3 ms·
Simple patch, in my mind: 1. Drop all interpretation of the results from the results pages. Instead, just spew out a bunch of semantically-tagged gene tables.
by derefr 13y ago
Simple patch, in my mind:
1. Drop all interpretation of the results from the results pages. Instead, just spew out a bunch of semantically-tagged gene tables.
2. Take all the interpretation map-data they have so far, and dump that into a FOSS Github project for a Firefox/Chrome Extension, which parses the results page and re-renders it into... exactly what it is now.
Bam. "23andMe" is no longer giving medical advice; some FOSS project is. (Even though the developers, individually, could be ongoing contributors to the very same FOSS project.)
This is actually probably for the better, either way. Other front-ends could make use of 23andMe's genetic-data "API", and the FOSS interpretation-map could be maintained by people (doctors!) all over the world.
- LogicX 13y agoBut you've just open sourced their entire value-proposition, which is that correlation part based on all the data. Mapping your DNA is now the 'easy' part, and offers them no differentiation and competitive advantage. (Ok, they still have lots of data to use to do their own lookups of all customers using the FOSS and improve that project, but again, they're adding value outside their company)
- derefr 13y agoI think that could still be tenable, if the marketing was rearranged so that the FOSS project was the initial point-of-contact for people looking for gene mapping (picture it as a whole app, rather than just an extension), and then it does lead-gen for "23andMe, the premium gene mapping service compatible with our gene explorer." The FOSS project still might get forked, of course... but as long as the 23andMe people are actually the leading experts in doing those correlational studies, their fork will stay the canonical/preferred one. Seems more honest. (Of course, no company wants to have to be "honest" in that way, but if the only other option being legislated out of existence, it might still be a profitable strategy.)