6 ms·
pensions are simply deferred wages, that is, money that workers could have taken as cash in their regular paychecks had they not opted to set it aside. That is
by dnautics 13y ago
pensions are simply deferred wages, that is, money that workers could have taken as cash in their regular paychecks had they not opted to set it aside.
That is not always the case. Often times in the public sector, pensions have undefined amounts (e.g. set to increase based on an annualized basis), and undefined terms (lifetime of the employee).
So here is another question. Knowing that the city was under dire financial straits, what business did the city have making new hires and promising them impossible compensation, that would result in passing the buck to the next generation?
- EliRivers 13y agoAlso, whilst I don't know how common it is in the US, every employer I've ever had in the UK has thrown into my pension as well, ranging from matching me pound for pound (up to a limit) to matching me two pounds per pound; I certainly couldn't have taken that as cash in my paycheque instead.
- ewams 13y agoIn the US it is generally called employer matching. This benefit is starting to be harder to come buy and some people are "grandfathered in" but many companies do have a matching plan to contribute additional money to an employee's 401k, 403b, pension plans, etc. Some do percentage matching up to a certain percentage of employee's pay. Other do percentage matching up to a certain dollar amount. Some do a hard dollar amount. Some do dollar amount or percentage matching based on years of service. Some do "as profits allow." Some do nothing. You are correct that this money is only to the retirement account, it would not otherwise be cash in hand at a paycheck.
- scpotter 13y agoGreat answer about employer contribution to 401k, etc, although I wasn't aware it was becoming less popular. I'm not familiar with the UK, but in the US there is one important distinction between a pension and individual retirement accounts like a 401k, 403b, IRA, etc. Most pensions are defined benefits, meaning they are not controlled or accessible to the individual, they are, which are a promise for the future with zero individual control. The other instruments are ultimately owned and controlled by the individual. You are typically limited to using the 401k your current employer offers if you want an employer contribution (which has a vesting schedule) and pre-tax investing, but when you change employers you can roll the money into another retirement instrument. The flip side is all responsibility for investment management, or even having retirement savings, is on the individual. Of course there are many people willing to help you manage it (for a fee).
- jmartinpetersen 13y agoI don't know how your private sector works, but it is perfectly natural for private pension funds in other parts of the world to offer those kinds of plans. You can exchange cash now for an insurance against living longer than you can otherwise afford. Normally, there's then governmental oversight that tries to ensure, that you can be sure, that the pension fund can actually deliver on their promise.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoWe have this in the US as well. ERISA and similar laws are the specific regulation. After ERISA and the like were passed, companies generally transitioned from defined benefit to defined contribution pensions since defined benefit pensions were too expensive when honestly accounted for. Government agencies (except for the USPS) are exempt from these regulations.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThis is the entire issue summed up. If pensions were limited in value to the amount payed in + any gains on the principal during the saving period. Then pensions would be simply deferred wages. Instead they are written as "some fraction of your last years wages" (common) or another formula which when applied against actuarial tables means that anywhere from 500 to 1000% of the 'money' that is paid out in pension wages will have to come from some other source. It is this that is the source of the great un-funded pension obligation California is looming under, and the one that did in Detroit. Once you cannot tax enough to pay the pension obligation and provide critical services, you are dead. There is no money, there is no exit other than to liquidate or restructure the pension obligation to something that you can pay. There is no 'stealing' here (unless you mean from working tax payers), there is simply a failed financial promise.