3 ms·
You cut it off a little early: Editor John Cook told us that the screenshots did not, in fact, have any identifying information. “We didn't publish any identi
by untog 13y ago
You cut it off a little early:
Editor John Cook told us that the screenshots did not, in fact, have any identifying information.
“We didn't publish any identifying information about the source of the screengrab,” Cook says. “We don't know who sent us that shot, and neither does Uber.
Now, I can't say which one of the two is telling the truth, but at least give both sides of the story. Looking at the shots, I'm not sure what is personally identifiable, though the bookmarks bar could give some clues.
And Travis's threat of legal action might just be hot air from him (which isn't exactly unprecedented). After all, these numbers look very good for Uber. I wouldn't want to be one of their competitors trying to raise a round of funding right now.
- kmfrk 13y agoPrivacy isn't exactly binary, though, so the point still stands that you should probably not leak to ValleyWag. Privacy is like a game of 20 Questions where the adversary intends to hone in on the full identity. Regardless of whether the source is identified, it is still unfathomably sloppy on ValleyWag's part in protecting their sources.
- zavulon 13y agoLook at the comment to the article: > It's a shame when tech journalists don't understand tech. Of course, they outed their source. With the time stamp Uber can check which employees looked at that page at a particular time. They can then ask these employees [likely just one] whose computer they were using at that time to figure out who grabbed the screenshot and sold it to ValleyWag. So it's either VW didn't realize this, or fully realized it and still outed their source because they don't give a shit. Given their history of outing their sources, even after specifically being asked not to, I think the latter is much more likely.
- untog 13y agoWith the time stamp Uber can check which employees looked at that page at a particular time. I think it's a bit of a leap to assume that the Uber admin system logs every user pageview. It may well do, but many home-grown systems (and it certainly looks homegrown) don't bother with that level of detail. Certainly, if they were that security conscious you'd think they'd also avoid allowing any employee to see overall revenue figures.
- ars_technician 13y agoApache access log by default has this. Doesn't matter how crappy the upper layers are.
- untog 13y agoPage views, yes. User account used, no.
- jc4p 13y agoAssuming they're using Apache's basic logs wouldn't it be insanely easy to track down all URLs visited by that IP? After you login to Uber.com it instantly does a GET to /api/clients/[PERSUMABLY_USER_ID]?parameters which would be in the logs or they might have logs of user logins on their side (to show users a 'you've recently logged in from...' list somewhere)
- boomzilla 13y agoDefault web server set up would log all HTTP requests. It's trivial to see which (internal) IP addresses connecting around that timestamp.
- untog 13y agoIt wouldn't be an internal address. As the article states, an Uber employee logged on using their friend's laptop. I'd be surprised if they did that at an Uber office.
- dclusin 13y agoYou can subpoena ISP's to see who owned an address (I believe) up to 6 months back. How exactly do you think the RIAA filed so many lawsuits against internet pirates?
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThink that through, the Uber dashboard is going to be protected by a login regardless of the IP used. Somebody's login was used to access the dashboard at that exact time stamp which will be in the logs. And every web server logs this stuff as a matter of course, and every operations group keeps those logs to scan for unexpected accesses from outside the company or from former employees etc etc.
- KaoruAoiShiho 13y agoThere's no timestamp for view... it only says last updated. If it updates every 10 minutes many people could have seen it.
- maxerickson 13y agoThere is a discussion in the article between Techcrunch and the Gawker editor about the timestamp. What's weird is the editor hairsplitting between the source and the employee that happily helped the source access the data. I guess Uber might care about the intermediary, but I'm pretty sure they will be concerned about the actions of the employee.
- gojomo 13y agoThe personally-identifiable bit could be a watermark: slight coloration changes. It could also be the last-updated time, or particular numbers in a column... which would have only been served to a single account in a logged transaction. A company that cares about its proprietary information can easily log and/or watermark everything served via internal tools.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]