3 ms·
You have a major flaw in your logic. There are 3 actors: S -- the security apparatus, the TSA, airlines, the state, the laws and rules they create, air marsha
by rdtsc 13y ago
You have a major flaw in your logic.
There are 3 actors:
S -- the security apparatus, the TSA, airlines, the state, the laws and rules they create, air marshals, NSA etc.).
A -- attackers
E -- everyone else, regular passengers
The flaw is that E is stupid, static, unable to learn form the past, need to be constantly protected by S.
A is smart, flexible, able to adapt and learn from mistakes ("ha we took X planes down, now we learned and we'll take X*5 planes down!").
S is also responsible, smart, it needs to act as a parent protecting and handling E. It also learns from the past, and if necessary it might impose arbitrary restrictions on E (security checks, black lists) in order to protect them from A.
You see the problem? Don't feel bad that is a very common mistake to make. Many people and the official reaction from S also follows the same logic (maybe you just internalized their PR?).
In fact not only did E learn better and was more effective, it has a track record to prove it. It immediately adapted (within hours!) and made sure to bring the plane down in a rural PA area not in NYC. TSA on the other hand, after years, billions of dollars and millions of man hours wasted still has not caught one single terrorist red-handed with a bomb ready to go off. (Granted other agencies from S foiled some plots). E has also been busy, they stopped Reid (the shoe bomber, if I am not mistaken).
Anyway, hopefully you see where I am going with this.