2 ms·
We have large projects under both BSD and GPL. We have different motivations for each, and the different licenses suit our needs. I'm always astonished by the s
by SwellJoe 17y ago
We have large projects under both BSD and GPL. We have different motivations for each, and the different licenses suit our needs. I'm always astonished by the self-righteous tone on both sides of the debate (though I find BSD extremists far more annoying for some reason...maybe just because RMS has inoculated me to the most obnoxious bits of GPL extremism).
And, yes, it is about who's in control; I don't see what's bad about that. If I wrote the code, I can exert as much or as little control over that code as I want...including making it more difficult for businesses to fork the code and distribute it under their own brand without giving back.
I have yet to hear about a BSD project that went under because of some company that refused to contribute back. I do however know of a couple of projects that thrived because of more liberal licenses.
This is a specious argument. One can point to dozens of GPL projects that have thrived because of the GPL; and none that went under because of something some third party did or didn't do.
Linux is one example of thriving GPL code, while the BSD-licensed competitors are dramatically less popular. Could it be because the BSD world forked off into dozens of competing commercial and free versions in the early days? Maybe. Maybe not. I dunno. But, for every BSD success story you'd like to trot out, I can trot out an equal number of GPL success stories. And, again, I'm a developer on projects that "prove" that both licenses are effective.
I can also assure you that the BSD projects see far less giving back than the GPL project, relative to total number of corporate users. When I worked as an IT guy, I regularly came upon server "appliance" products that used our software with a custom theme and heavy modifications, and we'd never even spoken to the company in question; the BSD permits that, and we aren't offended by that usage. It certainly isn't going to kill the project. But, in the case where we wanted more control, and had a very strong interest in that never happening because it would seriously impact our ability to build the products we wanted to build, we opted for the GPL license.
- bad_user 17y ago> And, yes, it is about who's in control; I don't see what's bad about that. I wasn't suggesting that there's something bad about it. I just get annoyed when people start talking about the freedom in GPL. > Linux is one example of thriving GPL code, while the BSD-licensed competitors are dramatically less popular In the case of Linux, I think we can all agree that a large part of its success is due to its creator that's a wonderful leader. 386BSD on the other hand had fewer contributions because of the strict development policies of its creators regarding external contributions. Of course, I'm not saying that the GPL wasn't a component of its success, but I think people overestimate its role in all this. After all, BSD is a lot more popular than GNU Hurd.
- billswift 17y agoFrom what I remember of what I read of the history of linux - it was the fact that BSD code was tied up in some kind of court case when linux was first introduced that allowed it to get a leg-up on the BSDs; because no one would risk basing anything on an OS that may not be available in the future.