2 ms·
I think you're probably right. Disproportionate response only makes sense if it actually prevents future crimes. I would like to clarify the blurring of two d
by saalweachter 13y ago
I think you're probably right. Disproportionate response only makes sense if it actually prevents future crimes.
I would like to clarify the blurring of two disproportionate costs.
The first is the cost to the criminal. Assume for the sake of argument that in this case we're talking a trip to the police station, a $50 fine, and 10 hours of community service. Absurd for a $0.05 theft of electricity, but a limited sort of absurdity. The criminal is made to pay a disproportionate amount in restitution for his crime.
The second is the cost to the society. The cost of having a police man arrest someone for a $0.05 theft, jail him, take him to court, and supervise the community service. Hell, the cost to cash the $50 check for the fine is probably more than $0.05. The society pays a disproportionate amount to prevent a $0.05 crime.
These two separate costs have two separate objections. The first violates our inherent notions of fairness; the second raises the question of cost effectiveness.