5 ms·
Pretty disappointed in this statement from Greenspan: “It has to have intrinsic value. You have to really stretch your imagination to infer what the intrinsic
by ars 13y ago
Pretty disappointed in this statement from Greenspan:
“It has to have intrinsic value. You have to really stretch your imagination to infer what the intrinsic value of Bitcoin is. I haven’t been able to do it. Maybe somebody else can.”
All money has no intrinsic value, including gold. Things have value because other people want them. That's it. People want bitcoin, then it has value.
Pretty much the only thing with intrinsic value is food since people don't want it, they require it.
Everything else has value because people say it has value.
- namespace 13y agoThere is a great post on r/bitcoin on this topic by Erik Voorhees. He talks about the value of network which gives bitcoin its value. A great read: http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1rxmk3/my_open_letter_to_peter_schiff_followup_from_the/ http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1rxmk3/my_open_lett...
- ethana 13y agoNetworks come and go. Hard money, however, can still be found on hundred-years-old wreckage somewhere under the ocean.
- ars 13y agoThat's because you happen to value gold just like someone else did 100 years ago. But there are plenty of other forms of money that have vanished, from stone wheels, to shells, to papers. And all of those would be considered hard money.
- wavesounds 13y agoDollars have intrinsic value in that you can burn them to keep warm, gold you can make things out of, Bitcoins have no possible use outside of being a currency, thus no intrinsic value.
- throwaway2048 13y agonobody feels safer with money because of that fact though, and besides 80%+ of money is as purely electronic as bitcoin is these days.
- yk 13y agoThe heating value of dollars is a lot lower than the economic value. Same for gold.
- the_mitsuhiko 13y agoRight now, but there were cases of people burning their money before.
- wavesounds 13y agoI was just pointing out Greenspan's statement was correct. Obviously dollars have a higher extrinsic then intrinsic value. I think Greenspan's point was that just like with stocks you have to be careful investing in things that have low intrinsic values, ie a company that is valued very high but doesn't make much money. This is why people view gold as a safer investment then dollars, it has a higher intrinsic value.
- XorNot 13y agoDollar's are backed by a large hegemonic power, with control of its armed forces, which is capable of extracting taxes from its population. This makes them valuable, unless you expect the US government to fall shortly. Bitcoin does not have these features. It also does not have the normal features of a commodity (i.e. industrial uses). This means it has zero intrinsic value - nothing stablizes or enforces its value in anyway.
- BrokenPipe 13y agoI certainly can't burn the dollars in my bank account. Not directly anyway. I have to go somewhere and take cash out which then I can burn, assuming the bank has that kind of money available when I attempt it and assuming I will be allowed to take it out. Furthermore in many places such activity would be illegal. Anyone arguing about Bitcoin without admitting that there is demand and basing everything on outdated/flowed theories is bound to be wrong with their predictions.
- molf 13y agoIntrinsic value (in the context of finance) usually refers to the value of something when not used as investment or money. Gold has intrinsic value because you can use it for jewellery and electronics. A bitcoin has no intrinsic value because you only have it to get something else in return later. Physical money has intrinsic value equal to the metal or paper it's made of. Of course that is not what makes physical money valuable and I am equally confused by that quote.
- w0utert 13y ago>> Physical money has intrinsic value equal to the metal or paper it's made of. Of course that is not what makes physical money valuable and I am equally confused by that quote. USD/EUR/JPY currency (either physical as bank notes and coins, or electronic) has intrinsic value because it is almost universally accepted, taxable, and backed by debt that (at least in theory) will have to be repaid at some point in time. Bitcoin proponents like to point out that bitcoins are decentralized as if that's only an advantage of the currency, but it's the fact that commonly accepted currencies are centralized, controlled and regulated that makes them trustworthy enough that people keep accepting them in exchange for goods or labor. It's called 'fiat money' for a reason. Bitcoin has none of this, and the 'value' it derives from the 'trust' people buying them is based on nothing but speculation and hype. Anyone who thinks otherwise is fooling themselves. Disclaimer: I'm not 'anti-bitcoin', 'anti-cryptocurrency', 'pro-government' or a big fan of fiat money and how central banks are handling it. I'm just stating my observation how the bitcoin hype and echo-chamber has made people almost blind to see the risk it will some day go to zero (maybe soon)
- antocv 13y agoMore than that, bitcoin has intrinsic value in that it solves a very hard problem in computer science, to trust a network of perhaps untrusted peers (up to 49% of them). The protocol itself I would say is of same value as the idea to use paper for value instead of carrying around heavy metals. How come some paper has more value than other paper. Intrinstically they are the same.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jackgavigan 13y agoCurrencies that are legal tender have intrinsic value as a means of discharging debts. In particular, they can be used to pay tax.
- rajacombinator 13y agoWhy would you be disappointed? Greenspan's true colors are well known. (Hint: green not gold.)
- mkramlich 13y agoone response to Greenspan's statement: “[Congress|WallStreet] has to have intrinsic value. You have to really stretch your imagination to infer what the intrinsic value of [Congress|WallStreet] is. I haven’t been able to do it. Maybe somebody else can.”
- SkyMarshal 13y ago>Things have value because other people want them. That's it. People want bitcoin, then it has value. No, things have intrinsic value for an underlying reason. People don't just want random stuff out of the blue, there's always a reason. Look at it from first principles: Gold: Rare, soft, lustrous metal that interacts with our genetic programming in some strange, emergent way that creates a strong desire for it most humans' psyche. No rational reason, a reason nonetheless - people covet it, and as a result of that demand plus sparse supply, it has become a status symbol throughout most of human history and across all cultures that had access to it (Western, Mid Eastern, Far Eastern, South American). Also, better conductor than copper for some industrial uses. Money: Utility + Fiat. It's much easier to store your wealth in coins, bills, or bits in a bank computer than in cows, lumber, corn, or iron. Also much easier to transact exact amounts than in cows, lumber, corn, iron. And, doesn't die, rot, or go bad over time (inflation jokes notwithstanding). That convenience is desired, hence has value, which drives demand for it. There are also some things that only money can buy, or pay for - taxes, oil, etc. Everyone is required to have money for such things, hence demand for money is increased. Bitcoin: Solved the problem of trust in unregulated, no-central-authority, P2P transactions, eliminating the middle man, enabling people to save money on direct transactions while sufficiently mitigating the fear of fraud that would otherwise sink the whole endeavor (and has in past attempts). That utility = value = demand. Things that have value and demand, have it for a reason. It's not just b/c people randomly decide it does. That Greenspan can't see this merely suggests he hasn't spent much time trying to grok bitcoin. Didn't read the source code, didn't install it and play with it to learn how it works, doesn't read any discussion of it at bitcointalk or the btc blogs or anything. He's applying old world thinking to a new world of cryptocurrency, and hasn't adjusted yet.