2 ms·
Amusingly enough, Wayland is already developing backwards-compatibility cruft even though it's not shipping anywhere yet. The core Wayland support for window cr
by makomk 13y ago
Amusingly enough, Wayland is already developing backwards-compatibility cruft even though it's not shipping anywhere yet. The core Wayland support for window creation and management cannot support minimizing windows, so it's being essentially obsoleted by an extension called xdg_shell, but xdg_shell isn't mandatory so applications and Wayland compositors will wind up having to support both.
- asabjorn 13y agoI thought things like xdg_shell grow up as either extension or in Weston, and then it gets merged into the stable Wayland protocol after it is battle tested and ready. Is this not the case for xdg_shell?
- toyg 13y ago>The core Wayland support for window creation and management cannot support minimising windows One of the problems with Big Rewrite projects is that, inevitably, early releases will never get feature-parity with the latest version of whatever it is that's being rebuilt. Managing expectations then becomes critical to avoid this sort of legacy-support nightmare.
- alexlarsson 13y agoThis is funny. You know that window minimization is not in the X11 spec either, right? Its something that X window managers handle internally (just like on Wayland where this is an internal compositor thing). Of course, desktop apps wanted to interact with minimization (read current state, etc), so the WM authors joined forces to create a spec that allowed this. See how it specs minimization here: http://standards.freedesktop.org/wm-spec/wm-spec-1.3.html#id2731936 http://standards.freedesktop.org/wm-spec/wm-spec-1.3.html#id... This is part of the "wm spec", and the thing corresponding to it in Wayland is called "xdg_spec", Both are produced by "xdg" (X Desktop Group) and are optional things that are used by "traditional desktop environments". It is a good thing that wayland does not enforce the existance of window minimization, because it is not always something that makes sense in all use cases of wayland. For instance in a phone like Jolla.