system and trades globally" ... So, isn't a question of time before they ban the protocol in China ? I don't see why people use BTC in China, if it isn't for the freedom (workaround) that it gives..
- chatmasta 13y agoIt also means that in the interest of experimentation, the US will likely do the opposite of China.