47 ms·
That's the wrong way to view it. The proper way is: will copyrighting APIs help our society? Will software developers have more of an incentive to make better A
by MichaelGG 13y ago
That's the wrong way to view it. The proper way is: will copyrighting APIs help our society? Will software developers have more of an incentive to make better APIs (assuming those benefit the general public) because of copyright?
Had there been strong copyrights, would Sun have made better date/time APIs? Would Microsoft not have ended up creating code that requires:
String.Split(s, new char[] { ',' }, StringSplitOptions.RemoveEmptyEntries)
To cut an unescaped CSV row?
I can't see any positive difference in the world by copyrighting APIs.
- mik3y 13y agoYou're right; to be clear, I also strongly don't believe that APIs should be copyrightable. But I'm nervous that there are at least a few ways to make the argument, to a layperson (like a judge or jury), and that Oracle might succeed eventually.
- MichaelGG 13y agoThat's because of the whole "intellectual property" concept. It moves the idea of copyright (and patents) from being an exception to free speech to being some sort of intrinsic fairness. Instead of looking at the tradeoffs with public interest, people start thinking things like "Well he did write it so he should control it. If he had made a chair instead of a poem, we wouldn't just steal the chair from him." In the process, the whole justification for IP is forgotten and we end up in bizarro world.
- josephlord 13y agoThat is a political argument against copyrightability though not a legal one. There is also the possibility of fair use arguments which probably could be decided by the court. Do remember that if you independently come up with the same API for a function without copying that is not infringement (copyright is not patents).